IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY
CRI-2010-012-5871
THE QUEEN
v
MAURICE DAVID DIDHAM
Hearing: 3 August 2011
Counsel: RD Smith for the Crown
WH Henderson for the prisoner
Judgment: 3 August 2011
SENTENCING NOTES OF RODNEY HANSEN J
Solicitors: Wilkinson Adams, P O Box 803, Dunedin 9054 for the Crown
WH Henderson, 109 George Street, Dunedin 9058 for the prisoner
R V MAURICE DAVID DIDHAM HC DUN CRI-2010-012-5871 3 August 2011
Introduction
[1] Mr Didham, you appear for sentence on one charge of cultivation of cannabis and one charge of possession of cannabis for supply. You pleaded guilty to those charges in the District Court. You have been committed for sentence to this Court because the District Court Judge thought the appropriate sentence may exceed his jurisdiction.
Agreed facts
[2] The factual background to the charges are as follows. On 23 November
2010, the police executed a search warrant at your home at Bradshaw Street in Dunedin. In a bathroom the police found an indoor cannabis-growing operation. There were 200 female cannabis seedlings growing in soil. They ranged from 10 -
30 cms in height. They appeared to have been growing for about four weeks. There was a light reflector and heat bulb over the plants, activated by automatic timers and heat pads under the plants.
[3] In the lounge the police found 657 grams (23.2 ounces) of dried cannabis head material, along with plastic ziplock bags and tin foil. There was a set of scales in the bedroom. You made frank admissions when spoken to by the police. You told the police you were growing the plants in three-month cycles in different stages so you had a continuous supply. You said you had been growing continuously for two or three years and each crop took 12–14 weeks. You said you harvested the plants before they reached full size and would get approximately $3,000 per cycle from a yield of 10–12 ounces per crop.
[4] You told the police you sold cannabis by the ounce at $300 per ounce. On that basis, the estimated value of the dried cannabis in your possession was $6,900.
Disputed facts
[5] The potential yield and value of the crop is a matter of considerable dispute. The police had estimated that each plant would yield four ounces of the valuable head material when fully grown. At a price of $300 per ounce, that would be $1,200 for each mature plant; 200 plants and the arithmetic is that there was a potential yield of $240,000 from the 200 seedlings in your possession. The police, however, accepted that it would not have been possible for those seedlings to have grown to maturity at your address. The premises were simply not set up for that purpose. Rather, it was in the nature of a nursery.
[6] As I have mentioned, your own advice to the police was very different. It was to the effect that the total yield from that number of plants, in your…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Didham HC Dunedin CRI-2010-012-5871 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NZHC 1587
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issue was to determine the appropriate sentence for Didham, considering the factors outlined in the Court of Appeal decision in R v Terewi. The court had to consider the number of plants, the sophistication of the growing operation, and the potential yield and value of the cannabis plants. The court also needed to take into account Didham's age, health issues, and his cooperation with the police.
Rodney Hansen J considered that the Crown's concession that the potential yield was as high as $240,000 was an appropriate and responsible one. The court determined that the starting point for sentencing should be no more than two years and six months imprisonment. The court took into account Didham's age, health issues, and the fact that he grew cannabis to supplement his pension and pay off debts. The court also considered that Didham was at low risk of reoffending and had family support available to him. The court decided to impose a sentence of eight months home detention, subject to specific conditions.
In summary, the court sentenced Didham to eight months home detention, considering the nature and extent of his offending, his age, health, and the potential yield and value of the cannabis plants found at his residence. The court took into account the factors outlined in R v Terewi and the mitigating factors presented by Didham's counsel. The court considered that a sentence of home detention was appropriate in this case, given Didham's low risk of reoffending and the availability of family support.