R v Kingi HC Napier CRI-2011-081-193

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CRI-2011-081-193

THE QUEEN

v

BROWN MARSH KINGI

Hearing:         28 September 2011

Counsel:         J Lucas for the Crown

R D Stone for Mr Kingi

Judgment:      28 September 2011

SENTENCE OF WOODHOUSE J

Solicitors:

Mr J Lucas, Elvidge & Partners, Office of the Crown Solicitor, Napier

Mr R D Stone, Souness Stone Law Partnership, Solicitors, Hastings

R V KINGI HC NAP CRI-2011-081-193 28 September 2011

[1]      Mr Kingi, you may remain seated while I explain the sentence I am going to impose.  I need, obviously, to explain it to you but I also need to explain it to the community as a whole.

[2]      I want to make clear at the outset that what I intend to do is impose a sentence of home detention, for reasons that I will explain, together with a sentence of community work.

[3]      You appear for sentence, with sentence having been transferred from the District Court, for cultivation of cannabis, possession of cannabis seeds and possession of three methamphetamine pipes.  The most serious of these offences is cultivation of cannabis and the maximum penalty for that is seven years imprisonment. And that maximum penalty is something which, by itself, I think you should reflect on.

Background facts

[4]      A brief summary of the background facts is that on 18 March 2011 you were found to be cultivating a total of 98 cannabis plants at your home near Waipawa. There were 27 plants growing outside and 71 clones were being cultivated in a grow room inside the house.  You were also found in possession of approximately 20,000 cannabis seeds with that calculated simply by weighing.

[5]      When spoken to by Police you did refer to yourself as a commercial grower, and I will come back to the relevance of that.

[6]      Approximately a month later Police found the three methamphetamine pipes.

Personal circumstances

[7]      In brief outline, your personal circumstances are as follows. You are 40 years old.  You were born in Kawakawa and, it would appear and I infer, in a supportive family.  For whatever reason – and not arising out of any difficulties as such with

your family – you over the years have drifted away from them and from the support that would have been readily available from them.

[8]      You described yourself to the probation officer as a “black sheep”. And there

was reference in the pre-sentence report to your being something of a lost soul.

[9]      You do have relevant previous convictions.  In 2001 you were convicted for possession of cannabis plant.   It was obviously a relatively minor offence because the penalty was a fine of $250.   In 2003 you were convicted for cultivation of cannabis and possession for supply of cannabis plant.  There was a sentence of two years imprisonment – and that is indicative of the level of the offending then – but with leave granted to apply for home detention.

[10]     There are further relevant matters in respect of your…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Kingi HC Napier CRI-2011-081-193 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1156
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Napier Registry, the case of the Queen versus Brown Marsh Kingi was heard and sentenced on 28 September 2011. The defendant, Kingi, was charged with the cultivation of cannabis, possession of cannabis seeds, and possession of three methamphetamine pipes. The case was transferred from the District Court for sentencing purposes. The primary legal issues involved determining the appropriate sentence for the offences, considering the degree of commerciality in the cannabis cultivation, and assessing mitigating and aggravating factors.

The court first established the starting point for sentencing, which, given the nature of the offences, fell within category 2 as per the Court of Appeal's decision in Terewi. This category involves small-scale commercial cultivation of cannabis plants. After weighing the arguments presented by counsel, the court determined that the starting point should be two years imprisonment, adjusted for the possession of seeds and methamphetamine pipes, and previous convictions, leading to an uplift of approximately six months. Mitigation factors, such as an early guilty plea and cooperation with police, resulted in a reduction of about 10 months. Ultimately, the court considered a sentence of home detention to be appropriate, given the offender's supportive family and willingness to participate in rehabilitation efforts.

The court sentenced Kingi to nine months of home detention, to be served at a specified address in Ohakune, along with conditions such as abstaining from alcohol and illicit drugs and completing an addiction program. Additionally, Kingi was sentenced to 100 hours of community work, with the possibility of up to 20% of this being converted to training. For the possession of cannabis seeds and methamphetamine pipes, Kingi was additionally sentenced to three months and one month of home detention, respectively, to be served concurrently with the primary sentence. There was no sentence of community work imposed for these additional offences.