R v Bennett HC Auckland CRI 2009-292-59

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2009-292-000059

THE QUEEN

v

B

Hearing:         23 July 2010

Appearances: K J Glubb and S A Mandeno for Crown

C H B   for Prisoner
C Bradley for TVWorks Limited

Judgment:      23 July 2010

Reasons:        27 July 2010

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF VENNING J

Solicitors:           Crown Solicitor, Auckland

Copy to:            C H B  , Auckland

C Bradley, TVWorks Ltd, Auckland

R V B HC AK CRI-2009-292-000059  23 July 2010

[1]      In a result judgment delivered on 23 July 2010 I declined TV3’s request for access to the DVD recording the police interview with the prisoner B  . These are the reasons for that judgment.

The application

[2]      The application is made under r 13(2)(b) Criminal Proceedings (Access to Court  Documents)  Rules  2009.    The  DVD  record  is  within  the  definition  of document in the Rules which includes exhibits and video recordings and records in electronic form.

[3]      The  applicant  seeks  the  DVD  to  play it  in  a  current  affairs  programme investigating the circumstances of the offending in this case.

[4]      The application is opposed by both the Crown and counsel for the prisoner, on the following grounds:

•         the age of the prisoner;

•the   personal   circumstances   of   the   prisoner   as  discussed   in   a psychiatric report from Dr Duff;

•         that the DVD interview was obtained in the first instance for use in

Court;

•         the prisoner does not consent to its use or further distribution;

•the DVD interview does not disclose any admission of guilt in this case;

•there is sufficient background in the summary of facts to which the prisoner pleaded guilty and in the transcript of the DVD interview itself.

•there is no need to access the DVD itself to accurately report the circumstances of the offending;

•disclosure would be a disincentive to people in the prisoner’s situation making statements to the police.

[5]      The matters to be taken into account on an application such as this are set out in r 16 as follows:

16       Matters to be taken into account

In determining an application under rule 13, or a request for permission under rule 8 or 9, or the determination of an objection under those rules, the Judge or other judicial officers or Registrar must consider the nature of, and the reasons for, the application or request and take into account each of the following matters that is relevant to the application, request, or objection:

(a)       the right of the defendant to a fair hearing: (b)      the orderly and fair administration of justice:

(c)       the protection of confidentiality, privacy interests (including those of children and other vulnerable members of the community), and any privilege held by, or available to, any person:

(d)       the principle of open justice, namely, encouraging fair and accurate reporting of, and comment on, trials and decisions:

(e)       the freedom to seek, receive, and impart information:

(f)       whether a document to which the application or request relates is subject to any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Bennett HC Auckland CRI 2009-292-59 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1319
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Bennett involved a decision by the High Court of New Zealand Auckland Registry. The central issue was whether TV3, a media company, should have access to a DVD recording of a police interview with the prisoner, Ms B. This request was made under the Criminal Proceedings (Access to Court Documents) Rules 2009. The application was opposed by both the Crown and Ms B’s counsel on several grounds, including the age of Ms B, her personal circumstances, and the potential negative impact on her rehabilitation.

The court was required to balance various factors, including the right of the defendant to a fair hearing, the orderly and fair administration of justice, the protection of privacy interests, and the principles of open justice and freedom of information. The court considered whether access to the DVD could deter future cooperation with the police, the potential privacy interests of Ms B, and the implications for her rehabilitation. The court also noted that the media had already been present during sentencing and had access to the summary of facts and the transcript of the DVD interview.

In its decision, the court found that while the principles of open justice and freedom of information were important, the primary consideration was the community’s interest in Ms B’s rehabilitation. The court was particularly influenced by a psychiatric report indicating that further publicity could reinforce Ms B’s attention-seeking behavior and potentially harm her rehabilitation. The court concluded that the risk of negative repercussions outweighed the benefits of allowing access to the DVD, leading to the denial of the application. The court made no order for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established