R v Hemara HC Wanganui CRI 2009-083-540

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

WANGANUI REGISTRY

CRI-2009-083-540

THE QUEEN

v

ANA ANDREA HEMARA

(At Wellington)

Counsel:               L C Rowe for Crown

S J Ross for Prisoner

Sentence:         12 March 2010

SENTENCING NOTES OF DOBSON J

[ 1 ]  Ms Hemara, you appear for sentencing this morning on your conviction for

murder and a further conviction for obstructing the course of justice. These charges arose as a result of your conduct on 14 February 2009. You pleaded guilty promptly to the charge of obstructing the course of justice and you were found guilty of murder by a jury in the Wanganui High Court on 5 February this year.

  1. On 14 February 2009, you were living with Michael Christison, a partner you

had recently moved in with, at Titoki Street in Wanganui. During the day, you invited a new neighbour, Heather Simons, to come over for drinks that evening, and she duly arrived at about 6pm. Ms Simons’ daughter confirms that Ms Simons was still fine at your place at about 9pm that evening, but sometime thereafter you savagely beat her to death.

R V HEMARA HC WANG CRI-2009-083-540 12 March 2010

  1. A post mortem determined that Ms Simons died from multiple areas of blunt force trauma to her head. The pathologist identified more than 60 separate sites of injury, without being able to express an opinion on how many actual blows were inflicted. A later explanation you gave to the Police confirmed that you kicked, punched and stomped on your victim. You acknowledged that you went “hard out” at her, and that you were aware of the sort of injuries your attack was causing. Police photographs of the scene produced at your trial showed that substantial volumes of Ms Simons’ hair had been pulled out in the course of your attack, consistent with you savagely attacking a person who was unable to adequately defend herself.

  2. I accept what Mr Rowe has said about the reconstruction this morning, that a good part of the attack must have occurred whilst Ms Simons was at least face down on the floor, and possibly already unconscious.

  3. The Crown’s reconstruction of the events does not establish the period of time between the end of this savage attack on Ms Simons, and you and your partner calling an ambulance to obtain medical assistance for her. I was left with the impression that that delay was more likely to be a matter of hours rather than a matter of minutes, and who knows what different outcome may have been achieved, had there been an immediate medical intervention.

  4. By the time the ambulance officers arrived, it is apparent that bleeding within the brain had caused substantial swelling. Ambulance officers were unable to force Ms Simons’ eyes open to check her medical condition, because of the extent of the swelling around her eyes caused by your attack on her. Ms Simons was flown from Wanganui to Wellington Hospital, where her injuries were assessed as so serious that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Hemara HC Wanganui CRI 2009-083-540 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 432
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Hemara involves the sentencing of Ana Andrea Hemara, who was convicted of murder and obstructing the course of justice. The murder charge arose from the fatal assault on Heather Simons on 14 February 2009. The assault, which involved severe blunt force trauma, was perpetrated by Hemara and her partner, Michael Christison. The attack was particularly brutal, with evidence showing that Simons was beaten while she was either unconscious or face down on the floor. Hemara and Christison attempted to cover up the crime by changing Simons' clothes and delaying the call for medical assistance. Hemara pleaded guilty to obstructing the course of justice but denied the murder charge, which was ultimately found by a jury.

The court had to determine the appropriate sentence for Hemara, considering the principles of sentencing under the Sentencing Act 2002, including the purposes of deterrence, accountability, and community protection. The court also had to decide the non-parole period for the murder conviction, considering whether any of the criteria in section 104 of the Act applied. The arguments focused on whether the murder involved high levels of brutality and callousness, or if Simons was particularly vulnerable due to her cerebral palsy and the unexpected nature of the attack. The court found that while the attack was brutal and callous, it did not meet the threshold of section 104. However, the court determined that the brutality and vulnerability factors warranted a non-parole period longer than the statutory minimum of 10 years.

After considering various sentencing precedents and the submissions from both the Crown and Hemara's counsel, the court set a starting point of 13 years and 6 months for the murder conviction. The court also considered the concurrent sentence for the obstructing the course of justice conviction, ultimately deciding on an additional six months, making a total sentence of 14 years. The court reduced the sentence slightly to account for mitigating factors such as Hemara's cooperation with the police and her mental health issues.

The final orders of the court were that Hemara be sentenced to life imprisonment with a non-parole period of 13 years and 6 months for the murder conviction, and an additional six months for the obstructing the course of justice conviction, to be served concurrently.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established