IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WANGANUI REGISTRY
CRI-2009-083-0002241
THE QUEEN
v
JOSEPH EDWIN COTTER CHAD IAN MCRAE-TWEEDDALE KELLY MARGARET TYACKE
CRI-2009-083-0002894
THE QUEEN
v
CHAD IAN MCRAE-TWEEDDALE
Charges: 1. Wounds with intent to cause gbh (Cotter)
2. Wounds with reckless disregard (McRae-Tweeddale/Tyacke)
3. Assaults with intent to injure (manually)
4. Assaults with intent to injure (manually)
5. Wounds with intent to cause gbh (oth wpn) (McRae-Tweeddale)
6. Wounds with intent to injure (oth wpn) (McRae-Tweeddale)
Plea: Guilty
R V COTTER AND ORS HC WANG CRI-2009-083-0002241 21 May 2010
Counsel: H C Mallalieu for Crown
M J Bullock for Accused Cotter
R B Crowley for Accused Mcrae-Tweeddale
C P Brosnahan for Accused Tyacke
Sentence: 21 May 2010
1. Six years imprisonment (Cotter)
2.One year imprisonment (McRae-Tweeddale) Nine months home detention (Tyacke)
3. Nine months imprisonment (concurrent) (Cotter)
Six months imprisonment(concurrent) (McRae-Tweeddale) Nine months home detention (concurrent) (Tyacke)
4.Nine months imprisonment (concurrent) (Cotter) Six months (concurrent) (McRae-Tweeddale)
Nine months home detention (concurrent) (Tyacke)
5. Two years imprisonment (concurrent) (McRae/Tweeddale)
SENTENCING NOTES OF MACKENZIE J
[1] Joseph Edwin Cotter, Chad Ian McRae-Tweeddale and Kelly Margaret Tyacke you appear for sentence on a number of charges arising out of two incidents in August 2009.
[2] In August 2009 you were all living at an address in Rimu Street Wanganui. You Mr Cotter and you Mr McRae-Tweeddale have some association with the Wanganui chapter of the Hells Angels criminal gang. You Ms Tyacke are the de facto partner of Mr McRae-Tweeddale.
[3] In the evening of 15 August you Ms Tyacke and another woman became involved in a verbal altercation outside an address in Harper Street where a party was taking place. You returned to your home and a short time later all three of you went to the Harper Street address. You went in without invitation or authority. You behaved confrontationally and aggressively, looking for the persons involved in the verbal altercation. You Mr Cotter were carrying a pair of knuckle dusters. You approached a group of party goers and punched the first victim in the head causing him to fall to the ground. He received a broken nose, a cut to the bridge of his nose requiring three stitches, and a cut to the bottom of his nose which required a further
two stitches. You then struck the second victim on the head with a closed fist causing him to fall to the ground unconscious. You continued to punch and kick him several times around the head while he was on the ground. You then confronted a third victim, a young woman. You acted aggressively towards her and then punched her on the side of the head with a closed fist causing her to fall to the ground unconscious. The three of you left the address once police had been called. You each face three charges arising from that incident. Mr Cotter as the principal offender and the others as party to that offending.
[4] The second incident occurred on 28…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Cotter HC Wanganui CRI 2009-083-2241 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NZHC 786
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court involved assessing the severity of the crimes, the degree of participation and intent of each defendant, and the appropriate weight to give to mitigating factors such as early guilty pleas and the potential for rehabilitation. The court had to consider the nature and extent of the injuries inflicted, the role each defendant played, and the circumstances surrounding the offences, including the element of premeditation and the use of weapons.
Judge Mackenzie began by examining Cotter's role in the first incident, where he punched three victims, causing significant injuries. The judge noted the premeditated nature of the attack, the use of knuckle dusters, and the severity of the injuries inflicted. Despite Cotter's expressions of regret and a letter of remorse, the judge found that more substantial evidence of genuine remorse and a commitment to change was necessary before any reduction in sentence would be appropriate. The court sentenced Cotter to six years imprisonment for the most serious charge and nine months each for the other two charges, to be served concurrently.
For McRae-Tweeddale, the court considered his involvement in the first incident as a supportive participant and his separate assault in the second incident. The judge acknowledged McRae-Tweeddale's potential for rehabilitation and his limited prior criminal history but emphasised the seriousness of his involvement. The court sentenced McRae-Tweeddale to two years imprisonment for the most serious charge, one year for the reckless wounding charge, and six months for each assault charge, all to be served concurrently.
Tyacke, who was involved in the first incident but not the second, received a sentence of nine months home detention for each of her charges, reflecting her lower risk of reoffending and the potential for rehabilitation. The court imposed specific conditions for her home detention, including restrictions on alcohol and drug use and limitations on communication with certain individuals.
The court's final orders were that Cotter receive a total sentence of six years imprisonment, McRae-Tweeddale two years imprisonment, and Tyacke nine months home detention, all sentences to be served concurrently where applicable. The judge also took into account the early guilty pleas of the defendants, granting appropriate discounts to their sentences.