IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CRI-2013-404-000213
CRI-2013-404-000214 [2013] NZHC 2778
THE QUEEN
v
DILIANA BORISOUA GUEORGUIE KLINTCHAROVA VLADIMIR BORISOV KLINTCHAROV
Hearing: 22 October
Appearances: H B Leabourn for the Appellants
J V Roach for the Crown
Judgment: 22 October 2013
ORAL JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J
R v DILIANA BORISOUA GUEORGUIE KLINTCHAROVA VLADIMIR BORISOV KLINTCHAROV [2013] NZHC 2778 [22 October 2013]
Introduction
[1] Mr Klintcharov and Mrs Klintcharova pleaded guilty in the North Shore District Court to 17 charges of aiding and abetting their company, Eastern Star Universal Limited (now in liquidation), of evading or attempting to evade the assessment and payment of goods and services tax and income tax in breach of ss 143B(2) and 148(1) of the Tax Administration Act 1994. These offences carry a maximum penalty of five years’ imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $50,000 or both. Judge P Sinclair sentenced both appellants to a term of six months’ home detention and ordered them each to pay reparation of $73,429.26. They appeal against these sentences.
The facts
[2] Eastern Star Universal Limited was incorporated in March 1994 by the appellants to operate a restaurant business. They were 50-50 shareholders in the company and they both dealt with the day to day running of the business. Mr Klintcharov worked as a chef and was the sole director. Mrs Klintcharova tended to business administration and purchased the food.
[3] The appellants used available cash and credit facilities to meet personal expenditure and to pay staff and other creditors in preference to ensuring that the company met its tax obligations. From the time the business started in 1994 until it was placed in liquidation in October 2011, 57 per cent of GST returns and
71 per cent of income tax returns were not filed by due date. The Inland Revenue Department sent the company 53 GST reminder notices and 24 income tax reminder notices over this period. On eight occasions, the Department contacted Mr Klintcharov or the company’s tax agent concerning outstanding returns and tax payments. Inland Revenue officers reminded Mr Klintcharov of his responsibility as a director of the company to ensure that outstanding returns were filed and tax paid in a timely manner.
[4] Thirteen of the charges relate to the failure to file GST returns in the period from 31 March 2009 to 30 September 2011. The other four charges relate to the
failure to file income tax returns for the financial years ended 31 March 2008 to
31 March 2011. The unpaid GST amounted to $51,405.04 and the unpaid income tax totalled $95,453.48. The total unpaid tax at the time the company went into liquidation was therefore $146,858.52. This does not include use of money interest or penalties.
Sentence indication
[5] The appellants sought a sentence indication in the District Court. Detailed written submissions were filed. Counsel for the informant, the Commissioner of Inland Revenue, submitted that the appropriate starting point was a 15 month term of imprisonment and that after considering…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Klintcharova and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NZHC 2778
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the appellants should have been provided with an opportunity to reconsider their position before sentencing and whether the sentence of home detention was inappropriate. The court examined the sentencing indication given by Judge Wilson QC and the submissions made by counsel for the appellants during the sentence indication hearing. The court also considered the precedent set by the Court of Appeal in Zaheed v R, where a similar sentence of home detention was imposed for less serious tax evasion offences.
In delivering the judgment, the court found that the sentencing indication given by Judge Wilson QC was consistent with the submissions made by counsel for the appellants. The appellants had accepted this indication and pleaded guilty, understanding that they could expect a non-custodial sentence of either home detention or community detention. The court concluded that there was no basis for the appellants’ complaint that they ought to have been given the opportunity to reconsider their position before such a sentence was imposed. The court also determined that the sentence imposed by Judge Sinclair was not clearly excessive or inappropriate, and was in line with the sentence indication given by Judge Wilson QC.
The appeals by the appellants were dismissed. The court upheld the sentence of six months’ home detention and the reparation order of $73,429.26 imposed by Judge Sinclair.