IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA38/03
THE QUEEN
v
ALAN IVO GREER
Hearing:23 February 2004
Coram:Chambers J
Robertson J
John Hansen JAppearances: B S Yeoman for Appellant
E M Thomas for Crown
Judgment:8 March 2004
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY CHAMBERS J
An arrest in Porirua
[1] In the early hours of 3 November 1994, Alan Greer was the passenger in a car being driven in Porirua. Two police officers, Constables Mark Duncan and Tania Lepoama, saw the car and caused it to pull over. They spoke to Mr Greer and the driver. There is no dispute that after a short time had elapsed Mr Greer was then arrested. Following the arrest Constable Duncan attempted to search Mr Greer. Mr Greer resisted. During the ensuing struggle Mr Greer bit the two constables. One bite drew blood. More police arrived. During a continued struggle in the police car, Mr Greer head-butted a third constable, Constable Manatua Faraimo, and at the police station, when his handcuffs were removed, he tried to punch a fourth constable, Constable Peter McManus, albeit without much success.
[2] Mr Greer was charged with assaulting the four constables, with intent to obstruct them in the execution of their duty. He was also charged with threatening to kill Constable McManus. He pleaded not guilty.
[3] There was no dispute at trial that the assaults on the police had occurred. Mr Greer, however, asserted that his actions were justified as being in self-defence. He asserted that his arrest had been unlawful, with the consequence that the police actions in trying to take him into custody were unlawful and he was entitled to use reasonable force to resist them.
[4] The jury found Mr Greer guilty of aggravated assault with respect to Constables Duncan, Lepoama, and Faraimo. He was found guilty of common assault with respect to Constable McManus. Mr Greer was found not guilty of threatening to kill Constable McManus.
[5] Judge Keane sentenced Mr Greer to six months’ imprisonment on the three charges of aggravated assault. He sentenced him to one month’s imprisonment for the common assault on Constable McManus. All sentences were concurrent.
[6] Mr Greer appeals against his convictions. This appeal is a rehearing pursuant to Part 2 of the Crimes (Criminal Appeals) Amendment Act 2001, which accounts for why it is being heard so long after the events in question and the trial. Mr Greer has already served his sentence.
Issues on the appeal
[7] Mr Greer filed his own notice of appeal. He relied on alleged “new evidence”. That alleged new evidence was a “NZ Police Report Form” prepared by Constable Duncan on 3 November 1994. Mr Greer appears to allege that this form had not been discovered by the police prior to his trial. Had it been, Mr Greer submitted, it would provide further support for “the defence version of events” and would have resulted in an acquittal.
[8] The Crown disputes that the form, which we shall refer…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Greer and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NZCA 16
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed. Greer's convictions for assaulting the police officers and threatening to kill one of them stand. The court found that the appeal was without merit, and that there was no basis for setting aside Greer's convictions. The court's decision was unanimous, with all three judges agreeing that the appeal should be dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Greer filed a notice of appeal relying on alleged "new evidence." This appeal was a rehearing pursuant to Part 2 of the Crimes (Criminal Appeals) Amendment Act 2001. Mr Greer had already served his sentence. Mr Greer's counsel, Mr Yeoman, expanded on the grounds of appeal and added a further ground that the essential question of the legality of the arrest should have been tested by a case stated before trial. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the Prosecution Section form new evidence that was not disclosed to the appellant's former counsel?
2. Should the essential question of the legality of the arrest have been tested in some way by a case stated before trial?
Held
1. The Prosecution Section form was not new evidence that was not disclosed to the appellant's former counsel. The ground of appeal on this point fails.
2. The essential question of the legality of the arrest should not have been tested by a case stated before trial. The argument that a case stated should have been sought is without merit.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appeal centered on two main issues: the alleged non-disclosure of a Prosecution Section form by the police and the failure to test the legality of the arrest through a case stated. Regarding the Prosecution Section form, the Court found that it was highly likely that the form had been disclosed to the appellant's former counsel, as part of the police file. Even if it had not been disclosed, the form would not have altered the outcome of the trial as it essentially mirrored other documents that were already used during the trial. The Court found no fault in the appellant's former counsel for not using the form as it would not have provided additional benefit.
As for the second issue, the Court examined the appellant's claim that the legality of the arrest should have been tested via a case stated. The Court concluded that the appellant's arrest was lawful as he had provided false information and failed to identify the vehicle's owner, justifying the arrest under the Transport Act 1962. Consequently, the appellant's defence of self-defence was based on a misunderstanding of the law. The Court held that seeking a case stated would not have achieved anything as the appellant's arrest was lawful, and he was not entitled to resist it.
In summary, the Court dismissed the appeal based on the findings that the Prosecution Section form was not new evidence and that a case stated on the legality of the arrest would not have altered the trial's outcome. The binding legal principle in this case is that a case stated should not be used to challenge the legality of an arrest when the arrest is found to be lawful based on the evidence presented.