R v Swann HC DN CRI 2009 412 26

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CRI  2009 412 26

REGINA

v

MICHAEL ANDREW SWANN

Hearing:         11 February 2010

Appearances:  R P Bates and A Killeen for Crown

H T Young for Prisoner

Judgment:      11 February 2010

REMARKS ON SENTENCE OF CHISHOLM J

[1]       Andrew Michael Swann,  you have pleaded  guilty  to  breaching  s4  of  the

Secret Commissions Act 1910.  The maximum penalty, as you are probably aware, is two years imprisonment or a fine of up to $1,000.

[2]      Between  6  January  2000  and  11  September  2006,  during  which  time  you were  employed  in  a  senior  position  with  the  Otago  District  Health Board, you received from Robin Sew Hoy a total of $755,153.89 in  relation  to  help  desk services provided by Mr Sew Hoy.  There were 85 payments.  In substance, for every hour  that  was  being  charged  to  the  Board  by  Mr  Sew  Hoy  at  $95  per  hour,  you received $25 per hour.

R V SWANN HC DUN CRI  2009 412 26  11 February 2010

[3]      On 19 November 2009 Mr Sew Hoy was sentenced by Fogarty J on a similar charge.   The Judge started at 18 months imprisonment, allowed a 10% discount for mitigating factors, including a guilty plea, and in the end result imposed a sentence of 10 months home detention.

[4]      You are 48  years of age, married  with four  children.   Your family are still supportive  of  you.   Currently  you  are  serving  a  sentence  of  nine  and  a  half  years imprisonment  for  another  fraud  against  the  Board  involving  $16.9  million. That offending occurred over roughly the same period as the offending for which you are to be sentenced today.

[5]      At sentencing on 11 March 2009 Stevens J observed that the other offending involved significant planning and premeditation, breaches of trust and abuse of your position.   He started at 10 and a half years imprisonment and allowed a discount of one year to reflect your (as he described it) relatively clear record, your remorse and attempts to reach agreement in relation to reparation.

[6]      For present purposes I approach the matter on the basis that the only relevant offending is the offending against the Health Board.  As Stevens J accepted, the only previous offending involving dishonesty was at the lowest end of the scale.

[7]      The impact on the Board has been huge.   You held a position of power and influence and the damage that has resulted from your offending has been extensive and is ongoing.   The reparation report from the  Board’s chief executive notes that while a financial settlement was reached with Mr Sew Hoy, no offer has been made, or is expected, from you.

[8]           As far as the aggravating factors are concerned, I list them as these:  first, at the  time  of  this  offending  with  Mr  Sew  Hoy  you  were  also  offending  against  the Board  with  another  person  (Mr  Hartford); secondly,  a  large  sum  of  money  was involved in this offending;   thirdly, it was over a lengthy period;   and, fourthly,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Swann HC DN CRI 2009 412 26 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court of New Zealand involved a defendant, Michael Andrew Swann, who pleaded guilty to a breach of the Secret Commissions Act 1910. Swann was found to have received $755,153.89 from Robin Sew Hoy, relating to help desk services provided by Sew Hoy. The court was tasked with determining an appropriate sentence, taking into account aggravating and mitigating factors, the starting point for sentencing, the discount for a guilty plea, and the question of whether the sentence should be concurrent or cumulative with a prior sentence. The court also considered the issue of reparation.

The primary legal issues involved the determination of the starting point for sentencing, the discount for a guilty plea, and whether the sentence should be concurrent or cumulative with the defendant's existing sentence. The court considered whether the defendant's breach of trust and abuse of his position warranted a different starting point compared to a similar case, as well as the applicability of a discount for a guilty plea. The court also weighed the arguments for concurrent versus cumulative sentencing, taking into account the totality principle.

The court determined that the starting point for sentencing should be two years due to the significant breach of trust and abuse of position by the defendant. The court accepted the Crown's submission on the starting point, despite the defence counsel's argument for an 18-month starting point. The court also accepted that the defendant was entitled to a 10% discount for his guilty plea, reducing the starting point from 24 months to 20 months. Regarding the issue of concurrent or cumulative sentencing, the court decided on a concurrent sentence, finding that the totality principle would be offended if the sentence was cumulative. Finally, the court found that there was insufficient information to determine the reparation issue and adjourned the matter for six months.

The court ordered that Swann serve 20 months imprisonment, which would run concurrently with his existing sentence of nine and a half years. The reparation issue was adjourned to 30 June 2010 for further consideration.