R v Greer

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA 163/03

THE QUEEN

v

ALAN IVO GREER

Hearing:17 May 2004

Coram:O'Regan J
Wild J
Doogue J

Appearances:  B S Yeoman for Appellant


M F Laracy for Crown

Judgment:20 May 2004 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY WILD J

[1]       By notice dated 21 April 2003 the appellant seeks leave to appeal against his conviction and sentence in the District Court at Palmerston North.  He was convicted having pleaded guilty on arraignment at the start of his trial on 21 June 1999 to nine of the 12 counts in the indictment, and to the remaining three a little way in to the Crown case at trial.  He was sentenced on 9 July 1999.

[2]       A previous application for leave to appeal dated 16 July 1999 was declined in or about August 1999.

[3]       An adjournment was sought and declined on 16 March 2004.  The application for an adjournment was renewed before us.  However, we need not rule on the application for an adjournment, and need not comment on the alleged lack of disclosure which was the basis for it.  The allegation of a lack of disclosure is impossible to reconcile with the appellant’s guilty pleas.

Conviction appeal

[4]       The basis for the application for leave to appeal against conviction is that the search of the appellant’s home which led to the charges was an unlawful one.  It is submitted that the trial Judge was wrong not to exclude, as exhibits in the case, the fruits of the search, on the principles established in R v Grayson and Taylor [1997] 1 NZLR 399 (CA). Under Grayson principles, the question was whether the search was unreasonable.  Its lawfulness or unlawfulness, whilst highly relevant, was not necessarily determinative either way.

[5]       There is no suggestion in the evidence called before the appellant pleaded guilty to the remaining charges that the search was unlawful.  Detective Sicely gave evidence that the Police executed search warrants at the appellant’s home on 30 June, 2 July and 3 July 1998 – three successive search warrants.  It was not put to the Detective that any of those warrants was improperly obtained or executed.

[6]       The second ground of the application for leave to appeal against conviction is that the appellant was poorly advised by his counsel at trial and was pressured to plead guilty to nine counts in the indictment in order to assist his co-accused, who was his then partner and mother of their three children.  No evidentiary foundation for this ground was laid:  there was no supporting affidavit(s) and no waiver was filed enabling a report to the Court by the counsel who represented the appellant at trial.  We note that counsel was very experienced senior counsel.  As we have mentioned, the appellant pleaded guilty to nine of the 12 charges in the indictment upon arraignment at the start of his trial, and to the other three a little way into the trial.  Two of those three counts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Greer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NZCA 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an appeal against conviction and sentence brought by Alan Ivo Greer, who was convicted and sentenced in the District Court at Palmerston North. The appeal was against his conviction on nine of the twelve counts in the indictment, and to the remaining three a little way into the Crown case at trial. He was sentenced on 9 July 1999. The appeal court considered two grounds for leave to appeal against conviction: firstly, that the search of the appellant's home which led to the charges was unlawful, and secondly, that the appellant was poorly advised by his counsel at trial and was pressured to plead guilty. The appeal court found that neither ground was made out. The appeal court also considered the appeal against sentence, focusing on the sentencing Judge's four year starting point on the possession of Class B drugs for supply count. The appellant argued that this was out of line with previous decisions, but the appeal court found that the four year starting point was appropriate and the end point well within the appropriate sentencing range.

The appeal court found that the search of the appellant's home which led to the charges was lawful, and that there was no suggestion in the evidence that the search was unlawful. The court also found that the appellant was not poorly advised by his counsel at trial, and that there was no evidentiary foundation for this ground. The appeal court found that the sentencing Judge's four year starting point was appropriate, and that the end point was well within the appropriate sentencing range. The appeal court dismissed the application for leave to appeal both against conviction and sentence, and the convictions entered and the sentences imposed stood.

Background

Background to the litigation

Alan Ivo Greer was convicted and sentenced in the District Court at Palmerston North. He pleaded guilty to nine counts of the twelve charges in the indictment at the start of his trial on 21 June 1999 and to the remaining three charges a little way into the Crown case at trial. He was sentenced on 9 July 1999. The basis for the appeal against conviction was the contention that the search of the appellant's home, which led to the charges, was unlawful. The search was conducted on three successive days in June and July 1998, and no improper conduct by the police was suggested. The appellant also claimed he was poorly advised by his counsel at trial, pressured to plead guilty to assist his co-accused, who was his then partner and mother of their three children. The basis for the appeal against sentence was the contention that the sentencing Judge erred in taking a four-year starting point on the possession of Class B drugs for supply count, rather than a three-year starting point.

The appellant had previously applied for leave to appeal on 16 July 1999, which was declined in or about August 1999. An application for an adjournment was sought and declined on 16 March 2004, and the application for an adjournment was later renewed before the Court of Appeal. However, the Court of Appeal did not need to rule on the application for an adjournment or comment on the alleged lack of disclosure. The appeal against conviction and sentence was heard on 17 May 2004 by O'Regan J, Wild J, and Doogue J. The appellant was represented by B S Yeoman, and the Crown was represented by M F Laracy.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the search of the appellant's home which led to the charges was unlawful and if the trial Judge was wrong not to exclude the fruits of the search.
2. Whether the appellant was poorly advised by his counsel at trial and pressured to plead guilty to assist his co-accused.
3. Whether the sentencing Judge erred in taking a four-year starting point on the possession of Class B drugs for supply count, rather than a three-year starting point.

Held
1. The Court held that the search of the appellant's home which led to the charges was lawful, and the trial Judge did not err in not excluding the fruits of the search.
2. The Court found that the appellant was not poorly advised by his counsel at trial and there was no evidence to support that he was pressured to plead guilty to assist his co-accused.
3. The Court determined that the sentencing Judge did not err in taking a four-year starting point on the possession of Class B drugs for supply count, rather than a three-year starting point.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal reviewed the grounds for the appeal against conviction and sentence and found them to be unsubstantiated. Regarding the search of the appellant's home, the Court found no evidence to suggest that the search was unlawful, and thus the trial Judge's decision to not exclude the evidence obtained from the search was upheld. The appellant's claim that he was poorly advised by his counsel and pressured to plead guilty was dismissed as there was no evidentiary foundation for this claim. The Court noted that the appellant's experienced counsel and the appellant's early guilty pleas indicated a voluntary decision to plead guilty. As for the sentencing appeal, the Court examined the sentencing guidelines for drug offences and found that the four-year starting point imposed by the sentencing Judge was appropriate given the scale and nature of the drug operation uncovered. The Court concluded that the four-year starting point was within the sentencing range indicated by prior cases and that the discount for the appellant's guilty pleas was properly applied. Therefore, the application for leave to appeal both against conviction and sentence was dismissed, and the convictions and sentences stood.