R v Bain HC CHCH CIV 2007-412-000014

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF THE JUDGMENT AND ANY PART OF THE PROCEEDINGS (EXCEPT FOR THE RESULTS AS SET OUT IN THE ACCOMPANYING PRESS RELEASE ) IN NEWS MEDIA OR ON INTERNET OR OTHER PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATABASE UNTIL FINAL DISPOSITION OF TRIAL.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CRI 2007-412-000014

REGINA

v

DAVID CULLEN BAIN

Hearing:         12 and 13 May 2008

Counsel:         K Raftery, C Mander and R P Bates for Crown

M Reed QC, H A Cull QC and P A Morten for Defence

Judgment:      19 May 2008

JUDGMENT OF PANCKHURST J

Introduction

[1]      The week commencing 12 May was scheduled for the hearing of pre-trial applications, including a stay application and a s344A application as to the admissibility of certain evidence.  In the event, and for reasons to which I will refer shortly, neither of the two main applications were ready for hearing.

[2]      Nonetheless I heard argument referable to several issues.   This judgment contains  rulings  upon  an  application  to  further  adjourn  the  trial,  an  argument

R V DAVID CULLEN BAIN HC CHCH CRI 2007-412-000014  19 May 2008

concerning  whether  the  Evidence  Act  2006  applies  to  the  retrial  or  not  and concerning a dispute as to the further testing of a skin sample, to which both the Crown and the defence wish to have access.   I shall also refer to questions raised with reference to disclosure, the preliminary examination of new Crown witnesses, particulars of the Crown case, an indicated stay application and a contention of possible conflict of interest affecting myself.

Adjournment of the trial

[3]      The Privy Council decision by which the convictions were quashed and a retrial ordered, was delivered on 10 May 2007.   On 21 June the Solicitor-General announced his decision that a retrial would proceed.

[4]      On 26 July I held the first telephone conference with counsel.  A subsequent minute arising from that conference fixed a trial date of 5 May 2008.  A timetable was also prescribed which required that Crown witness statements were to be provided  by early  November,  venue  and  stay  applications  were  to  be  filed  for hearing in December and that if the defence adhered to its intention to seek to examine new witnesses pursuant to s178 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957, it was “imperative” that any such application be filed in a timely manner.

[5]      Following   a   further   telephone   conference   I   issued   a   minute   dated

2 November which recorded that the Crown had provided witness statements for the persons it intended to call at the retrial, although 13 of the statements remained to be signed.  A reservation was also expressed that testing, or retesting, of exhibits (which had earlier been foreshadowed) could result in some further or amended witness statements.   Despite a defence protest that it was not possible to file pre-trial applications in this situation, I directed their filing by the end of November.  Such did not occur.

[6]      On 6 December, following a further telephone conference, I again directed that the indicated stay and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Bain HC CHCH CIV 2007-412-000014 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZHC 2334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court was Regina v David Cullen Bain. The matter was a retrial of David Bain who had previously been convicted of the murders of his parents, sister, and brother in 2001. The Privy Council had quashed Bain's convictions and ordered a retrial. The case raised issues concerning the admissibility of evidence, the application of the Evidence Act 2006 to the retrial, and the further testing of a skin sample. The court heard argument concerning a possible stay of proceedings and other pre-trial applications. The court further adjourned the trial date from 11 August 2008 to 16 February 2009 due to the need for further forensic testing and evaluation of evidence by defence counsel. The court found that the Evidence Act 2006 applied to the retrial. The court also ruled that the Crown could conduct further testing of the skin sample in whatever manner it deemed best. The court heard submissions on disclosure, examination of new witnesses, particulars of the Crown case, and a potential conflict of interest. The court directed a telephone conference to manage any remaining pre-trial issues.