R v Sullivan HC Wellington CRI 2009-485-86

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI 2009-485-000086

THE QUEEN

v

SHAUN MIHAKA SULLIVAN ANDREW DEAN KUPA-CAUDWELL RANGITERA SPENCER WALKER

Counsel:         T Gilbert and V Brewer for the Crown

C Stevenson and L Hall for Sullivan
P V Paino and M Lillico for Kupa-Caudwell
G King and L Elder for Walker

Date:              10 February 2010

SENTENCES OF WILD J

Introduction

[1]      The three of  you appear this afternoon for sentence following a three week trial before a jury in this Court last November.

[2]      The jury found you Mr Sullivan, and you Mr Walker, guilty of murdering Mr

Paul Irons.

[3]      Mr Sullivan and Mr Walker, the two of you should know at the outset that the minimum sentence for murder is 10 years imprisonment.

R V SULLIVAN AND ORS HC WN CRI 2009-485-000086  10 February 2010

[4]      The jury found you, Mr Kupa-Caudwell, guilty of manslaughter.  There is no minimum sentence for manslaughter.  But you are liable to life imprisonment.

What happened

[5]      On the night of 8 October 2008 the three of you were at a party at a house in Featherston. All  three  of  you  were  drinking,  and  two  of  you  had  been  drinking before going to the party.

[6]           You, Mr Sullivan, were very drunk. You acted aggressively toward people at the  party, which was a birthday party for  two  young  men. One  of  them  was  Mr Wirihana  Wright. You  punched Mr Wright in  the  nose  with  a  closed  fist  after accusing him of stealing your beer.  You were seen to stand over some of the young women at the party in a way that they told the jury scared them, and you were seen to rummage through their handbags looking for cigarettes.

[7]      Mr Walker, you were also very drunk at the party.  At one stage the man you murdered,  Mr  Irons,  arrived  at  the  party.  It  seemed  to  be  generally  known  in Featherston that Mr Irons had a drug problem, and at one stage he offered you some pills.   It seems he had syringes and perhaps other drug paraphernalia in the bag he was carrying.   Mr Walker, you were overheard to threaten Mr Irons:   “Don’t bring that shit here – I’ll smash your fucking face in”.

[8]      At about 12.30 in the morning the three of you and two other young men left the party in a group.   The five of you walked through Featherston, heading toward the centre, which is on Fitzherbert Street.

[9]      As the group approached Fitzherbert St you, Mr Kupa-Caudwell, were out in front. As you were walking through the Cherry Tree Gardens, you heard someone shouting and yelling and a man came running across Fitzherbert St and ran  up  to you.  This was Mr Irons.  He came right up to you and it seems he may have grabbed at  your  arms.   Mr  Kupa-Caudwell,  you  responded  by taking  a  swing  at  Mr  Irons, possibly two swings.  You told the Police you did that because you felt intimidated.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Sullivan HC Wellington CRI 2009-485-86 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 257
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard the case of the Queen v Sullivan and others where the defendants were sentenced for their involvement in the death of Mr Paul Irons. Shaun Mihaka Sullivan and Rangitera Spencer Walker were found guilty of murder, while Andrew Dean Kupa-Caudwell was found guilty of manslaughter. The court had to determine the appropriate sentences for each defendant, taking into account their individual circumstances, roles in the offence, and the seriousness of their actions. The judge considered the defendants' backgrounds, their level of involvement in the offence, and the impact of their actions on the victim and the community. The judge imposed a sentence of life imprisonment with a minimum term of 12 years for Sullivan, reflecting the seriousness of the offence and the need for accountability, denunciation, deterrence, and protection of the community. Walker received a sentence of life imprisonment with a minimum term of 11 years, taking into account his age, lack of previous convictions, and remorse. Kupa-Caudwell was sentenced to 6 years imprisonment with a minimum term of 3 years, acknowledging his lesser role in the offence and the impact of his cancer on his behaviour at the time.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established