R v Te Maari HC Nelson CRI-2011-042-001451

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CRI-2011-042-001451

CRI-2011-442-000017

THE QUEEN

v

DAVID ALAN TE MAARI

Hearing:         22 June 2011

Counsel:         M A O'Donoghue and S K O'Donoghue for Crown

M G Dollimore for Prisoner

Judgment:      22 June 2011

NOTES ON SENTENCING OF GENDALL J

[1]      David Alan Te Maari, you appear for sentence having pleaded guilty to the crimes of manslaughter, dangerous driving causing injury, two charges of driving whilst disqualified, being third or subsequent offences and driving with excess blood alcohol.  You entered guilty pleas on 20 April 2011 and were remanded to the High Court for sentence. The facts upon which I sentence you are as follows.

Background

[2]      It is necessary to go back to 20 January 2009 when you were convicted of driving whilst disqualified.  And you were further disqualified from driving for one year from 27 May 2010 and a “final warning” was given.  Up until then you had five previous  convictions  for  driving  whilst  disqualified.    So  that  was  your  sixth

conviction for such an offence.  But you knew better and were not going to learn.

R V TE MAARI HC NEL CRI-2011-042-001451 22 June 2011

So, undeterred, on 19 October 2010 you were stopped against whilst driving a motor vehicle in Richmond.  You initially supplied a false name and address in order to avoid apprehension.   That was your seventh offence of disqualified driving.   You were summonsed to appear in the Nelson District Court on 29 November 2010.  You pleaded not guilty and maintained that stance over the next two months.  But in the meantime, however, you continued to drive, whilst disqualified, whilst on bail, awaiting determination of that most recent offence.

[3]      As I have said, you were not going to learn until tragedy occurred.   It did when  you  committed culpable homicide, that  is  the unlawful  killing of another person.

[4]      On 16 April 2011 you were driving again with a front seat passenger at about

7.00pm in the Stoke area.  As I have said you were disqualified then and on bail. Your front seat passenger was Travis Russ, a good friend of yours.  You had drunk alcohol and you drove on the main road in Stoke at an excessive speed in a 50kmph controlled area, travelling north towards Nelson.  It was dark, the road was wet and there were other motorists using the busy highway.  You began manoeuvres which, I am  told  are known as  “drifting”,  where a  vehicle is  deliberately made to  slide sideways under power.  This was “hooning” behaviour, and you did it to show off as a form of bravado.

[5]      You had no thought of the danger you posed not just to your passengers but to other road users.  No doubt you thought you were invincible, or perhaps you gave no thought at all.   Your vehicle slid sideways into the path of oncoming traffic, colliding head-on with a vehicle containing the driver and a passenger.   The passenger’s side of your vehicle took the full impact of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Te Maari HC Nelson CRI-2011-042-001451 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1557
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved David Alan Te Maari who pleaded guilty to several charges including manslaughter, dangerous driving causing injury, driving whilst disqualified, and driving with excess blood alcohol. The court had to determine appropriate sentences for these offences. The key legal issues were the sentencing principles for motor manslaughter, the aggravating and mitigating factors, and the imposition of a non-parole period. The court considered the consumption of alcohol, excessive speed, deliberate bad driving, prior convictions, and the impact on the victims. Aggravating factors included Te Maari's multiple serious convictions, particularly for driving whilst disqualified, and his status as a recidivist offender. Mitigating factors were limited to his early guilty plea and remorse. The court fixed a starting point of seven years six months' imprisonment, adjusted for aggravating and mitigating factors, resulting in an effective sentence of six years two months' imprisonment on the charge of manslaughter. The court also imposed disqualifications from holding or obtaining a driver's licence and issued a warning under the three strikes legislation.

The final orders included the sentence of six years two months' imprisonment, a five-year disqualification from holding or obtaining a driver's licence, and a first warning under the Sentencing Parole Reform Act 2010. The court also considered the Crown's request for the confiscation of Te Maari's motor vehicle registration number and invited the parties to submit memoranda on the matter.