R v HC Auckland CRI-2010-404-170

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2010-404-170

QUEEN

v

V

Hearing:         4 August 2010

Appearances: S Petricevic for Crown

M Lowe for Respondent

Judgment:      6 August 2010 at 4:30 pm

JUDGMENT OF ASHER J

This judgment was delivered by me on 6 August 2010 at 4:30 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

………………………………………..

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

………………………………………..

Date

Solicitors:

S Petricevic, Meredith Connell, Crown Solicitor, PO Box 2213, Auckland

M Lowe, Barrister, Auckland

R V V HC AK CRI-2010-404-170  6 August 2010

Introduction

[1]      This  is  an  application  for  a  suspect  compulsion  order  under  s 13  of  the Criminal  Investigation  (Bodily  Samples)  Act 1995,  requiring  the  respondent, Stephen V  , to give a bodily sample.

[2]      The application arises out of four charges of burglary, one of unlawful taking and one of theft.  The alleged offences took place between 27 September 2007 and

11 September 2008.  There are no charges presently outstanding in respect of these offences.

[3]      Mr V   can be fairly described as a recidivist offender.   He has some

14 pages of convictions, of which many involve dishonesty, including unlawfully taking  motor  vehicles,  theft,  shoplifting,  receiving  property  and  burglary.    In August 2009  he  was  sentenced  to  prison  for  one  year  and  one  month,  and  in November 2009  he  was  separately sentenced  to  eight  months’  imprisonment  on various charges.

[4]      During the first part of 2008, Mr V   was a suspect in relation to the offences committed in late 2007.  Between 10 January 2008 and 28 April 2008 the burglary and vehicle scenes were forensically linked to each other by blood found at the scenes, and by corresponding samples being found on the crime sample database. The male DNA profiles all corresponded to each other, indicating that the DNA in each of the blood samples could have come from the same male individual.   The male to whom these DNA profiles correspond was Stephen V  .

[5]      On  25 June 2008  the  police  requested  a  voluntary  DNA  sample  from Mr V   in relation to the offences.  This request was refused.  On 26 June 2008 indictable charges were laid in respect of the 2007 offences.  On 28 August 2008 at the depositions hearing for those offences, the charges were withdrawn.  The reason put forward in the Crown’s submissions, not contested by Ms Lowe for Mr V  , was that they were withdrawn because a suspect compulsion order had not yet been sought or obtained in respect of the offences.  It has been common ground between

Ms Petrecovic for the Crown and Ms Lowe that the only evidence that the police have linking Mr V   to the offences is the DNA evidence.

[6]      On 3 September 2008 a Constable Pringle created a suspect compulsion order file in relation to the offences, in order to apply for a sample from Mr V  .  The file contained an original and an identical copy.  It would seem that the procedures required the original to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v HC Auckland CRI-2010-404-170 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1361
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, the case of R v V HC AK CRI-2010-404-170 was heard on 4 August 2010. The Crown sought a suspect compulsion order under section 13 of the Criminal Investigation (Bodily Samples) Act 1995, requiring Stephen V to provide a bodily sample. This application arose from charges of burglary, unlawful taking, and theft that occurred between 27 September 2007 and 11 September 2008. The Crown argued that the only evidence linking Mr V to the offences was DNA evidence, and obtaining a bodily sample from him was critical to the investigation.

The primary legal issue was whether it was reasonable to make the order under section 16(1) of the Act, despite the significant delay caused by police error. The court had to consider whether the Crown had established good cause to suspect Mr V committed the offences, whether the material was reasonably believed to be from him, whether analysis of a bodily sample would tend to confirm or disprove his involvement, and whether it was reasonable to make the order given the delay. The court also had to consider the seriousness of the offences, the importance of obtaining a bodily sample, and any other relevant factors under section 16(2).

The court found that there was good cause to suspect Mr V committed the offences due to the DNA evidence. The court was satisfied that the material was from him, that analysis of a bodily sample would be relevant, and that he had refused to consent. The court acknowledged the significant delay but found it was due to police error rather than misconduct. The court balanced the delay against the importance of obtaining the bodily sample, the seriousness of the offences, and the legitimate expectations of the complainants and the public. The court concluded that it was reasonable to make the order, and granted the application.

The final orders were that Stephen V was required to give a bodily sample under section 13 of the Criminal Investigation (Bodily Samples) Act 1995.