R v McDonald HC Whangarei CRI-2011-088-3522

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CRI-2011-088-3522

THE QUEEN

v

JOHN GILBERT MCDONALD

Counsel:         M A Jarman-Taylor for Crown

J S Day for Prisoner

Judgment:      5 September 2011

SENTENCING NOTES OF BREWER J

SOLICITORS/COUNSEL

Marsden Woods Inskip & Smith (Whangarei) for Crown

John Day (Whangarei) for Prisoner

R V MCDONALD HC WHA CRI-2011-088-3522 5 September 2011

Introduction

[1]      Mr  McDonald,  you  appear  for  sentence  on  one  charge  of  cultivation  of cannabis  (which carries  a maximum  penalty of seven  years’ imprisonment)  and possession of cannabis for sale (which carries a maximum penalty of eight years’ imprisonment).

Facts

[2]      On 3 June 2011 the Police searched your address and vehicle.  In the vehicle the Police found 14 cannabis tinnies, a one-ounce bag of cannabis head, a pipe and a spotting knife. The total weight of cannabis located was 41.21 grams.

[3]      You advised that you were moving house and the Police searched your new address.  They located a shed at the rear of the property which had been converted into  a cannabis  growing room.    Inside  the shed were 48  small  cannabis  plants ranging from 150-200mm.   The plants were growing in planter bags under grow lights.  They were healthy and in good condition.  The grow lights and heat shields were attached to a timer which was set on a 12-hour cycle; two ballast boxes to regulate power to the shed were attached to a multi-plug in the wall of the shed; and an extractor fan and attached ducting had been constructed in the roof to ventilate the shed.  The inner walls of the shed had been lined with reflective paper to maximise the growing conditions for the plants.  The power source to the shed and grow room was supplied by an extension cord which had been buried in a direct line from the house.  The extension cord had been run from underneath the floor of the house and was attached to a power outlet in the laundry.

[4]      Inside your home the Police found a roll of tin foil, digital scales, a sealable plastic bag containing cannabis residue, and a small amount of cannabis plant material.

[5]      In explanation you told the Police that you had bought two one-ounce bags of cannabis and that you had made the tinnies to sell, although you said that you had

not yet sold any of them.  You said that you are also a user of cannabis and that the cannabis pipe and spotting knife were for your own use.

[6]      You spoke candidly to the officer who prepared the pre-sentence report about your involvement with the cannabis.   You told the officer that money was your motivation for your offending.  You needed money because you could not afford to provide for your children, pay fines, and service a debt to a finance company.  You reported that you smoked up to three cannabis cigarettes on a daily basis.

Purposes and principles

[7]      Sentencing you today will involve a three-step process.  The first step is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v McDonald HC Whangarei CRI-2011-088-3522 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1029
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court of New Zealand was a sentencing matter involving John Gilbert McDonald. McDonald was convicted of cultivating cannabis and possessing it for the purpose of sale. The case was heard in the Whangarei Registry, and the sentencing was overseen by Justice Brewer on September 5, 2011. The Crown was represented by M A Jarman-Taylor, while McDonald was represented by J S Day.

The court was required to determine an appropriate sentence for McDonald's offenses. The key legal issues involved the classification of McDonald's cannabis cultivation and sale activities, the starting point for sentencing, and whether the purposes of sentencing could be adequately achieved through a less restrictive sentence, such as home detention. The court also needed to consider the personal circumstances of McDonald, including his motivation for the offending and his potential for rehabilitation.

Justice Brewer began by assessing McDonald's offending within the range of similar cases, determining a starting point of two years' imprisonment. The court took into account the commercial nature of the cannabis cultivation and the possession of cannabis for sale. The Crown argued for a higher starting point due to the commercial aspect and possession for sale, while McDonald's lawyer suggested a starting point of two years to two years and three months, with the possibility of home detention. Ultimately, the court settled on a starting point of two years' imprisonment.

After considering McDonald's personal circumstances, including his age, family responsibilities, and criminal history, the court applied a 25% discount for his early guilty pleas, resulting in a final term of imprisonment of 18 months. The court found that home detention would not adequately reflect the principles of deterrence and denunciation necessary for drug-related commercial offenses. Therefore, McDonald was sentenced to 18 months' imprisonment on each charge, to be served concurrently. His fines were remitted as per the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established