QSM Trustees Limited v Body Corporate 162791

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-001286 [2013] NZHC 1762

BETWEEN  QSM TRUSTEES LIMITED Plaintiff

AND  BODY CORPORATE 162791

First Defendant

BOUTIQUE BODY CORPORATES LIMITED

Second Defendant

DOUGLAS PATTINSON Third Defendant

GRACE CHENG Fourth Defendant

SHAHIN KERMANI Fifth Defendant

TERRY KIM Sixth Defendant

STUART GORDON Seventh Defendant

PETER COOPER Eighth Defendant

Hearing:                   11 July 2013

Counsel:                  DM Hughes for Plaintiff

TJG Allan and A Credin for Defendants

Judgment:                11 July 2013

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASHER J (Security for costs and directions)

Solicitors:

Kensington Swan, Auckland.

Grove Darlow & Partners, Auckland.

QSM TRUSTEES LIMITED v BODY CORPORATE 162791 [2013] NZHC 1762 [11 July 2013]

[1]      In this commercial dispute the defendants at the outset seek security for costs. There are also timetabling issues that must be resolved.

[2]      The plaintiff is a corporate trustee and the registered proprietor of units 3A to

3E, being levels three to five 239 Queen Street.

[3]      The first defendant Body Corporate is the body corporate for the unit title development at 239 Queen Street.  The second defendant Boutique Body Corporates Ltd is the secretary.  The defendants named thereafter are members of the committee of the Body Corporate.

[4]      The  dispute  relates  to  complex  arrangements  entered  into  between  the proprietors of levels three to five and the Body Corporate.  The plaintiff claims that there was an agreement reached on various matters with the Body Corporate that has been breached.  It says that there have been wrongful attempts by the defendants to vary the arrangements made.   There is also an argument about whether the Body Corporate levies are payable, whether the Body Corporate made misrepresentations, and a pleading of estoppel against the Body Corporate.

[5]      Further details of the dispute are too complex to endeavour to summarise in this short judgment, and it has to be observed that the statement of claim is difficult to follow.  I accept that there was a lack of formality in the dealings of the various parties over the years which makes the task of pleading a difficult one.  However, obviously the plaintiff must have clear and discernible causes of action if it is to be able to proceed.

[6]      It is not in dispute that the threshold requirement for the payment of security for costs by the plaintiff has been crossed.   The plaintiff has not contested the proposition that it should pay security for costs (despite some equivocation in its most recent submission).

[7]      The real issue that arose in the conference last week was quantum and how security for costs should be paid.   Mr Allan for the defendants has submitted a schedule of costs calculated on a 2B basis.  On the basis that there will be a 10 day

hearing, the total costs come to $67,206.   I accept Mr Allan’s submission that the costs calculation is conservative.

[8]      Mr Hughes  for the  plaintiff  has  sensibly not  sought  to  quibble over the amount claimed.

[9]      It was his position at the case management conference last week, and remains…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QSM Trustees Limited v Body Corporate 162791 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1762
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

QSM Trustees Limited v Body Corporate 162791 involved a commercial dispute between a corporate trustee and a body corporate, alongside several individual defendants. The plaintiff, QSM Trustees Limited, claimed breaches of an agreement with the first defendant, Body Corporate 162791, regarding complex arrangements at 239 Queen Street. The defendants sought security for costs, given the threshold requirements had been met. The court considered the complexity of the case and the reasonable approach taken by both parties. The judge ordered staged security for costs, accepting the defendants' submission for a total of $67,000, payable in two installments. Additionally, the judge provided timetable directions for the filing of documents and completion of inspection, contingent upon the payment of the initial security.

The legal issues addressed by the court included the quantum of security for costs and the method of payment. The plaintiff did not contest the need to pay security for costs, but proposed a staged payment. The defendants argued for a single upfront payment. The court acknowledged the common practice of ordering staged security but found the defendants' calculation reasonable. The judge also highlighted the importance of timely submissions and the reasonableness of both counsel in managing the proceedings. The court ruled that the costs on this hearing would be left where they fell, considering the positions of both parties and the overall context of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established