R T Vincent Limited v Watts & Hughes Construction Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-4420 [2015] NZHC 424

BETWEEN

R T VINCENT LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

WATTS & HUGHES CONSTRUCTION LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 1 December 2014

Appearances:

C R Pidgeon QC for Plaintiff
R E Kettelwell and R E Catley for Defendant

Judgment:

10 March 2015

JUDGMENT OF PETERS J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Peters on 10 March 2015 at 4.45 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date: ...................................

Solicitors:           Cargill Stent Law Limited, Taupo

Sharp Tudhope, Tauranga

Counsel:            C R Pidgeon QC, Auckland

R T VINCENT LTD v WATTS & HUGHES CONSTRUCTION LTD [2015] NZHC 424 [10 March 2015]

[1]      The Plaintiff (“Vinteq”) seeks leave to apply for summary judgment and, if leave is granted, summary judgment in respect of its claim for $250,668.91 plus interest and costs. The Defendant (“Watts & Hughes”) opposes both applications.

[2]      For the reasons given below, I propose to decline leave to Vinteq.1

Background

[3]      In 2012 Taupo District Council (“Council”) engaged Watts & Hughes to refurbish the AC baths at Taupo.  Watts & Hughes subcontracted Vinteq to carry out various works required under Watts & Hughes’ contract with the Council.

[4]      First, Vinteq was contracted to dismantle, supply and install structural steel for the baths.  Vinteq quoted for this work on 17 May 2012, the relevant quote being Q10339.2    Watts & Hughes accepted the quote in or about September 2012.   It is common ground this subcontract was on the terms of NZS 3910:2003 – Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering Construction (“NZS 3910:2003”).

[5]      Secondly, on 19 October 2012 and at Watts & Hughes’ request, Vinteq quoted to supply labour only for site works in respect of particular scheduled quantities, the quote being for $62,994.20 excluding GST – Q10357.3   This quote was arrived at on what is referred to as a “measure and value” basis.   For instance, Vinteq quoted

$11.90 per m2  to install 1,003 m2 of 9 mm Villaboard.   Watts & Hughes accepted

Q10357 on or about 25 October 2012.4

[6]      Thirdly, the evidence for Vinteq is that on 15 October 2012 Watts & Hughes’ site  manager,  Mr  Stuart  Gillard,  asked  Vinteq  to  supply  carpenters,  painters, trades assistants  and  engineers  “on   an  hourly  basis  (on  charge  up)”.5    Few

contemporaneous documents as to matters affecting the supply of labour on this

1      High Court Rules, r 12.2(1).

2      Affidavit of C B Michael sworn 19 November 2013 at CMB 1.

3      At CMB 3.

4      At CMB 4.

5      Affidavit of R T Vincent sworn 5 December 2013.

basis exist or, if they do, they are not in evidence.  Vinteq’s evidence, however, is that these employees:6

…  all  started  on  the  [16th]  October  2012  labour  only.    This  was  the beginning of the supply of labour only charge up work.   Vinteq supplied daily time sheets that were signed off each day.  Watts & Hughes did not like the system and they requested it be changed to daily Daywork sheets.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R T Vincent Limited v Watts & Hughes Construction Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 424
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, RT Vincent Limited, sought leave to apply for summary judgment against Watts & Hughes Construction Limited for a debt of $250,668.91 plus interest and costs. Watts & Hughes opposed both the application for leave and the application for summary judgment. The court was required to determine whether RT Vincent Limited was entitled to leave to apply for summary judgment, and if so, whether summary judgment should be granted. The court also needed to consider the parties' arguments on the basis of payment for the work done by RT Vincent Limited under the contract with Watts & Hughes Construction Limited.

The court declined to grant leave for summary judgment. It reasoned that RT Vincent Limited had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that Watts & Hughes Construction Limited had no defence to the claim. The court found that the factual and legal issues between the parties were too complex to be resolved on affidavit evidence alone. The court also noted that the parties had taken opposing positions on the issues requiring determination, and that there were discrepancies in the invoices submitted by RT Vincent Limited. The court concluded that an urgent trial of the proceeding was possible and that Watts & Hughes Construction Limited should be allowed an order for costs, subject to the parties' submissions.

The court declined to grant RT Vincent Limited leave to apply for summary judgment. However, it offered the parties an urgent trial of the proceeding. The court also noted that Watts & Hughes Construction Limited would be entitled to an order for costs, subject to the parties' submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established