This case has been anonymized
IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY
CRI 2009-419-4
R
Applicant
v
THE POLICE
Respondent
Hearing: 10 February 2009
Appearances: J Buckle for applicant
A M Beveridge for Crown
Judgment: 10 February 2009
JUDGMENT ON BAIL APPEAL OF ALLAN J
Solicitors/counsel :
J Buckle james.buckle@wave.co.nz
Crown Solicitor Hamilton
R V POLICE HC HAM CRI 2009-419-4 10 February 2009
[1] Mr R appeals against the refusal of bail in the District Court at Taumaranui on 15 December 2008. On that occasion Judge Radford declined bail pending a hearing of charges against the appellant of:
a) Common assault;
b)Intentional damage; male assaults female and breach of a protection order; and
c) Breach of a protection order.
[2] All of the offences except for the common assault charge relate to the same complainant.
[3] Mr R appeared at a status hearing on 9 December 2008 and pleaded not guilty to all the charges.
[4] The common assault charge was set down for hearing on 15 December 2008. On that day the appellant was acquitted. An application for bail on the remaining charges was made but Judge Radford declined bail.
[5] A hearing was scheduled on 15 January 2008 on the single charge of breach of a protection order, but it was adjourned because the appellant was ill. The current position is that that charge is scheduled to be heard on 11 March 2009, and the remaining charges are to be heard tomorrow, 11 February 2009. All hearings are in the Taumaranui District Court.
[6] Mr R appeals against the refusal of Judge Radford on 15 December to grant him bail. The primary argument advanced by Mr Buckle today is that even at that stage, on 15 December, the appellant had served a longer sentence than was likely to be imposed if he was found guilty on the outstanding charges. Of course, if Mr Buckle is right, the position has been exaggerated by the passage of time since the decision under appeal was made.
[7] Mr R has now been in custody for some four months, he having initially been granted bail, but having been remanded in custody in October following a breach of the condition as to the consumption of alcohol.
[8] In my opinion, this appeal is meritorious in that, putting matters at their worst for the appellant, and assuming he is convicted on all of the outstanding charges, it is unlikely he would face a sentence of more than eight months imprisonment, which is the equivalent of four months time served. In making that observation, I do not of course in any way purport to fetter the discretion of the Judge or Judges hearing the remaining charges.
[9] This morning, Ms Beveridge has outlined something of the recent history of the appellant. Plainly he has an alcohol problem. There have been recent convictions for assault and breaches of a protection order. On those occasions, the appellant has been treated relatively leniently, which suggests…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Police HC Hamilton CRI 2009-419-4 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NZHC 84
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue in this case was whether Mr. R should be granted bail, considering that he had already served four months in custody and that the maximum likely sentence for the remaining charges was eight months imprisonment. The Court had to decide whether Mr. R should continue to be held in custody or granted bail based on the circumstances and the potential sentence.
The Court considered the applicant's recent history, including his alcohol problem and recent convictions for assault and breaches of a protection order. The Court acknowledged that the applicant had been treated relatively leniently on those occasions, suggesting that the offences concerned did not fall towards the top of the scale. The Court concluded that it was not appropriate for persons facing criminal charges to serve any sentence of imprisonment to which they were likely to be subjected on remand. The Court allowed the appeal and granted bail subject to the specified conditions.
The final orders of the Court were that Mr. R was granted bail subject to the following conditions: he was to reside at a specified address, not associate or communicate with the complainant, report to the police station on certain days, not possess or consume alcohol or illicit drugs, undergo a breath screening test upon request, and be curfewed on the night of 10-11 February 2009. The Court emphasized that if the appellant was convicted on any of the charges, the question of bail would arise afresh and be a matter for the presiding Judge.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi