R v Brown HC Auckland CRI 2008-004-22829

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2008-004-022829

THE QUEEN

v

PAUESI LEOFA BROWN

Charges:         Murder

Assault with a weapon

Plea:               Guilty

Appearances: A Perkins and R Savage for Crown

B J Hart and A J Haskett for Prisoner

Sentenced:     10 December 2010

Murder – life imprisonment, minimum non-parole period of 16 years
Assault with a weapon – 2 years’ imprisonment concurrent

SENTENCING NOTES OF VENNING J

Solicitors:           Crown Solicitor, Auckland

Copy to:            B J Hart, Auckland

A J Haskett, Auckland

R V BROWN HC AK CRI-2008-004-022829  10 December 2010

[1]      Pauesi Leofa Brown, you are for sentence this morning having pleaded guilty to the murder of Austin Hemmings and the assault of Ms Nonu with a weapon.

[2]      Just as a preliminary matter can I address the media and remind you that the sentence  the Court  will  impose on  Mr  Brown  for  murder  is  a sentence of  life imprisonment.    There  has  been  discussion  this  morning  and  in  this  sentencing decision  I  will  discuss  and  fix  a  minimum  non-parole  period.    However,  the minimum non-parole period is just that.   It is a condition of the sentence but the actual sentence for murder in New Zealand is life imprisonment and that is the sentence that will be imposed.  At times that does seem to rather become lost in the reports of the sentencing process.  I am sure it would be of assistance to the public for whom you are the ears and eyes, if that matter was made clear and I would appreciate it if it was.

[3]      Also before I proceed with the sentence and matters counsel have addressed to me, I do want to acknowledge the presence in Court of Mr Hemmings’ family, in particular his wife and children and also Ms Nonu, the other victim in this matter. The victim impact statements, relating to Mr Hemmings, paint a picture of a man who had already given much to his family, and also to the business and social community and a man who still had much to offer.  Considering the loss you have suffered  your  victim  impact  statements  were  expressed,  if  I  might  say  so,  in restrained and insightful terms.

[4]      As far as you are concerned, a loved husband, father, son and brother has been  taken  from  you.    The  sentence  that  this  Court  imposes  on  Mr  Brown  is society’s response, through the judicial system, to his action of killing Austin Hemmings.  It is not meant to be, and it could never be, a measure of the value of Mr Hemmings’ life.

[5]      Mr Brown, the circumstances which led to your killing Mr Hemmings, your assault on Ms Nonu and your being before this Court this morning for sentence are as follows.

[6]      In September 2008 you were in a relationship with a Ms Ioane.  She worked in a call centre in a building off Queen Street.  Her work was on an upstairs floor in an office that backed onto and overlooked Mills Lane.  She worked there with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Brown HC Auckland CRI 2008-004-22829 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 2220
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Brown, heard in the High Court of New Zealand in Auckland, involved Pauesi Leofa Brown, who pleaded guilty to the murder of Austin Hemmings and the assault of Ms Nonu with a weapon. The central legal issue was determining the appropriate minimum non-parole period for Brown's life sentence for murder, considering the specific circumstances of the offence and Brown's personal history. The court had to decide whether certain provisions of the Sentencing Act applied, particularly those demanding a minimum term of imprisonment, and if not, what the appropriate term should be.

The court evaluated whether section 104 of the Sentencing Act applied, which mandates a minimum non-parole period of at least 17 years unless manifestly unjust. The Crown argued for its application due to the exceptional nature of the crime and the intervention by Hemmings, who acted as a good Samaritan. However, the court found the circumstances, while tragic, not exceptional enough to trigger this section. The court also considered whether section 104(1)(d) applied, requiring a prior serious offence, but found it did not apply based on the Crown's concessions.

Ultimately, the court determined the appropriate minimum non-parole period under section 103, focusing on holding Brown accountable, denouncing the conduct, deterring similar offences, and protecting the community. The court found the circumstances of the offence, including Brown's propensity for violence and use of a knife, warranted a 14-year minimum non-parole period, with an additional uplift due to Brown's extensive criminal history, leading to a total of 16½ years. However, considering Brown's late guilty plea and lack of genuine remorse, the court reduced this period to 16 years. Brown was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder, with a concurrent two-year sentence for the assault, and a minimum non-parole period of 16 years.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established