R v UGT HC Rotorua CRI-2011-263-000073

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

NOTE: ANY REPORT OF THIS PROCEEDING MUST COMPLY WITH S

438 OF THE CHILDREN, YOUNG PERSONS, AND THEIR FAMILIES ACT

1989. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION PLEASE SEE WWW2.JUSTICE.GOVT.NZ/FAMILY/LEGISLATION/RESTRICTIONS

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CRI-2011-263-000073

THE QUEEN

v

UGT

Hearing:         12 July 2011

Appearances: A F Pilditch and C H Macklin for Crown

A M M Schulze for Prisoner

Judgment:      12 July 2011

SENTENCE OF WHATA J

Solicitors:

Gordon Pilditch, Crown Solicitors, PO Box 740, Rotorua 3040

Lance Lawson, PO Box 2279, Rotorua

R V UGT HC ROT CRI-2011-263-000073 12 July 2011

[1]      UGT you are charged and have pleaded guilty to the offence of manslaughter. That offence carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment.

Relevant facts

[2]      This  is  a  tragic  account  of  the  loss  of  a  life  caused  by  alcohol  fuelled violence.

[3]      UGT you stabbed TT in the groin area while fighting with him.  He died soon after on your front porch.  He was a close friend to you, and on some accounts, your closest friend.

[4]      On the night of 20 August 2010, you, TT, your girlfriend and other friends had been drinking alcohol and smoking cannabis at your home.  You obtained this alcohol from your mother, among others.   It was a potent mix, with various altercations occurring between yourself, your girlfriend and TT throughout the night.

[5]      The fatal fight between you and TT followed from a heated dispute between you and your girlfriend.  At the conclusion of that dispute you had indicated to your girlfriend that you intended to commit suicide.   It seems that you then retrieved a knife from the kitchen area.   TT intervened in the hallway and this intervention progressed to a fight that ended up in a bedroom.

[6]      Your girlfriend and a boarder who lived in the bedroom tried to intervene in your fight with TT.  When the fight concluded, in a particularly poignant moment, TT hugged the boarder and apologised to her for an earlier blow that had happened in the dark while they tried to intervene. You have said that TT said he loved you.

[7]      At the end of the fight no one realised how badly wounded TT was until he left the room and it became clear that he had lost a significant amount of blood.  TT then went outside onto the doorstep at the address where he slumped over and died within a few minutes.  By the time the ambulance staff arrived, shortly after 10.00 p.m., TT was beyond treatment and was declared dead almost immediately.

[8]      UGT, you were distraught when you realised that TT was badly hurt.  You were heard to exclaim the words to the effect that the deceased, TT, was your best friend and that if he was dead that you would kill yourself.  You were then joined by your girlfriend, and to onlookers you both appeared almost hysterical.   You again mentioned killing yourself.

[9]      The police then took you into custody for your own protection.  While there you…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v UGT HC Rotorua CRI-2011-263-000073 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1872
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Rotorua Registry, heard the case of The Queen v UGT, a charge of manslaughter. UGT, who pleaded guilty, was sentenced by Whata J. The court examined the legal issues of determining an appropriate starting point for sentencing, considering mitigating and aggravating factors, and applying the principles and purposes of sentencing. The Crown argued for a starting point of seven to eight years, considering the use of a weapon as an aggravating factor. UGT's counsel, however, submitted that a starting point of six years would be appropriate, drawing comparisons with the case of R v Te Moana-Takao. After reviewing the facts and circumstances of the case, the court found that a starting point of six years was appropriate, taking into account the lack of premeditation and the personal circumstances of the offender. The court considered mitigating factors such as UGT's youth, lack of proper parental guidance, remorse, and participation in restorative justice. The court also accepted that UGT's early guilty plea warranted a discount of three years, resulting in a final sentence of three years' imprisonment.

Final orders:
UGT was sentenced to three years' imprisonment for the offence of manslaughter. Name suppression was extended pending submissions from counsel for the prisoner, with a call-over scheduled for 9:00 a.m. on Thursday, 14 July 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established