R v Luo HC Auckland CRI 2007-004-22697

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI 2007-004-022697

THE QUEEN

v

YIHUA LUO

Hearing:         1 July 2010

Appearances: B D Tantrum for Crown

R J Earwaker for Prisoner

Judgment:      1 July 2010

SENTENCE OF KEANE J

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor, Auckland

R V YIHUA LUO HC AK CRI 2007-004-022697 [1 July 2010]

[1]      Luo Yihua, you appear for sentence following trial for 12 offences between 5

August - 7 December 2006, nine offences of supplying the class A controlled drug methamphetamine, two of conspiring to do so and one of possession for supply.

[2]      As I said when sentencing Mr Voong, the principal offender at trial, who controlled methamphetamine distribution from the Sky City Casino over the 19 weeks of the police operation, you were his right hand man. You communicated with him frequently. You looked to him for supplies of methamphetamine. You accounted to him for the sales made. He made his supplies, principally through you.

[3]     In all, the Crown contends that you were found guilty of supplying methamphetamine on nine occasions in an amount in excess of 1,000 grams; and also supply of 10,000 methamphetamine tablets. In addition, you were found accountable for possession for supply of 10,000 tablets containing methamphetamine and 28.3 grams of pure methamphetamine, and for conspiring to supply some 280 grams.

Pre-sentence report

[4]      You are, your report says, 32 years of age. You emigrated to New Zealand from China with your family in 1990. You completed school to the sixth form and then worked casually.

[5]      Your report says you did not work between 2004 - 2008. That is incorrect. When you were offending you were working at your girlfriend's karaoke bar. Later you worked at your brother's restaurant. Your terms of bail were altered so that you could work at each. Your report also says that you have previous convictions. That too is incorrect. Until you were convicted of these present offences for sentence you had no previous convictions. You are a first offender.

[6]      Your offending was not prompted by harmful alcohol or drug use or problem gambling.  Rather,  you  say  you  were  anxious  to  make  money  to  improve  your family's life. It was a way of making money fast. You now express remorse. You say that you will not become involved in this way again.

[7]      You confirm that now that your offending has been brought home to you by the jury's verdict you did offend in just the way that the Crown alleged at trial. You did commit the offences of which you have been convicted. The scale on which you offended in aggregate was as the Crown says on sentence.

Purposes and principles

[8]      I must hold you accountable for the harm you have done, promote in you a sense of responsibility, denounce your conduct, deter you and others from acting in this way, protect the community and provide for the interests of any conceivable victim. This was far from victimless offending. I must…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Luo HC Auckland CRI 2007-004-22697 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1076
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v Luo, the defendant, Luo Yihua, was sentenced for multiple drug-related offences. Luo was found guilty of nine instances of supplying methamphetamine, two counts of conspiracy to supply, and one count of possession for supply. The court had to determine an appropriate sentence for Luo, considering various legal and mitigating factors. The Crown argued for a sentence comparable to that of the principal offender, Voong, who received an 18-year imprisonment sentence. The Crown also sought a minimum term of imprisonment and the forfeiture of $16,000 found in Luo's possession and his car.

The defence argued that Luo should be considered a secondary offender, acting as an employee rather than a partner to Voong, and thus deserving of a lower starting point. They also highlighted Luo's remorse, lack of previous convictions, and the restrictive terms of his bail as mitigating factors. The defence further argued for a reduction in sentence due to the significant delay before the trial and the impact of bail conditions.

The court acknowledged Luo's role in the drug supply chain but distinguished him from the principal offender, Voong. It determined that a starting point of 17 years was appropriate for Luo's lead offences. Considering the delay in trial and the effects of bail terms, the court reduced the sentence by one year. Additionally, Luo's acceptance of responsibility and genuine remorse warranted a further six-month reduction. Consequently, Luo was sentenced to 15 and a half years for his lead offences and seven years for the conspiracy offences, to be served concurrently. A 40 per cent minimum term of imprisonment was also imposed. The court ordered the forfeiture of Luo's car and half of the $16,000 found in his bank box and car.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established