IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY
CRI-2009-063-509
THE QUEEN
v
JOSEPH RONALD KHAN
Appearances: L Maynard for the Crown
AMM Schultz for the prisoner
Judgment: 13 August 2010
SENTENCING NOTES OF PRIESTLEY J
Counsel:
L Maynard, Gordon Pilditch, P O Box 740, Rotorua 3040. Fax: 07 349 3985
Email: lauren.forsyth@gordonpilditch.co.nzAMM Schultz, P O Box 2279, Rotorua 3040. Fax: 07 349 3179. Email: Shirley@lancelawson.co.nz
R V KHAN HC ROT CRI-2009-063-509 13 August 2010
[1] Joseph Ronald Kahn, I am to sentence you today on one charge of injuring with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, laid under s 189(1) of the Crimes Act
1961. That charge carries with it a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment. You pleaded guilty to this charge in this court in March. Prior to that you faced an indictment of three alternative counts which included attempted murder and threatening to kill. Those counts were justified on the facts available to the police. I appreciate, however, that for understandable forensic reasons you were not prepared to plead guilty to the more serious count of attempted murder at an earlier stage which in the round was probably a charge which, as a matter of prosecutorial discretion, need not have been laid. In making that comment, however, I am not at all critical of the police or indeed the Crown.
[2] Let me tell you this now Mr Kahn, if you had a track record of domestic violence, previous convictions for that, or previous convictions for violent offending, you would be going to jail. Do you understand that? I am, however, in all the circumstances minded to impose a lenient sentence on you, being one of home detention. I note that outcome is not opposed by either the Crown or your own counsel and for that reason my sentencing comments can be fairly short.
[3] Your offending took place in January 2009. Your wife, as part of her occupation, had formed an emotional attachment with another man, even though she was still living with you. You, at a stage when you had some health problems, found this difficult to accept. My own assessment is that inspired in large measure by sexual jealousy you became enraged. When your wife came home you went into her room, began to abuse her verbally, got on top of her, pinned her down to the bed and then proceeded to choke her with your hands. She became unconscious. It would have been a terrifying experience for her. She subsequently regained consciousness and you attempted to repeat your assault of her. The next day you and she went off to the police station where you admitted that you had choked your victim.
[4] I have heard today from your victim, your wife. Fortunately for you she is supportive of you. She has spoken at length to a dramatic and highly intricate drawing which she has made, being a mosaic type depiction of your head, which shows amongst other things your good…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Khan HC Rotorua CRI 2009-063-509 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NZHC 1584
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court had to decide included the appropriate sentence for Khan's crime, considering the mitigating factors such as his immediate remorse, participation in a domestic violence programme, and his wife's forgiveness. The court also had to consider the impact of Khan's health issues and the fact that this was his first conviction. The court applied the Sentencing Act purposes and principles, taking into account the tariff case of R v Taueki and the Court of Appeal judgment of R v Brown.
Priestley J decided on a sentence of home detention for nine months, with specific conditions such as no alcohol or illicit drug consumption, regular reporting to a probation officer, and participation in programmes to control temper and restore Khan to an active life in the community. The court also recommended finding Khan useful employment to help him re-enter the workforce. The final orders required Khan to travel directly to a specified address for the duration of his sentence, not consume alcohol or illicit drugs, report to his probation officer, and undertake any programmes directed by the probation officer to assist him in controlling his temper and restoring his relationship with his wife.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi