R v Teddy HC Rotorua CRI 2009-063-000697

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CRI 2009-063-000697

THE QUEEN

v

LYNETTE VICTORIA TEDDY

Hearing:         18 March 2011

Counsel:         F Pilditch for the Crown

M Simpkins for the Prisoner Teddy

Judgment:      18 March 2011

SENTENCING NOTES OF WYLIE J

R V TEDDY HC ROT CRI 2009-063-000697 18 March 2011

[1]      Ms Teddy you can remain seated until I tell you to stand.  Ms Teddy, you are one of a number of persons who were involved in a gang-related confrontation which occurred in Murupara in late January 2009, and which culminated in the death of Jordon Herewini.

[2]      Shortly after the trial commenced in October last year, you pleaded guilty to a count of participation in an organised criminal group.

[3]      Participation in an organised criminal group is an offence pursuant to s 98A of the Crimes Act 1961.  Although it has since been increased, at the relevant time, the maximum penalty was a term of imprisonment of five years.

Relevant Facts

[4]      Your offending arose out of a confrontation between the Mongrel Mob and local residents of Murupara, many of whom were members of the Tribesmen gang.

[5]      Mongrel Mob members arrived to attend a tangi in Murupara on or about Monday 27 January 2009.   Various members of the gang stayed in the town at Mr Terry Faataape‟s home for several days thereafter.   These members included Mr Pukeroa,  Mr  Aramoana  and  Mr  Iopata.     Tensions  between  Mongrel Mob members and local Tribesmen gang members gradually escalated, particularly after an incident in the township where Mr Pukeroa was assaulted by a number of locals. One of those locals was Mr Iwi Delamere.  Shortly after the assault, another local took Mr  Pukeroa‟s motor vehicle and it was later found burnt out near a nearby quarry.

[6]      Mr Pukeroa informed other members of the Mongrel Mob about the incident. As a consequence, gang members armed themselves with weapons and formed a convoy of vehicles to go after the people they believed were involved.  You drove one  of  the  vehicles  in  this  convoy  and  you  directed  where  they  should  go. Mr Delamere was spotted.  Mongrel Mob members believed he was associated with the events that had occurred.   They pursued him to his house at 43 Matai Street.

Mr Delamere escaped, but several Mongrel Mob members went onto the property, smashing windows in the house, damaging vehicles located on the property, and entering the house and smashing various items of furniture.   You were present, although you did not go onto the property or inflict any damage.  You got out of the vehicle you were driving and stood in front of the house encouraging the Mob members and you also became involved in a verbal altercation with Mr Delamere‟s partner, Wai Rurehe.

[7]      The Mongrel Mob members then went to another property at 10 Matai Street where one of the victims, Jamie Herewini, was attacked with a weapon, probably an axe.    Subsequently,  Mr  Pukeroa  got  into  Mahu  Herewini‟s ute  and  ran  down Jordan Herewini…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Teddy HC Rotorua CRI 2009-063-000697 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Lynette Victoria Teddy was convicted of participation in an organised criminal group, an offence under section 98A of the Crimes Act 1961. The case arose from a gang-related confrontation in Murupara, which resulted in the death of Jordan Herewini. Teddy pleaded guilty to her involvement in the events of January 2009, where she drove a vehicle in a convoy of Mongrel Mob members seeking revenge for an earlier assault. The court had to determine an appropriate sentence considering the purposes and principles of sentencing, the gravity of the offence, and mitigating factors such as her guilty plea and remorse.

The court established a starting point of two years and three months in imprisonment, acknowledging Teddy’s limited role in the events but considering the serious nature of the gang-related violence. Several mitigating factors were recognised, including her previous good character, genuine remorse, and active efforts towards restorative justice. The court also noted her late guilty plea, allowing for a discount. Consequently, Teddy was sentenced to 20 months in imprisonment, but the court opted for a less restrictive sentence of home detention and community work, recognising the importance of denunciation and deterrence. The sentence includes home detention for 10 months, with conditions such as abstaining from alcohol and drugs, and attending a drug and alcohol rehabilitation programme. Additionally, Teddy is required to complete 100 hours of community work and participate in any restorative justice processes organised post-sentence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established