IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
CRI-2014-085-3701
CRI-2013-085-11932 [2017] NZHC 1661
THE QUEEN
v
CLINT JOHN TUIRANGI HELMBRIGHT LEWIS CONSTANTINE PADDEN
Hearing: 19 July 2017 Counsel:
E M Light for Crown
E J Forster for Mr Helmbright
L C Padden in Person
B S Yeoman, Counsel Assisting the CourtSentencing:
19 July 2017
SENTENCING NOTES OF THOMAS J
[1] Mr Helmbright and Mr Padden you appear for sentence having been found guilty by a jury in respect of methamphetamine offending discovered as a result of the Police investigation known as Operation Nebraska.
Background
[2] Operation Nebraska was conducted between July and October 2013, extending from Rotorua to Christchurch. The operation involved an interception phase conducted between 26 August and 23 October 2013.
[3] A trial was held in 2016 involving Mr Helmbright, Mr Padden and four co-defendants. Around 12 other co-defendants had pleaded guilty to related charges.
The jury found Mr Helmbright guilty on 38 charges and not guilty on others, but was
R v HELMBRIGHT AND PADDEN [2017] NZHC 1661 [19 July 2017]
unable to agree on verdicts on yet other charges. The jury was also unable to agree on verdicts in relation to all the charges faced by Mr Padden and a co-defendant, Nicholas van der Wiel. The Crown elected to retry Mr Helmbright in respect of some of the charges and retry Mr Padden and Mr van der Wiel. Mr van der Wiel pleaded guilty to certain charges, leaving Mr Helmbright and Mr Padden to face a retrial. At that retrial they were convicted of all charges they faced and on which they are to be sentenced today as follows:
Mr Helmbright
(a) Eleven charges of supplying the Class A controlled drug methamphetamine;1
(b)two charges of offering to supply the Class A controlled drug methamphetamine; and
(c) two charges of possessing the Class A controlled drug methamphetamine for supply.
Mr Padden
(a) Five charges of supplying the Class A controlled drug methamphetamine.
[4] Generally speaking, Mr Padden supplied methamphetamine to Mr Helmbright, and Mr Helmbright then possessed methamphetamine for supply to various people. Mr Helmbright then supplied, or offered to supply methamphetamine to Mr van der Wiel.
[5] Mr Padden played the role of a facilitator, that is, somebody who passed on larger amounts of drugs which were then broken into smaller amounts and on-sold.
The evidence demonstrated a pattern whereby Mr Helmbright would obtain
1 The maximum penalty for all the charges faced by Mr Helmbright and Mr Padden is life imprisonment.
methamphetamine from Mr Padden and then meet his “runners” in Wellington and
Christchurch to supply them.
Amount of methamphetamine
[6] Mr Helmbright was charged with supplying Mr van der Wiel with the amounts specified in the particulars to charges 8, 10, 12, 13, and 15–20, and a further unspecified amount in charge 14. Mr Helmbright was also charged with offering to supply Mr van der Wiel amounts specified in charges 9 and 11. The amount of methamphetamine was established by the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Helmbright and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZHC 1661
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to decide were the appropriate starting point and sentence for each defendant, considering the aggravating and mitigating features of their offending. The court also had to determine if a minimum period of imprisonment (MPI) should be imposed for each defendant.
The court's reasoning and outcome were based on the quantity and value of drugs involved, the roles played by the defendants, and the premeditation inherent in the type of offending. For Helmbright, the court concluded a starting point of a little under 10 years' imprisonment was appropriate, and imposed a sentence of 10 months' imprisonment cumulative on his existing sentence. The court declined to impose an MPI for Helmbright. For Padden, the court took a starting point of seven years' imprisonment and imposed a sentence of seven years' imprisonment, also declining to impose an MPI.
The final orders were that Helmbright was sentenced to 10 months' imprisonment, cumulative on his current sentence, while Padden was sentenced to seven years' imprisonment.