R v H HC Dunedin CRI 2007-012-4181

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CRI 2007-012-4181

THE QUEEN

v

H
S

Hearing:         17 November 2008

Appearances: R Bates & A Killeen for the Crown

J Haigh QC & B Boyd for accused S 
G King for accused H 

Judgment:      25 November 2008

JUDGMENT OF STEVENS J

(Section 344A application to determine admissibility of challenged evidence)

This judgment was delivered by me on Tuesday, 25 November 2008 at 4pm pursuant to r 540(4) of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:
Crown Solicitor, PO Box 803, Dunedin 9054

J Haigh QC, PO Box 1614, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140

G King, PO Box 24086, Manners Street, Wellington 6142
A Killeen, Serious Fraud Office, PO Box 7124, Wellesley Street, Auckland 1141

B Boyd, PO Box 37139, Parnell, Auckland 1151

R V S AND ANOR HC DUN CRI 2007-012-4181  25 November 2008

Introduction

[1]      The accused, S   (Mr S  ) and H   (Mr H  ) are each charged with two counts of using a document with intent to defraud contrary to s 229A(b) of the Crimes Act 1961.  Each accused also faces a further  charge  of  using documents  to  obtain  a  pecuniary advantage  or  valuable consideration contrary to s 228(b) of the Crimes Act.  The Crown contends that the amount of money dishonestly obtained  as a result of the use of the documents concerned exceeds $16.9 million.

[2]      The prosecution of the accused follows an investigation by the Serious Fraud Office.   The Crown proposed to lead evidence from a senior investigator for the Serious Fraud Office.   Mr David Osborn is designated Supervising Senior, Investigations.   Much of his evidence is not challenged in terms of admissibility. But Mr Haigh QC, counsel for Mr S  , signalled an objection to evidence being led by the Crown as to the utilisation of monies received by Computer South Ltd pursuant to contracts entered into between Sonnford Solutions Ltd (and its predecessor) and the Otago District Health Board (ODHB).  Counsel challenged the relevance of the evidence of how the monies received by Computer South Ltd (or any person acting for and on behalf of that corporate entity, particularly the accused Mr S  ) were spent (the challenged evidence).

[3]      Mr King made a similar objection on behalf of Mr H  .  He objected to evidence being led by the Crown concerning the utilisation of certain funds which were received for the acknowledged personal benefit of Mr H  .   Mr King submitted that the destination of some of the monies, namely, those paid to the Inland Revenue Department and those dispersed for accounting services, was admissible.  However, he also contended that the destination of the balance of the funds, comprising in excess of $1.4 million spent on vehicles, boats, property and other personal items, was not relevant and should not be referred to by the Crown. In  the  alternative,  defence  counsel  submitted  that  the  evidence  of  sources  of spending should be excluded because of its prejudicial value.

[4]      Mr  Bates,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v H HC Dunedin CRI 2007-012-4181 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZHC 1848
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of R v H involved two accused individuals, S and H, charged with multiple counts of using documents with intent to defraud and obtaining pecuniary advantages. The Crown proposed to lead evidence from a senior investigator of the Serious Fraud Office regarding the use of funds obtained through fraudulent means. Defence counsel objected to the admissibility of certain evidence, particularly relating to how the funds were spent by the accused, arguing it was irrelevant and overly prejudicial. The Crown argued the evidence was relevant to proving the accused's motive and intent. The court held that the challenged evidence was relevant as it pertained to the accused's control over the funds, their personal receipt of the funds, and the lack of business operational costs. The evidence was also deemed relevant to the context of the alleged offences, mens rea, and motive. Despite concerns about potential prejudice, the court found that the probative value of the evidence outweighed any prejudicial effect. The application to admit the challenged evidence was granted, allowing the Crown to lead the contested portions of the evidence.