R v Tait HC Hamilton CRI-2010-070-5571

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CRI-2010-070-5571

THE QUEEN

v

MURRAY DAVID TAIT

Hearing:         30 June 2011

Appearances: G Hollister-Jones and H Booth for the Crown

J Bergseng and M McCarty for the Accused

Judgment:      30 June 2011

ORAL JUDGMENT OF PRIESTLEY J (S 344A Application of Accused)

Counsel/Solicitors:

G Hollister-Jones, Crown Solicitors, Tauranga Central 3141. Email: ghollister-jones@rhjl.co.nz
H M Booth, Crown Solicitors, Tauranga Central 3141. Email: hbooth.rhjl.co.nz

J Bergseng, Bergseng & Co Lawyers, Auckland. Email: john@bergseng.co.nz

M McCarty, Barrister, Tauranga Email: maryann@mccartys.co.nz

R V TAIT HC HAM CRI-2010-070-5571 30 June 2011

[1]      The defence has made an application under s 344A of the Crimes Act 1961. That application is to call expert opinion evidence from a reputable consultant psychiatrist, Dr S Kumar, who practises in Rotorua.   Dr Kumar is frequently instructed by this Court to prepare reports under relevant mental health legislation and I do not perceive there is any attack or challenge to his professional qualifications.

[2]      The evidence which defence counsel seeks to call (the Crown being opposed to it), is contained in an eight page, undated, brief of evidence which defence counsel filed in court earlier this week.  That report is supplemented by a further three page report dated today in which Dr Kumar deals with three supplementary questions.

[3]      It is unnecessary for me to set out in any great detail the contents of Dr Kumar’s brief.  In essence he concludes that the accused can properly be diagnosed as having developed an obsessive compulsive personality disorder (OCPD) during his adult years, possibly following his involvement in a motor accident.

[4]      The relevant personality traits constitute the preference of people suffering from OCPD to live rigid, regimented, and predictable lifestyles.   In Dr Kumar’s typical experience such people frequently have a lowered ability to tolerate frustration.

[5]      Supplementing his brief in today’s report Dr Kumar opines that the accused falls into an OCPD sub-type, being “Parsimonious Compulsive”.  Characteristics of this sub-type are being miserly, tight-fisted, hoarding, protecting against loss, fearful of intrusions, and dreading exposure.

[6]      Significantly, as I shall say later, on the ultimate issue of this trial Dr Kumar, under  the  heading  “Risk  Assessment”,  sees  no  necessary  connection  between violence and OCPD.  He places the accused in a population of individuals with a low or minimal risk of violence and opines that, on balance, the accused’s risk of committing a violent offence would have to be considered minimal.

[7]      Mr Bergseng tells me that Dr Kumar is of the view that he can say nothing about the central issue of this trial, murderous intent, and will not be commenting on that.

[8]      It is very clear from the authorities that judges must act as the gate-keeper on not only admissibility issues, which entail an assessment of relevance, but also on whether  opinion  evidence,  which  Dr  Kumar’s  evidence  would  constitute,  can properly be admitted.

[9]      Relevant provisions of the Evidence Act 2006 are as follows:

7        Fundamental principle that relevant evidence admissible

(1)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Tait HC Hamilton CRI-2010-070-5571 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1562
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of R v Tait involved Murray David Tait, who was charged with the murder of his father. The court heard an application by the defence to call expert opinion evidence from Dr S Kumar, a consultant psychiatrist, to testify regarding Tait's mental health condition. The Crown opposed the application, arguing that Dr Kumar's evidence was not relevant to the central issue of the trial, which was Tait's intent to commit murder.

The legal issues before the court were whether Dr Kumar's evidence was relevant under the Evidence Act 2006 and whether it was likely to offer substantial help to the jury in understanding other evidence or ascertaining facts of consequence to the determination of the proceeding. The court considered the relevance of Dr Kumar's opinion on Tait's obsessive compulsive personality disorder (OCPD) and whether it could assist the jury in understanding Tait's odd behaviour and increased hostility towards his parents.

Priestley J concluded that Dr Kumar's evidence was relevant and could offer substantial help to the jury in understanding Tait's odd behaviour. However, the court ruled that Dr Kumar was not to give any evidence or speculate on the central issue of the trial, which was Tait's capability of forming a murderous intent on the day of the homicide. The court also excluded Dr Kumar's opinion on Tait's level of tolerance to frustration, as it was based on statements made by Tait months after the homicide and was at variance with other evidence.

The final orders of the court were that Dr Kumar's evidence was admissible within the confines outlined by the court, and it could assist the jury in understanding Tait's odd behaviour and increased hostility towards his parents. However, Dr Kumar was not to give any evidence or speculate on the central issue of the trial, which was Tait's capability of forming a murderous intent on the day of the homicide.