R v Campbell HC Napier CRI 2009-069-2003

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CRI-2009-069-2003

THE QUEEN

v

EARL STRATHERN CAMPBELL

Hearing:         15 December 2010

Counsel:         C R Walker and J D Lucas for Crown

A Malik for Prisoner

Judgment:      15 December 2010

SENTENCING NOTES OF DOBSON J

Introduction

[1]      I have to sentence you this morning following the entry of a guilty plea for the aggravated robbery of an Armourguard van as its officers delivered money to the ANZ Bank in Hastings, and two related charges of arson and theft of a vehicle.  You also appear for sentence on one charge of escaping from custody, and three for resisting prison officers and a Court security officer.  As the charge for aggravated robbery is the most serious, I will take that as the lead offence.

Facts

[2]      Dealing with the facts briefly, on Monday 29 June last year, you and your associate, Mr Garnham, took a Subaru vehicle which had been previously stolen in

R V CAMPBELL HC NAP CRI-2009-069-2003 15 December 2010

preparation for the next day’s plan.  On Tuesday 30 June 2009, you and Mr Garnham drove to where that vehicle was, dressed in black, wearing black beanies with holes cut out for your eyes, and carrying a large sports bag and an unloaded pistol. Meanwhile your sister, Ms Hema, had positioned herself in a position to observe the movements of the Armourguard van.  She telephoned you when the van was nearing your position.

[3]      You then drove the stolen car to meet the Armourguard van.  As its officers got out of the van, Mr Garnham parked behind it and you got out of the car, with the pistol in your hand.  You ordered the Armourguard officers to put their hands above their heads and struck one of the officers on the forehead with the butt of your pistol. You then picked up the case containing cash canisters and ran back to the waiting vehicle.   Mr Garnham drove the two of you at speed while you placed the cash canisters into the sports bag. You then drove back to the vehicle you had used earlier that morning and you were at least a party to setting the stolen Subaru alight, and you both then left the scene.

[4]      You and Mr Garnham then drove to a property to which your father, Ricky Campbell, had access.   Ricky and you left that property and disposed of the cash canisters.  You then, later that day, met up with Mr Garnham at a motel room and, with a third man, counted the cash. You had taken some $156,000.

[5]      You have disputed elements of the Police summary of facts, intending to downplay your role because the Police summary treats you as being the principal offender.  First, your version reflected in the pre-sentence report and in Mr Malik’s submissions is that Mr Garnham was the first to suggest committing the robbery.  I have read all of the intercepted text messages and whilst that could literally be true, I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Campbell HC Napier CRI 2009-069-2003 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 2264
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Earl Strathern Campbell was sentenced by the High Court of New Zealand in Napier for multiple serious offences, including aggravated robbery, arson, theft, and escaping lawful custody. The court heard that Campbell and an associate had robbed an armoured guard van carrying substantial amounts of money, using a firearm and inflicting violence on the guards. The planning and execution of the crime demonstrated a high degree of preparation and risk. The court also considered related charges of arson and theft of a vehicle used in the robbery, as well as charges stemming from Campbell’s escape from custody and resisting arrest.

The legal issues included determining an appropriate starting point for the sentence, considering the aggravating and mitigating factors personal to the offender, and deciding on the imposition of a minimum period of imprisonment. The court applied the guidelines for sentencing, taking into account the nature and circumstances of the offences, the offender's criminal history, and the impact on the victims. The court also evaluated the relevance of a guilty plea entered close to the trial date.

The court reasoned that the starting point for the aggravated robbery should be nine and a half years, adjusted to ten years considering the concurrent sentences for related offences. Aggravating factors such as previous convictions and the lack of genuine remorse warranted a small increase, while the guilty plea led to a modest discount. The court ultimately sentenced Campbell to nine years and six months for the aggravated robbery, with concurrent sentences for related offences, and six months for escaping custody to be served cumulatively. The court decided against imposing a minimum period of imprisonment, hoping the lengthy sentence would encourage rehabilitation. A reparation order was also made, limited to the proceeds of the vehicles involved in the crime.