R v Harding HC Wellington CRI 2011-091-3903

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI 2011-091-3903

THE QUEEN

v

CHRISTOPHER KEVIN HARDING

Hearing:         22 September 2011

Counsel:         K Grau for the Crown

P Surridge for the Accused

Judgment:      9 December 2011

SENTENCING REMARKS OF MALLON J

The charge

[1]      Mr Harding, you are here for sentence having pleaded guilty to a charge of possession of cannabis for the purpose of supply or sale.  You are here in the High Court for sentencing because the District Court declined jurisdiction.

Circumstances of offending

[2]      You  were  charged  following  the  execution  of  a  search  warrant  at  your residential address.  The police found a plastic bag containing 9 cannabis tinnies and a bucket containing 7 ounce bags of cannabis.  Together the cannabis found totalled

208 grams.  Other than glad snap lock bags and tin foil in the kitchen, no other items

potentially associated with supplying or selling cannabis was found.

R v HARDING HC WN CRI 2011-091-3903 9 December 2011

Circumstances of offender

[3]      You are 60 years old. You have been with your wife for over thirty years. As a result of suffering injuries in a motor vehicle accident you have had on-going pain in your leg, hip and lower back for many years.  Photographs have been supplied to the Court showing the severity of your injuries, and I have heard further from your counsel this afternoon about your injuries and the steps that you are taking in relation to those including having recently changed your medical care.

[4]      You have been unable to work and there is a medical certificate confirming that you have been on constant medication for pain relief.   You say that the medication has been inadequate and that cannabis helps you to manage the on-going pain.  You have been a regular cannabis user for many years and have developed a high tolerance to it. You say that you do not sell cannabis but do trade it with friends at times for a “nice change” of “smoke”.

[5]      You  acknowledged  to  the  pre-sentence  report  writer  that  you  require assistance regarding your drug use.  You have said that you are open to attending substance abuse education.

[6]      You  have  a  number  of  previous  convictions.    For  present  purposes,  the relevant ones are possession of cannabis x5 (on dates between 1992 and 2006), possession of cannabis for supply (1991), possession of cannabis oil for supply x2 (1997) and selling cannabis (1994).   The most serious of these was the 1997 possession of cannabis oil for supply for which you received a sentence of imprisonment of one year and nine months.

Sentencing approach

[7]      In  sentencing  you  I am  required  to  take into  account  the principles  and purposes of sentencing set out in the Sentencing Act.  Of particular relevance in drug offending is deterrence.   Consistency with other offenders convicted of similar offending is also important.   Depending on the circumstances of the offender, a sentence may be aimed at rehabilitation.

[8]      I approach your sentence by first considering what sentence for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Harding HC Wellington CRI 2011-091-3903 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1977
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of The Queen v Christopher Kevin Harding involved the sentencing of Mr Harding for possession of cannabis with the intent to supply or sell. The High Court at Wellington was responsible for the sentencing after the District Court declined jurisdiction. Mr Harding pleaded guilty to the charge, which stemmed from a search warrant executed at his residence where police found cannabis, totaling 208 grams, packaged in a manner suggestive of distribution.

The legal issues before the court included determining the appropriate starting point for sentencing in light of the nature of the offence, Mr Harding's personal circumstances, and his previous convictions. The court also had to consider whether home detention would be an appropriate alternative to imprisonment, given the personal mitigating factors and the low level of commercial activity involved.

Mallon J, the presiding judge, commenced the sentencing process by acknowledging the principle of deterrence and consistency with other offenders convicted of similar offences. The court considered a starting point of two years based on the Crown's submission and the guideline set by the Court of Appeal in R v Terewi. However, considering the relatively minor commercial element of the offence and Mr Harding's long-standing cannabis use, the court adjusted the starting point to no more than two years. The court then applied a 25% discount for Mr Harding's early guilty plea, resulting in a sentence of 18 months' imprisonment. Ultimately, the court decided to impose nine months of home detention, subject to conditions that Mr Harding attend any assessment, counselling, or treatment for drug abuse as directed and approved by the probation officer and service provider.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established