R v Coleman HC Wanganui CRI 2009-083-2069

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

WANGANUI REGISTRY

CRI-2009-083-002069

THE QUEEN

Appellant

v

CHARLENE ANN COLEMAN

Respondent

Hearing:         23 February 2010 (Heard at Wellington)

Counsel:         L Rowe for Crown

R B Crowley for Respondent

Judgment:      2 March 2010 at 3.15pm

In  accordance  with  r 11.5  I  direct  the  Registrar  to  endorse  this  judgment  with  a delivery time of 3.15pm on the 2nd  day of March 2010.

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF MACKENZIE J

[1]      This is a Crown appeal against  a  sentence  of  10  months  imprisonment

imposed on the respondent on one count of arson, one count of attempted arson and one count of driving with excess blood alcohol (third or subsequent offence).

[2]      The facts relating to the arson  and  attempted  arson  counts  were  that  on

19 August 2009 the respondent went to   a   residential   address   in   which   the

R V COLEMAN HC WANG CRI-2009-083-002069  2 March 2010

complainant, the complainant’s two daughters aged eight and two, and the complainant’s partner (the respondent’s  ex-partner) were asleep. She   placed cardboard cartons under  a vehicle in an open  garage underneath the house and set fire to the cartons.   She also put some cardboard cartons under a vehicle parked on the front lawn and set fire to those.  She then looked back at the garage and saw that the fire had taken hold of the vehicle and was beginning to take hold of the building. She alerted the neighbours to the fire and fled the scene. The neighbours woke the complainant and other occupants who escaped the address unharmed. The car in the garage  was  completely  destroyed and there was substantial damage to the  garage area  underneath  the  house. The car on the front lawn suffered only superficial damage. The respondent admitted lighting the fires.  In explanation she said that she was upset with her ex-partner and lit the fires on the spur of the moment to get back at him and the complainant for being in a relationship.  Damage caused amounted to approximately $45,500.

[3]      The excess blood alcohol count related to an incident on 30 July 2009 when Police were called as a result of erratic driving.   She was apprehended at her home sitting  in  her  vehicle  with  the  keys  still  in  the  ignition. A  blood  test  showed  a proportion of 122 milligrams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood.   This was her fourth such offence.

[4]      The respondent first appeared on  the  arson  and  attempted  arson  charge  on

20 August 2009. She subsequently appeared on the excess blood alcohol count on

15 September 2009.She sought  a  sentence  indication,  which  was  dealt  with  on

15 October 2009.    The  Judge  indicated  a  view  that  a  sentence  of  10  months imprisonment was likely.  The respondent subsequently entered guilty pleas and was sentenced on 22 October 2009.

[5]      In sentencing, Judge Radford considered the need to deter the respondent and others and denounce her behaviour, arson being an easy crime to commit but with potentially horrific consequences. He described the offending as very serious…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Coleman HC Wanganui CRI 2009-083-2069 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Crown appeals against the sentence imposed on Charlene Ann Coleman for one count of arson, one count of attempted arson, and one count of driving with excess blood alcohol (third or subsequent offence). The Crown argues that the 10-month imprisonment sentence, imposed following a guilty plea, was manifestly inadequate. The respondent committed arson by setting fire to two vehicles, one of which caused substantial damage to a garage and the other only superficial damage. The respondent also drove with a high blood alcohol level, her fourth such offence.

The appeal hinges on whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate or if there was an error in principle. The Crown argues that the sentence was inadequate, citing cases where higher sentences were imposed for similar offences. The respondent's counsel argues that the sentence reflects the discretion available to the sentencing judge, who considered the respondent's immediate change of heart and remorse as mitigating factors.

The court finds that the starting point of 17 months imprisonment, as determined by the sentencing judge, was not below the range appropriate for such offences. The judge's approach, which included generous discounts for the respondent's previous record and guilty plea, was within the sentencing judge's discretion. The court concludes that the sentence, while merciful, was not manifestly inadequate and that the appeal should be dismissed.

The appeal is dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established