This case has been anonymized
IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WANGANUI REGISTRY
CRI-2008-483-000032
THE QUEEN
Applicant
v
R
Respondent
Hearing: 9 February 2009 (Heard at Wellington)
Counsel: L C Rowe for applicant
D M Goodlet for respondent
Judgment: 13 February 2009
RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J
[1] This was an application on behalf of the Police for consent to present an indictment under s 345(3) of the Crimes Act 1961 in respect of an offence alleged against Mr R
[2] Mr R was charged in the District Court at Taihape with intentionally and without claim of right damaging by fire a motor vehicle, contrary to s 267(1)(b) of the Crimes Act 1961. The vehicle was a 1997 Subaru owned by Ms Kerri-Jo Te Huia, the partner of one Mark Bowsher. Following a preliminary hearing,
Justices of the Peace discharged Mr R .
R V R HC WANG CRI-2008-483-000032 13 February 2009
[3] The background to the alleged offending is that Mr R was involved in a fight in a Taihape bar on the evening of 12 April 2008, when Mr Bowsher intervened and broke the fight up. Mr Bowsher’s intervention led to a confrontation between the two that continued outside the bar, and then Mr Bowsher and Ms Te Huia returned to their home in Swan Street, Taihape.
[4] Shortly before 7am on the following morning, 13 April 2008, Mr Bowsher and Ms Te Huia became aware that Ms Te Huia’s vehicle, which was parked outside their residence, had been set alight. Mr Bowsher observed a person leaving the vicinity, who was walking away from him in a hooded garment with the hood up. The person got into a black station wagon vehicle. Mr Bowsher’s recollection was that the vehicle was most likely a Subaru, or alternatively a Mitsubishi Legnum.
[5] There was also evidence at the preliminary hearing from a street cleaner, Ms Larsen, who gave evidence as to two sightings of Mr R on the morning in question. First, at about 5.30am when she was clearing rubbish bins in the main street of Taihape, a black station wagon passed her two or three times. On one of the occasions she identified Mr R as the driver, he being a person known to her since he was a child.
[6] Secondly, at about 7am Ms Larsen heard a vehicle travelling at speed and saw the same vehicle as she had seen earlier fishtail out of the road connecting Swan Street with the main thoroughfare through Taihape. Again she was able to positively identify Mr R as the driver. At one point when the vehicle slowed, as Ms Larsen described it, she looked at the driver and he looked back at her.
[7] Other evidence at the hearing included the Police finding the remnants of fish and chips near the burning vehicle, when the staff at the only outlet that was serving fish and chips the previous evening had not seen Mr R purchasing fish and chips. It…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v R HC Wanganui Cri-2008-483-32 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NZHC 130
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the evidence presented during the preliminary hearing was sufficient to support a conviction if the case were to proceed to trial. The court had to determine whether the evidence, when viewed in the context of what a properly directed jury could decide, established the requisite elements of the charge beyond reasonable doubt. The court also had to assess whether the Justices who discharged Mr R had applied the correct legal test in making their decision.
The High Court, in granting the Police's application, found that the Justices had likely erred in their reasoning by adopting the wrong legal test. Instead of determining whether there was sufficient evidence for a jury to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt, the Justices seemed to have assessed the evidence themselves as if they were the fact-finders. The High Court noted that the evidence, particularly the identification of Mr R by a street cleaner as the driver of a black station wagon seen near the crime scene, was compelling enough to support a conviction if accepted by a jury. The court concluded that the evidence was sufficient for a properly directed jury to find the requisite elements of the charge proven beyond reasonable doubt.
The High Court granted the Police's application and directed that the indictment be filed in the District Court at Taihape. The decision underscores the importance of applying the correct legal test in committal proceedings and highlights the role of circumstantial evidence in criminal prosecutions.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi