R v Davis HC Whangarei CRI-2009-029-990

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CRI-2009-029-990

THE QUEEN

v

NOREFJELL DEANA FAY DAVIS

Hearing:         14 July 2011

(Heard at Auckland)

Counsel:         M Smith for the Crown

B Sellars for Ms Davis

Judgment:      14 July 2011

SENTENCE OF WOODHOUSE J

Solicitors:

Mr M Smith, Marsden Woods Inskip & Smith, Office of the Crown Solicitor, Whangarei

Ms B Sellars, Barristers, Auckland

R V DAVIS HC WHA CRI-2009-029-990 14 July 2011

[1]      Ms Davis, you may remain seated until I come to impose the formal sentence.

Offences

[2]      You are to be sentenced for the manslaughter and the earlier ill-treatment of your daughter, Jacqui Petersen-Davis.   The maximum penalty for manslaughter is life  imprisonment.    The  maximum  penalty for  wilful  ill-treatment,  which  is  an offence against s 195 of the Crimes Act, is 5 years imprisonment.

[3]       As  I am sure you  will  now be well aware, there will be a sentence of imprisonment, and a lengthy sentence of imprisonment.  It is necessary to outline the background to this in some detail, and other relevant matters, in order to explain the sentence that I will impose. And it is in order to explain it to you, obviously, but also in order to explain it to your wider family, all of those connected with these events and to the community as a whole.

[4]      You were charged that you murdered your daughter, on or about 7 August

2009.  She was then aged 2 years and 4 months.  The ill-treatment charge was that, between 1 January 2009 and 6 August 2009, when Jacqui was in your custody, you wilfully ill-treated her in a manner likely to cause her actual bodily harm.

[5]      Following  a  trial  of  11  days  you  were  found  guilty  by  the  jury  of manslaughter and of the charge of ill-treatment.

Information for sentencing

[6]      I will outline the information available to me for the purposes of sentencing. As the Judge presiding at the trial I heard all the evidence.  I have received careful written submissions on sentence from your counsel, Ms Sellars, and from Mr Smith on behalf of the Crown.  This morning I have heard further oral submissions from both counsel on central issues.  I have received a victim impact statement from Jade Petersen, Jacqui’s father and your former partner.  I have a victim impact statement written on behalf of your daughter, L, aged 12 who is Jacqui’s half-sister, and your

son, C, aged 2 who is Jacqui’s full brother.  I have a pre-sentence report completed on 5 July 2011. And I have a detailed report from Ms Anne Huddleston, a registered clinical psychologist, who provided a report at my request pursuant to s 38 of the Criminal Procedure (Mentally Impaired Persons) Act 2003.

[7]      Ms Davis, I have taken account of all relevant information although I do not intend to seek to summarise all of it.

The background facts

[8]      I will outline the facts, including relevant background facts.

[9]      You met Jade Petersen, Jacqui’s father, in about…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Davis HC Whangarei CRI-2009-029-990 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 812
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Davis, heard by Justice Woodhouse in the High Court of New Zealand, involves Noreffjell Deana Fay Davis, who was charged with the manslaughter and wilful ill-treatment of her daughter, Jacqui Petersen-Davis. Davis was found guilty following an 11-day trial. The legal issues centered on determining an appropriate sentence considering the totality of the offending, including the pre-existing injuries, the assault that led to the child's death, and the mitigating factors presented by Davis's defense. The court had to balance the gravity of the crimes with personal factors that might reduce the sentence.

Justice Woodhouse thoroughly considered the evidence, including victim impact statements, a pre-sentence report, and expert psychological opinions. The court established a starting point of 10 years for the totality of the offending, recognizing the seriousness of the violence and the abuse of trust, but also acknowledging Davis's difficult personal circumstances, such as her troubled relationship with the child's father and her struggle to bond with Jacqui. Despite these factors, the court emphasized the gravity of Davis's actions, which involved repeated assaults and a callous disregard for her daughter's vulnerability. The sentence was ultimately set at 8 years and 6 months for manslaughter, with an additional concurrent 2-year sentence for wilful ill-treatment, and a minimum period of imprisonment of 4 years and 3 months to ensure accountability and denouncement of the conduct.

The final orders of the court reflect the severity of the crimes committed against a vulnerable child and the need to balance this with the personal mitigating factors presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established