R v Margetson HC Dunedin CRI-2011-012-003495

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CRI-2011-012-003495

THE QUEEN

v

ANTHONY THOMAS WILLIAM MARGETSON

Hearing:         14 December 2011

Appearances: R D Smith for Crown

A Dawson for Prisoner

Judgment:      14 December 2011

SENTENCE OF WHATA J

Solicitors:

Wilkinson Adams, Crown Solicitors, PO Box 803, Dunedin 9054

Public Defence Service, DX YX 10180, Dunedin

R V MARGETSON HC DUN CRI-2011-012-003495 14 December 2011

[1]      Mr Margetson, you appear for sentence on three charges, two for possession and one for sale of cannabis.

Offences

[2]      Indeed, you pleaded guilty on 6 October 2011, to two counts of possession of cannabis  for  supply  and  one  count  of  selling  cannabis.    Each  count  carries  a maximum penalty of eight years’ imprisonment.

[3]      An order for forfeiture of $60 from the first search and $815 from the second search is also requested.

Facts

[4]      The facts  are summarised  in  the police summary,  but  you  disagree  with certain aspects of them.

[5]      Two  search  warrants  pursuant  to  the  Misuse  of  Drugs  Act  1975  were executed on your address.

[6]      In the first (on 11 August 2011), 90 grams of low quality cannabis leaf and 32 grams of high quality cannabis head was found in your bedroom.  Hidden under the bed there were a number of small deal bags, each containing cannabis bud and having a street value of $20.  A small amount of cash ($60) was located with these. You were interviewed and admitted selling cannabis in the form of $20 bags over the preceding three months.

[7]      The second search warrant was carried out on 2 September 2011.  You were at home on this occasion, and the search turned up 2.5 ounces of cannabis head in your room and $815 cash in your wallet.  You explained the cash as being from your parents, flatmates and personal savings.  During the course of the search you threw your cellphone into the bush area of the neighbouring property.   This was later recovered and text message data showed that you were selling cannabis to approximately 60 people.

[8]      You say that instead of selling cannabis for profit, as stated in the Summary, you were doing so as a means of covering the cost of your own cannabis use.  You also say that 60 clients is an exaggeration.  You say that you never in fact sold larger amounts of cannabis (being half ounces) although there were occasional mentions of this in text messages.  These sales never transpired and it was only smaller amounts of cannabis that were sold.

Resolution of disputed facts

[9]      I am prepared to proceed on the basis that your offending was low-level cannabis dealing for the purpose of funding your habit.   That still makes it commercial activity and therefore if the cash is the product of that activity it may be forfeited.  On this aspect I am not satisfied that the cash was directly linked to that activity.  There is no evidence other than the dealing to show such a link.  No records for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Margetson HC Dunedin CRI-2011-012-003495 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 2006
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of The Queen v Anthony Thomas William Margetson, the defendant faced sentencing for three charges related to the possession and sale of cannabis. The defendant had pleaded guilty to two counts of possession of cannabis for supply and one count of selling cannabis, each carrying a maximum penalty of eight years' imprisonment. The defendant was also subject to a request for the forfeiture of $60 and $815 from two separate searches conducted under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1975. The defendant argued that he was not selling cannabis for profit but rather to fund his own usage, and that the number of clients was exaggerated. The court considered the defendant's age, employment, and remorse in determining the appropriate sentence. The court concluded that the defendant's low-level cannabis dealing was for the purpose of funding his habit. However, the court found insufficient evidence to link the cash found during the searches to the defendant's cannabis dealing activities. The court imposed a sentence of eleven months of home detention with conditions, including residence at a specified address, attendance at treatment and/or counselling to address cannabis-related issues, and travel directly to the residence to await the arrival of a probation officer. The sentence was to commence on 15 December 2011, and all sentences were to be served concurrently. The court also encouraged the probation officer to support the defendant's ongoing employment. The $60 had already been forfeited by consent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established