R v B HC Wellington CRI 2008-085-8760

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI 2008-085-8760

THE QUEEN

v

B

Hearing:         19 June 2009

Counsel:         G A Kelly for Crown

K Jefferies for Accused

Sentence:       19 June 2009

SENTENCE OF SIMON FRANCE J

[1]       Mr B    appears  for  sentence  on  three  charges  involving  cannabis dealing.  He appears in this Court because the District Court declined jurisdiction.

[2]       The charges are:

a)        possession of a Class C controlled drug (cannabis) for the purpose of supply;

b)        sale of a Class C controlled drug (cannabis); and

c)        conspiracy to sell the same drug.

R V B HC WN CRI 2008-085-8760  19 June 2009

[3]      The offending began in 2007 but seems to have mainly occurred in mid 2008.

[4]      You sourced your cannabis from a group operating out of Westport.  The first two purchases were for one pound and two pounds respectively.  You then on-sold these still in the bulk quantities.   On the third occasion you became the retailer, selling two pounds to about ten clients.  From these three transactions you made a profit of $6,600.  I note here in passing your admissions on arrest suggest one further purchase of another pound.

[5]      Then November 2008 your car was stopped after you had made yet another purchase.   On this occasion you had three pounds of cannabis in your possession. You were going to on-sell it as retailer to your small group of clients.

[6]      The conspiracy charge relates to the operation occurring in Westport.   It involved growing the cannabis, and then selling it.  Over and above the purchases, your involvement seems to have been to rent one of the properties, which was used to grow cannabis.  You deny knowledge of what was happening with the property, but have pleaded guilty to participation in the wider conspiracy.  It is not suggested you  were  to  profit  from  the  conspiracy other  than  through  whatever  deals  you personally did.

Personal circumstances

[7]      You are forty-one, single, self-employed with two children from a previous marriage.  You have been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder as a result of events when you were younger.   It is said that this led to the breakdown of your marriage when you began to deal with the issues many years later.  You have also been  diagnosed  with  a  major  depressive  episode  in  December 2008.     Your relationship with both your parents is described as unsatisfactory and the psychological reports suggest that that has contributed to your difficulties.  You are a regular of  cannabis to the point of being dependent  on  it.    You  have  a  varied employment and business history but currently manage a successful business organising motor cross events.

[8]      The psychologist considers that your offending was out of character and can be understood within the context of the psychological factors she identifies.

[9]      The pre-sentence report confirms your background and notes that you accept responsibility for your offending, which displayed poor decision making and the influence of associates.  You have never previously appeared…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v B HC Wellington CRI 2008-085-8760 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZHC 1810
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The defendant, B, was sentenced in the High Court of New Zealand, Wellington Registry, for three charges related to cannabis dealing. The charges were possession of a Class C controlled drug (cannabis) for the purpose of supply, sale of the same drug, and conspiracy to sell the same drug. The District Court had declined jurisdiction, leading to the case being heard in the High Court. B was sentenced on 19 June 2009.

The legal issues before the court involved determining an appropriate starting point for the sentence, considering the defendant's peripheral role in the conspiracy, his early pleas, genuine remorse, and personal circumstances. The court needed to balance the principles of deterrence and rehabilitation in sentencing, particularly given B's involvement in the conspiracy and his psychological issues.

The court established a starting point of two years, nine months for the possession and sale offences, considering recent Court of Appeal decisions. The conspiracy charge added six months to the starting point, making it three years, three months. After applying a one-third discount for early pleas, the sentence was reduced to twenty-six months. The court acknowledged the technical requirement for a sentence of two years or less for home detention but considered the personal circumstances and the defendant's low risk of re-offending. The court concluded that home detention was an appropriate sentence and imposed concurrent terms of twelve months’ home detention on each charge, with specific standard and special conditions.