R v Burton HC Ak CIV 2009-044-010515

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI 2008-044-010515

THE QUEEN

v

GRAEME WILLIAM  BURTON

Hearing:         19 February 2010

Appearances:  D A Bell for Crown

P H H Tomlinson for Prisoner

Judgment:      19 February 2010

SENTENCE OF RANDERSON J

Solicitors:       Crown Solicitors, PO Box 2213, Auckland 1140

P Tomlinson, PO Box 194, Auckland 1140

R V BURTON HC AK CRI 2008-044-010515  19 February 2010

Introduction

[1]      Mr Burton, on 11 November 2009 you were convicted after a jury trial of one count of attempting to murder a prisoner at the Paremoremo Prison on 20 December

2008.     The  maximum  sentence  for  that  offending  is  14  years’  imprisonment, although  I  also  have  the  power  to  impose  a  sentence  of  preventive  detention  if  I conclude that a sentence of that kind is necessary to protect the community.

Background facts

[2]      The facts established  at  trial  are  that,  sometime  prior  to  the  incident,  you obtained  a  stainless  steel  rod  approximately 300  mm  long  and  8  mm  in  diameter. One end of the rod had been sharpened to a point and the other had been wrapped to make a makeshift handle.  It is reasonable to infer that you hid this weapon (known in the prison as a shank), and another weapon, in your cell.

[3]      On the day of the incident, video surveillance footage showed you emerging from your cell when it was opened along with other cells in your block.   You had padded yourself up to avoid injury should the victim strike back.  The video footage showed you pursuing your victim up and down the landing outside the cells armed with a shank in each hand.  Although you have an artificial leg, this does not seem to have been any impediment to your actions that day.   You pursued the victim along the  length  of  the  landing  several  times,  the  victim  backing  away  from   you. Although, at one point, the victim grabbed a mop handle in order to defend himself, I have no doubt that you were the aggressor.   There was no evidence that the victim attacked you in any way.  Nor was there evidence of any provocation on his part.

[4]      The  video  footage  did  not  show  you  striking  any  blows,  but  when  prison officers came to the scene, the victim was pulled to safety, exhibiting multiple cuts to his t-shirt and substantial bloodstaining.   In all, there were some 27 wounds to the victim’s chest, shoulders, arms and legs.  It was not in dispute at trial that you caused these wounds.

[5]      The surgeon  who treated the victim said that two of the three blows to the chest were relatively superficial, but the third was nearly fatal.   It was a wound of two to three centimetres in depth through the ribs on the left side of the chest and into the heart.  The wound was about one centimetre wide.

[6]      The Crown case was that, if a man stabbed another in the vicinity of a vital organ  such  as  the  heart,  an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Burton HC Ak CIV 2009-044-010515 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, sentenced Graeme William Burton for the attempted murder of a fellow prisoner at Paremoremo Prison on 20 December 2008. The court was required to decide on an appropriate sentence, considering the severity of the crime, Burton's history of violent offending, and the risk he posed to the community. The legal issues included whether a finite sentence or preventive detention was more appropriate, and if so, the minimum term of imprisonment.

The court reasoned that Burton's attack on a fellow inmate, while in custody for other violent offences, was deliberate, premeditated, and determined. The court accepted the Crown's identification of aggravating factors, including the use of two lethal weapons, the high level of violence, and the absence of any provocation or retaliation from the victim. The court also considered Burton's extensive history of serious violence, his failure to address the causes of his criminal behaviour, and the expert evidence indicating a high risk of future violent offending. The court concluded that a sentence of preventive detention was appropriate to protect the public and the prison community, and a minimum period of imprisonment of ten years was suitable given the gravity of the offence and the risks Burton posed to public safety.

The final orders of the court were that Burton be sentenced to preventive detention on the charge of attempted murder, with a minimum period of imprisonment of ten years, to run concurrently with the sentences he was presently serving. The court also ordered the destruction of the weapons used in the commission of the offence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established