IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CRI 2009-092-2198
THE QUEEN
v
MICHAEL CARTWRIGHT
Hearing: 18 March 2010
Appearances: G Kayes for Crown
G Gotlieb for Cartwright
Judgment: 18 March 2010
SENTENCING REMARKS OF ALLAN J
Solicitors:
Crown Solicitor Auckland G Gotlieb, Auckland
R V CARTWRIGHT HC AK CRI 2009-092-2198 18 March 2010
[ 1 ] Mr Cartwright, you appear for sentence having pleaded guilty on 18
December 2009 to two counts of arson and one count of manslaughter. The maximum penalty for arson is 14 years imprisonment and for manslaughter is life imprisonment.
Factual background
You committed these offences together with a young woman who is yet to be tried. Because your role was a limited one, it is important to outline the part you yourself played in what occurred.
You are now 19 years old. At the time of these unfortunate events you were 18. You had known your co-offender for about three weeks. She was simply one of a number of friends; there was no special relationship between you. During the evening of 19 January 2009, you were at your co-offender’s house along with several other friends. There, the group drank codies, which are a whisky and cola mix. There was also a bottle of absinthe, a drink which contains a very high proportion of alcohol and was being drunk with water.
During the evening there was a certain amount of coming and going among the group. For a time you were not in your co-offender’s company. But later in the evening you encountered her once more with a group of friends and made your way back to her place. As you walked, she complained about the behaviour of her former boyfriend, Brad. In particular she was critical of one incident which she described to you. After you had been back at her house for a time, she devised the idea of burning a t shirt belonging to Brad, which she had found on the floor. By this time you were both significantly intoxicated.
She first asked her boyfriend to accompany her outside in order to burn the t shirt, but he declined. When you were asked to go with her you agreed. You went out with her to the patio in front of her house; you were carrying the bottle of absinthe, from which you were drinking. Your co-offender had the t shirt and a
lighter. You understood the t shirt was to be lit outside her house, but instead your co-offender led you across the road towards Brad’s house. Although there was a car in the driveway you did not see any lights on in the house and did not know if anyone was home.
At her invitation, using the lighter, you lit the t shirt which your co-offender had placed on the front door mat. The flame simply flickered and died. Your co-offender told you to pour the absinthe onto the t shirt. You accept that you knew you were increasing the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Cartwright HC Auckland CRI 2009-092-2198 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NZHC 438
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was to determine the appropriate starting point for sentencing Cartwright, given the varying circumstances of similar cases, and to decide on the appropriate adjustments for aggravating and mitigating factors. The court also had to decide whether a sentence of home detention would be suitable, given the current unavailability of a suitable address.
The court began by identifying the manslaughter charge as the lead offence and set a starting point of five years imprisonment, reflecting Cartwright's relatively limited role in the events. The court acknowledged several mitigating factors, including Cartwright's youth, lack of prior convictions, compliance with strict bail conditions, his guilty plea, and his agreement to assist the Crown at his co-offender's trial. These factors resulted in a total discount of 60%, leading to an end sentence of two years imprisonment. However, due to the unavailability of a suitable address for home detention, the court imposed an immediate two-year prison sentence, with leave granted for a future application for home detention if a suitable address becomes available.
The final orders were that Cartwright be sentenced to two years imprisonment for manslaughter, with concurrent 12-month sentences for the two counts of arson, making the effective sentence two years imprisonment. The court also recommended participation in anger management and drug/alcohol counselling programmes. Additionally, pursuant to section 80I of the Sentencing Act, Cartwright was granted leave to apply for the cancellation of the imprisonment sentence and substitution with a sentence of home detention if a suitable residence becomes available.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi