R v A HC Invercargill CRI 2009-025-995

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

CRI 2009-025-000995

REGINA

v

A

Hearing:         17 and 27 November 2009

Counsel:         JNP Young for Crown

W N Dawkins for Prisoner

Judgment:      27 November 2009

SENTENCING REMARKS OF FOGARTY J

[1]      A   you have pleaded guilty to a charge that having under your control a motor vehicle which in the absence of precautional care may endanger human life and then under a legal duty to take reasonable care to avoid such danger did admit without lawful excuse to discharge that duty thereby causing the death of Mrs Lenore Carr and thereby committed manslaughter.   That is the nature of the charge which I will have occasion, really for the benefit of the lawyers, to refer to in a moment.

[2]      On Saturday evening, 13 September 2008, you had been socialising with your partner at your friend’s house in Crawford Street in this city.  During the course of that evening you had drunk between three and six stubbies of beer and one or two

RTDs.  At about 3.00 am in the morning you and your partner had returned home to

R V A HC INV CRI 2009-025-000995  27 November 2009

Lyon Street.   Soon after arriving home an argument started in the bedroom.   It resulted in you being struck in the face by your partner giving you a bleeding nose. You became angry and upset.   You smashed three windows in the laundry area before leaving your home in your car and going back to your friend’s house at Crawford Street.  A man at Crawford Street assisted you cleaning up your bloody nose and suggested you stay there.  But then you left and went back to your home. There you spoke to some pedestrians, perhaps at the time when you were putting your partner’s dog in your car.  You asked the pedestrians to ring the police and that presumably was in respect of the assault that you had suffered just prior.    Then as you were reversing out of the drive onto Lyon Street, planning to leave, your partner appeared out of the house and spread-eagled himself on the bonnet of your car.  You reversed at speed onto Lyon Street, your partner falling off the bonnet onto the road. You continued reversing at speed for approximately 70 metres down Lyon Street and then drove into Cree Street before returning to check your partner was okay.  You could not find him.

[3]      You then drove north on Lyon Street towards St Andrew Street and turned west into St Andrew Street.  At the same time Mrs Carr, who had been called out by her son to pick him up, was driving down St Andrew Street.  It is not entirely clear to me how the first ramming of her car took place but it is quite clear there were two rammings of the car.  The second one seems to have taken place, judging from my inspection of the police evidence, some time later, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v A HC Invercargill CRI 2009-025-995 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZHC 2388
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand at Invercargill, the court heard the case of Regina v A, where the defendant pleaded guilty to a charge of manslaughter by dangerous driving. The defendant had driven recklessly, causing the death of Mrs Lenore Carr. The court was tasked with determining an appropriate sentence, considering both aggravating and mitigating factors. The defendant had no prior convictions but had engaged in dangerous driving, including a prolonged pursuit of Mrs Carr's vehicle after two rear-end collisions. This pursuit, combined with the excessive speed and the defendant's state of mind following an assault by their partner, were significant aggravating factors. Mitigating factors included the defendant's genuine remorse, their early guilty plea, and the absence of a significant history of dangerous driving.

The court noted the wide disparity in sentencing for similar offenses and highlighted the challenges in reconciling these sentences. It observed that while Parliament had established a maximum penalty for reckless driving causing death, courts were increasingly imposing sentences exceeding this limit. The court suggested that Parliament review its policy on reckless driving causing death to provide clearer guidance. After considering the aggravating and mitigating factors, the court decided on a starting point of seven years imprisonment, reduced to six years by the mitigating factors, and further reduced to four years and ten months by the defendant's guilty plea. The defendant was also disqualified from driving for five years.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established