R v C HC Tauranga CRI 2008-270-361

Link copied
Case Copied 2 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CRI 2008-270-361

THE QUEEN

v

C AND LTW

Telephone Conference:     31 July 2009

Appearances:  D McWilliam for Crown

C J Tennet and A Steedman for Accused C 

G Tomlinson for Accused LTW Accused Ms C   also attending

Date of Minute:                31 July 2009

TELEPHONE CONFERENCE MINUTE OF RANDERSON J

Solicitors:   Ronayne Hollister-Jones Lellman, PO Box 13063, Tauranga 3141

C J Tennet, PO Box 12456, Wellington 6144

Gowing & Co, PO Box 548, Whakatane 3158

R V C AND LTW HC TAU CRI 2008-270-361  31 July 2009

[1]      There are two applications under s 344A Crimes Court 1961 to be heard in

Hamilton on 24/25 August 2009.

[2]      The first relates to a challenge by Ms C   to statements she made to the police.   Mr Tennet is acting as counsel on behalf of Ms C   and has indicated  his  willingness  to  conduct  the  trial  on  her  behalf  irrespective  of  the outcome of a pending legal aid application.   Ms C   confirms that she is comfortable with Mr Tennet acting on her behalf.

[3]      However, difficulties have been encountered in obtaining the services of an expert witness to assess Ms C  ’s cognitive abilities.  More time is needed for this to be attended to.   Mr McWilliam for the Crown does not oppose an adjournment of this s 344A application until a date in September.  Counsel consider that up to two days may be required.

[4]      Accordingly, I direct in respect of the first s 344A application that the hearing for 24/25 August be vacated.  The registrar is to make inquiries with a view to an alternative date (possibly in Auckland) in September.   This will be confirmed to counsel.  To check progress, there will be a further telephone conference in relation to that matter to be arranged for 10 am on Monday 24 August 2009 at the commencement of the hearing of the second application under s 344A which I will now deal with.

[5]      The  second  application  relates  to  a  challenge  by  the  accused  LTW  to evidence obtained under an interception warrant.   Counsel estimate that no more than  one  and  a  half  to  two  hours  should  be  required  for  this  application. Mr Tomlinson  has  filed  submissions  and  the  Crown  will  file  and  serve  its submissions  by  7  August  under  the  timetable  previously  set  by  Heath  J  on

10 July 2009.  No evidence is required other than that which is already on the file.

[6]      A trial date is set for 16 November 2009.  This is a murder charge involving two young people.   It is important that the trial proceed on that date and that all counsel and parties strive to achieve that end.

A P Randerson J Chief High Court Judge

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v C HC Tauranga CRI 2008-270-361 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZHC 1955
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves two applications under section 344A of the Crimes Act 1961, heard in a telephone conference on 31 July 2009. The first application pertains to Ms. C’s challenge to statements she made to the police, represented by Mr. Tennet, who has confirmed Ms. C’s willingness to proceed with the trial regardless of the outcome of a pending legal aid application. The second application concerns a challenge by the accused, LTW, to evidence obtained under an interception warrant, represented by Mr. Tomlinson. The Crown is represented by Mr. McWilliam.

The legal issues in the first application revolve around the admissibility of statements made by Ms. C to the police, with a focus on her cognitive abilities, which require expert assessment. This has led to difficulties in securing an expert witness, necessitating a delay in the application’s hearing. The second application deals with the admissibility of evidence obtained through an interception warrant, requiring timely submissions from both parties. The court must balance the need for an expeditious trial against the requirements of a fair hearing for both applications.

The court granted an adjournment for the first application to allow more time to secure an expert witness, directing the registrar to find an alternative date in September. For the second application, the court set a trial date for 16 November 2009, emphasizing the importance of proceeding as scheduled, while ensuring both parties have adequate time to file their submissions by 7 August 2009. The court scheduled a further telephone conference on 24 August 2009 to monitor progress.

The court ordered the first application’s hearing to be vacated from 24/25 August and set an alternative date for September, to be confirmed later. The second application’s hearing will proceed as scheduled, with a trial date set for 16 November 2009. The court also mandated that all parties strive to meet the trial date and ensure timely submission of legal arguments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established