R v Bragger HC Wellington Cri-2010-091-4438

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI-2010-091-004438

THE QUEEN

v

SUSAN LAURA BRAGGER SEAN MICHAEL HAWKE

Counsel:         G J Burston and S McLean for Crown

I M Antunovic for Prisoner Bragger
V C Nisbet for Prisoner Hawke

Judgment:      17 February 2011

SENTENCING NOTES OF GENDALL J

[1]      Susan Laura Bragger and Sean Michael Hawke, you appear for sentence each having pleaded guilty to the crime of conspiring to cause grievous bodily harm, with intent that such grievous bodily harm be caused to a young man, Raymond Piper. Even though the maximum penalty for causing grievous bodily harm with intent is

14 years’ imprisonment,  the  law  provides  that  where  the  charge  is  only one  of conspiracy to commit that crime, then the maximum penalty is only seven years’ imprisonment.

[2]      The facts upon which I sentence you are as follows.   Raymond Piper was aged 23 and a young man who had been in a relationship for three years with your daughter Mrs Bragger, and they had a young son, he being your grandson.  Perhaps the relationship was turbulent.   Mr Hawke, you are Mrs Bragger’s brother, so the

uncle of her daughter.  On 17 April 2010 there was a 21st birthday celebration, which

was held at Mrs Bragger’s home.  An altercation involving a friend of the Bragger

R V BRAGGER HC WN CRI-2010-091-004438 17 February 2011

family and Mr Piper occurred.  Mrs Bragger for some time had not viewed Mr Piper in a favourable light, and she considered that misbehaviour at the party was the “last straw”.  So she later discussed with her brother, Mr Hawke, about how they might remove Mr Piper from the life of their daughter and niece.  They discussed finding someone  to  deal  to  him  and  Mr  Hawke  offered  to  Mrs  Bragger,  to  make arrangements for this.

[3]      Certain text messages have been read by the Crown prosecutor and I do not need to repeat them in any detail.  But it is clear that Mr Hawke told Mrs Bragger that he would sort it out and contacted a man named Anderson, and Mr Hawke asked Mrs Bragger, or words to the effect, if she wanted Mr Piper put “in hospital and have cash”.   Haggling occurred over the contract price.   Mrs Bragger advised that she could pay $4,000 if necessary but Mr Hawke, on her behalf, offered Mr Anderson

$3,500 which he accepted and an agreement or contract, if you could put it that way, was that something serious would happen to Mr Piper.  Mrs Bragger’s response was that she “definitely” wanted it to happen provided it was not linked to her and that it did  not  take  place  in  front  of  her  daughter  and  grandson.   As  a  consequence, Mrs Bragger met Mr Anderson, who really was a violent thug, and paid him $3,500. There were some later communications between Mrs Bragger and Mr Hawke as to picking the right time at which the planned attack on Mr Piper by Mr Anderson would occur.

[4]      On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Bragger HC Wellington Cri-2010-091-4438 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Susan Laura Bragger and Sean Michael Hawke were sentenced in the High Court of New Zealand for conspiring to cause grievous bodily harm to Raymond Piper, with intent to cause such harm. The maximum penalty for this crime is seven years’ imprisonment. Bragger and Hawke plotted to hire a man named Anderson to assault Piper, with Bragger paying Anderson $3,500 for his services. Anderson violently assaulted Piper, resulting in his death. Bragger and Hawke did not anticipate that their actions would lead to Piper's death.

The court considered the personal circumstances of both defendants, noting that neither had previous convictions and were generally of good character. However, the court emphasised the premeditated and appalling nature of their conspiracy. Bragger and Hawke both expressed remorse for their actions. The court also considered the victim impact statements from Piper's family, which illustrated their outrage and anguish over the events that led to Piper's death.

The court determined a starting point of four years’ imprisonment for both Bragger and Hawke, with a discount for Bragger due to her claim that she withdrew from the conspiracy before the attack was carried out. The court applied discounts for their guilty pleas and remorse, resulting in a final sentence of three years’ imprisonment for both defendants. The court emphasised that the sentence must fit the crime of conspiracy and reflect the offenders' background and community expectations. The court also noted that the sentence was necessary to hold the defendants accountable, denounce their conduct, and deter others.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established