R v F HC Nelson CRI 2007 042 3707

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CRI 2007 042 3707

THE QUEEN

v

F
B
A

S
 M

S
S

Hearing:         4 and 5 August 2008

Appearances: R G Marshall & T Boyd-Wilson for the Crown

S Zindel for B  , A   and M 
W Jones for S 
A J Bamford for S 
H Riddoch for S 

Judgment:      11 August 2008

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J (ON SECTION 347 APPLICATIONS)

[1]      The indictment in this matter originally included 24 counts, from which one has previously been severed.   The remaining counts relate to a series of alleged undertakings between February and October 2007, in which various of the accused

either conspired to supply Class A or Class B controlled drugs, supplied Class A or

R V F AND ORS HC NEL CRI 2007 042 3707  11 August 2008

Class B controlled drugs, were in possession of Class A controlled drugs, or sold

Class C controlled drugs.

[2]      On 4 and 5 August 2008, I heard a succession of applications under s 347 of the Crimes Act 1961, for discharge of various of the accused from various of the counts under which they are charged.  It is convenient to deal with the issues, as they were raised in respect of each accused in sequence.

[3]      The test I apply on these applications is that guided by the Court of Appeal’s reasoning in Parris v Attorney-General [2004] 1 NZLR 519, and most particular the oft-cited approach in paragraph [14] of that judgment:

The issue is not what the Judge may or may not consider to be the reasonable outcome.  Rather, and crucially it is whether as a matter of law a properly directed jury could reasonably convict.  Unless the case is clear-cut in favour of the accused, it should be left for the jury to decide.

[4]      Obviously, s 347 applications can be renewed, including during the trial, as matters develop.

Mr S 

[5]      After a review of all the material placing Mr S   in the context of the three conspiracy charges in counts 1, 4 and 11, Mr Marshall acknowledged that the challenge to his inclusion in those charges was appropriate, and the Crown did not oppose a s 347 discharge for Mr S   in respect of counts 1, 4 and 11 and I so order accordingly.

[6]      Of the balance of the charges Mr S   faces, Mr Riddoch accepted that a case could not be made out under s 347 in respect of counts 18, and 20 to 23 inclusive.

[7]      Accordingly, the terms of the remaining counts in the indictment in respect of which Mr S   seeks discharge are the following:

Misuse of Drugs Act 1975 S.6(1)(c)

9.        KERRY JOHN SIDWELL between the 5th  day of October 2007 and the 10th day of October 2007 at Nelson supplied the Class A controlled drug methamphetamine to person or persons unknown.

Misuse of Drugs Act 1975 S.6(1)(c)

10.      KERRY JOHN SIDWELL between the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v F HC Nelson CRI 2007 042 3707 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZHC 1271
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case before the High Court of New Zealand involved a series of charges related to drug offenses against several accused individuals, including conspiracy to supply and supply of Class A, B, and C controlled drugs. The Crown's case against the defendants involved intercepted communications, witness testimonies, and physical evidence such as the discovery of a point bag with traces of methamphetamine. The defendants sought discharge from various counts under Section 347 of the Crimes Act 1961, arguing that the charges were not adequately supported by evidence and that they should not be left to a jury's determination. The court examined the sufficiency of the evidence, the adequacy of the charges, and whether the defendants' inclusion in the conspiracy charges was justified.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether there was sufficient evidence to support the drug-related charges against each defendant and whether the charges themselves were adequately framed. In particular, the court had to determine if the defendants' involvement in the alleged conspiracies could be reasonably inferred from the evidence and if the charges were specific enough to ensure a fair trial. The court applied the test from Parris v Attorney-General, focusing on whether a properly directed jury could reasonably convict the defendants based on the presented evidence.

The court found that for most of the charges against the defendants, there was sufficient evidence to allow the case to proceed to a jury. The intercepted communications and other evidence provided a basis for the jury to infer the defendants' involvement in the drug supply activities. The court also concluded that the charges, while not perfectly detailed in some respects, were not deficient to the extent that they would cause material prejudice to the accused. Therefore, the court denied the applications for discharge under Section 347, allowing the case to proceed to trial.

In summary, the High Court of New Zealand determined that the evidence against the defendants was sufficient for the charges to be left to the jury, and the charges were adequately framed for the purposes of a fair trial. The defendants' applications for discharge were denied, and the case was set to proceed to trial with a pre-trial conference scheduled to facilitate the smooth running of the proceedings.