R v Kumar HC Auckland Cri-2008-092-18963

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI 2008-092-18963

THE QUEEN

v

PRAVIN KUMAR

Appearances: A McClintock and M Gatland for Crown

P Kaye for accused

Judgment:      7 October 2009

Reasons:        13 October 2009

REASONS FOR RULING OF ALLAN J COMMENCEMENT OF TRIAL IN ABSENCE OF ACCUSED

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor Auckland

P Kaye, Auckland

R V KUMAR HC AK CRI 2008-092-18963  7 October 2009

[1]      Mr Kumar faces a number of charges of serious sexual offending involving two  unconnected  complainants.     His  trial  was  scheduled  to  commence  on Wednesday 7 October 2009 at 10 am.   He failed to answer his bail that morning. Urgent police inquiries revealed he had absconded.  Ms McClintock for the Crown submitted that, despite the absence of the accused, the trial should nevertheless proceed.

[2]      At 2.15 pm I convened the Court in order to hear detailed argument from counsel as to the Court’s jurisdiction to continue in Mr Kumar’s absence, and as to the exercise of the Court’s discretion in the event that such jurisdiction existed. After hearing from counsel for more than an hour, I concluded that the Court had jurisdiction to proceed in Mr Kumar’s absence, and that in all the circumstances of this case the trial ought to proceed without him.  I gave an oral ruling to that effect, and indicated that I would give my reasons in writing.  These are those reasons.

Mr Kumar’s absence

[3]      The accused was apprehended in October 2008, in consequence of two quite separate complaints of serious sexual offending.  He was then remanded in custody and remained in custody until June 2009, when, over the opposition of the Crown, I ordered  that  he  be  released  on  bail  on  very  strict  conditions  which  included electronic monitoring (EM).  In a subsequent judgment on 20 August 2009, Asher J declined an application to vary the bail address.

[4]      The Crown’s opposition to bail was based not upon flight risk, but upon a concern that Mr Kumar might re-offend whilst on bail, given his earlier record.  In fact the accused did not offend while on bail, nor did he otherwise breach his bail conditions.  Indeed, he scrupulously adhered to the requirements of EM bail.  Very recently, in the ordinary way, arrangements were made for him to see his counsel in order to prepare for his forthcoming trial.  No difficulties were experienced in that respect.

[5]      At about 8.15 on the morning of the trial, the Henderson police had received a truncated call on a telephone associated with the accused.  During the brief call a person who called himself “Robert” confirmed that the accused would be attending Court that morning.  The call was abruptly terminated by the caller.

[6]      Against that background Mr Kumar was expected to present himself at Court prior to 9.30 am on the morning of his trial.   He did not arrive.   Urgent inquiries were made during the morning.  In particular, the police visited his bail…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Kumar HC Auckland Cri-2008-092-18963 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZHC 2457
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Kumar involves the accused, Pravin Kumar, who absconded prior to the commencement of his trial on serious sexual offence charges. Kumar was apprehended in October 2008 following complaints from two separate victims, and had been on bail with strict conditions since June 2009. Despite strict adherence to bail conditions, Kumar deliberately absconded on the morning of his scheduled trial date. The Crown sought to proceed with the trial in Kumar's absence, raising jurisdictional and discretionary issues regarding the Court's ability to do so. The legal issues centered on Kumar's right to be present at his trial under Section 376 of the Crimes Act 1961, and the Court's discretion to proceed in his absence under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.

The Court ruled that it had jurisdiction to proceed with the trial in Kumar's absence, and that the trial should indeed proceed without him. The Court considered various factors, including the deliberate and premeditated nature of Kumar's absence, the potential length of any adjournment, the adequacy of legal representation, the disadvantage to Kumar's defence, the risk of jury speculation, the seriousness of the charges, and the interests of the victims. The primary consideration was the significant distress and trauma experienced by the victims, which the Court deemed should not be prolonged by Kumar's deliberate absence. While Kumar's absence would undoubtedly hamper his defence, his legal representation would ensure that his defence was still presented to the jury.

The final orders included the denial of Mr. Kaye's application to withdraw as Kumar's counsel, and instructions for Mr. Kaye to inform the Court that no defence evidence would be presented due to Kumar's absence.