IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC CRI 6/2004
THE QUEEN
v
ALAN IVO GREER
Coram:Elias CJ
Gault JCounsel:K D O'Brien for Applicant
S P France for Crown
Judgment:9 September 2004
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
[1] Alan Ivo Greer seeks leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a decision of the Court of Appeal delivered on 17 May 2004 dismissing his appeal against conviction and sentence on 12 counts. They were three counts of receiving, two counts of taking documents with intent to defraud, four drug offences (including possession of a Class B drug for the purposes of supply) and three counts under the Arms Act. On all counts he had pleaded guilty in the District Court at Palmerston North. Guilty pleas to nine of the counts were entered on arraignment. They included the drug charges and the Arms Act offences. Pleas to the remaining three charges were entered a day into the evidence at trial. The applicant was sentenced to a total of 3½ years imprisonment. The Court of Appeal decision was a re-hearing of an earlier ex parte determination.
[2] Written submissions have been received on behalf of the applicant and the respondent. We have concluded that it is unnecessary to require oral submissions.
[3] Four grounds for further appeal are put forward, three entailing challenges to the convictions and one being a challenge to the sentence.
[4] First it is asserted that the trial Judge wrongly admitted evidence from an unlawful search. The admission of such evidence is said to amount to a substantial miscarriage of justice. No basis for these assertions is identified in the submissions. Nor was any basis for the unlawfulness of the search of the applicant’s home identified in the Court of Appeal. Evidence was given at the trial of execution of three search warrants at the applicant’s home but no challenge to the evidence was made and no basis upon which the searches could be challenged for unlawfulness has been identified at any stage, including in the present application.
[5] The second ground sought to be advanced is that police radio communication transcripts and computer data were not fully disclosed to the defence. It is asserted that such disclosure would have been of benefit to the applicant in his defence “as it may have contributed to creating a reasonable doubt”. Questions as to disclosure were raised by the applicant before trial and answered by affidavit from the officer in charge. Some material was provided. No further steps were taken in relation to any information withheld. No basis upon which it might be suggested that further disclosure would have affected the guilty pleas or assisted in any defence are identified.
[6] The third ground raised is that the applicant was advised by his trial counsel to enter pleas of guilty to the nine counts to which he pleaded guilty before trial. It is asserted that the applicant was trying to protect his co-accused. These assertions are not supported by any…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Greer and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NZSC 10
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Supreme Court found that the first ground, regarding the admission of evidence from an unlawful search, had no basis. No evidence had been presented to show that the search was unlawful, and no basis for the unlawfulness of the search had been identified at any stage. The second ground, concerning incomplete disclosure of police radio communication transcripts and computer data, was also rejected. There was no evidence to show that further disclosure would have affected the guilty pleas or assisted in any defence. The third ground, regarding the advice given by Greer’s trial counsel to plead guilty, was not supported by any evidence. The Court of Appeal had noted that Greer’s counsel was very experienced and that Greer later entered guilty pleas on the remaining three counts. The final ground, regarding the severity of the sentence, was dismissed as the starting point for the sentence was within the range available to the sentencing judge. The Supreme Court concluded that none of the points put forward by Greer raised any issue of general or public importance, and the application for leave to appeal was dismissed.
The Supreme Court dismissed Greer’s application for leave to appeal against his conviction and sentence. The Court found that none of the grounds for further appeal raised any issue of general or public importance, and there was no basis for a substantial miscarriage of justice. The Court noted that the merits of the appeal had been fully considered on appeal to the Court of Appeal, and no basis for granting leave to appeal under s12 of the Supreme Court Act 2003 had been made out.
Background
Background to the litigation
Alan Ivo Greer, having previously had his appeal dismissed by the Court of Appeal, seeks leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New Zealand against the dismissal of his appeal. The Court of Appeal had re-heard the matter after an earlier ex parte determination. The Supreme Court received written submissions from both the applicant and the respondent and determined that oral submissions were unnecessary. The Supreme Court considered four grounds for further appeal, three concerning the convictions and one concerning the sentence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the trial Judge wrongly admit evidence from an unlawful search?
2. Were police radio communication transcripts and computer data not fully disclosed to the defence, which might have contributed to creating a reasonable doubt?
3. Was the applicant advised by his trial counsel to enter pleas of guilty to the nine counts to protect his co-accused?
4. Was the sentence imposed excessive, particularly the lead sentence of 3½ years for possession of a Class B drug for supply?
Held
1. The Supreme Court held that the trial Judge did not wrongly admit evidence from an unlawful search, as no basis for the unlawfulness of the search was identified.
2. The Supreme Court held that police radio communication transcripts and computer data were sufficiently disclosed to the defence, and no basis was provided to show that further disclosure would have affected the guilty pleas or assisted in any defence.
3. The Supreme Court held that the applicant was not advised by his trial counsel to enter pleas of guilty to protect his co-accused, as no evidence supported this assertion.
4. The Supreme Court held that the sentence imposed was not excessive, as the starting point for sentencing was within the range available to the sentencing Judge.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Supreme Court considered the application for leave to appeal and noted that the applicant's grounds for appeal did not raise any issue of general or public importance. Regarding the first ground, the court held that no basis was provided to show that the search of the applicant's home was unlawful, and therefore, the trial Judge's admission of evidence from that search was not erroneous. For the second ground, the court found that the defence was provided with sufficient disclosure of police radio communication transcripts and computer data, and no evidence was presented to suggest that further disclosure would have affected the outcome. The third ground, which claimed that the applicant was advised by his trial counsel to enter pleas of guilty to protect his co-accused, was dismissed for lack of evidence. Finally, the court concluded that the sentence imposed was within the appropriate range, and therefore, the sentence was not excessive. The Supreme Court decided that none of the points raised by the applicant warranted granting leave to appeal, and the application was dismissed. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Supreme Court will not grant leave to appeal if the applicant fails to demonstrate an issue of general or public importance, or a substantial miscarriage of justice.