R v A HC Rotorua CRI 2006-070-7259

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CRI 2006-070-7259

THE QUEEN

v

A
F
T

Hearing:         5 May 2008

Appearances: H Wrigley for the Crown

A Balme and S Whitehead for accused A 
C Horsley for accused F 
W Nabney for accused T 

Judgment:      5 May 2008

(ORAL) RULING [1] OF STEVENS J

Solicitors/Counsel:

Crown Solicitor, PO Box 13 063, Tauranga
A Balme, PO Box 13 079, Tauranga
C Horsley, PO Box 699, Tauranga

W Nabney, PO Box 13 007, Tauranga

R V A AND ORS HC ROT CRI 2006-070-7259  5 May 2008

Introduction

[1]      The three accused Messrs F   and T   and Ms A   are charged

inter alia with three offences contrary to the provisions of s 45 of the Arms Act

1983.   The Crown alleges that the three accused were jointly in possession with Manjit Singh (who has pleaded guilty to the three charges) of three firearms found in a van stopped by the Police in Tauranga on 18 November 2006.

[2]      Mr Nabney for the accused, Mr T  , raised an objection prior to  the Crown calling Detective Constable Curragh.  Mr Nabney challenged a portion of the evidence about to be given.  A voir dire was held to determine the admissibility of the  evidence.    The  Detective  Constable  outlined  the  relevant  portions  of  her proposed evidence.  She was then cross-examined by defence counsel.

[3]      In summary, the Detective Constable’s evidence is that she was carrying out surveillance using the security cameras in the Hotel on Devonport on the evening of

17 November 2006.   During the time when she was carrying out surveillance she saw a vehicle, which appeared to be driven by a male, enter the carpark.  She is able to describe the van and the fact that the four occupants that emerged from the van, one female and three males, all then walked into the hotel.

[4]      The  Detective  Constable  continued  with  her  surveillance  and  observed, through the video footage, that the vehicle left the hotel at 2.11am via The Strand extension.   The crucial portion of evidence then follows, namely, that “the same male person who was driving the vehicle into the hotel drove the vehicle out”.

Submissions for the defence

[5]      The key ground of the objection raised by Mr Nabney was that the evidence was opinion evidence and that it was not sufficient to enable the Crown to invoke the presumption in s 66 of the Arms Act.  This statutory presumption would apply in the circumstances of this case if the Crown were able to prove, beyond reasonable doubt, the identity of the driver of the vehicle at the time it was later stopped.  Mr Nabney

submitted that the challenged evidence did not meet the threshold for relevance under the Evidence Act 2006 (the Act).

[6]      For completeness, the presumption applicable to the drivers of vehicles under s 66 of the Arms Act may assist in proof of the three counts in the indictment of possession of pistols…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v A HC Rotorua CRI 2006-070-7259 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZHC 2305
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The three accused, Messrs F, T and Ms A, were charged with three offences under the Arms Act 1983. The Crown alleged that the accused were jointly in possession of three firearms found in a van stopped by police in Tauranga. The case before the court revolved around the admissibility of evidence provided by Detective Constable Curragh, who had observed the van and its occupants via surveillance footage from a hotel on Devonport. The accused's counsel argued that the evidence was opinion evidence and did not meet the threshold for relevance under the Evidence Act 2006. The Crown, on the other hand, contended that the evidence was relevant and could form part of the pool of evidence to establish the identity of the driver. The court held that the evidence was relevant as it had a tendency to prove matters of consequence to the determination of the proceedings. The evidence of the detective established what she saw via surveillance when the van arrived at the carpark and when the occupants got out of the van. The court ruled that the Crown was permitted to lead the evidence from Detective Constable Curragh. The application of the presumption under section 66 of the Arms Act was reserved for later in the trial. The court held that the Crown could establish the identity of the driver not only by direct observations of opinion but also by matters of circumstantial evidence or other direct evidence tending to exclude the remaining individuals in the van.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established