QBE Insurance (International) Ltd v Pegasus Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA830/2009

[2011] NZCA 268

BETWEEN  QBE INSURANCE (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED
First Appellant

AND  AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE COMPANY
Second Appellant

AND  PEGASUS GROUP LIMITED
Respondent

CA58/2010

AND BETWEEN             AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE COMPANY
Appellant

AND  PEGASUS GROUP LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:         3 and 4 May 2011

Court:             Ellen France, Randerson and Harrison JJ

Counsel:         M G Ring QC, M O Robertson and H P Twomey for First Appellant in CA830/2009
A Challis and K Harkess for Second Appellant in CA830/2009 and Appellant in CA58/2010
M J Tingey and B M M McKinlay for Respondent

Judgment:      13 June 2011 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

ALeave granted to the appellants in CA830/2009 and CA58/2010 to file amended notices of appeal.

BThe appeals in CA830/2009 and CA58/2010 are dismissed.

CThe cross-appeal in CA830/2009 is dismissed.

DQBE and AHA must each pay Pegasus an amount equal to 85 per cent of costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Contents

Introduction  [1]
Indemnity  [8]

(a) Approach  [8]
(b) QBE   [12]

(i)    Policy  [12]

(ii)   QBE’s case  [16]
(iii)  Analysis  [20]

(c) AHA  [45]
(d) Consequences  [51]

Stocktaking  [55]

(a) Process  [55]

(b) The August 2004 stocktake  [62]

(i)    High Court  [62]

(ii)   QBE’s case  [65]
(iii)  AHA’s case  [72]

(c) The February 2005 stocktake  [75]

(i)    High Court  [75]

(ii)   Insurers’ case  [79]

Theft  [93]
Conclusion  [118]
Set-off  [121]
Costs  [136]

Introduction

  1. Pegasus Group Ltd, the respondent and cross-appellant, imports and distributes branded sporting and leisure goods.  Between 2001 and 2005 the company stored its stock in warehouses operated by New Zealand Express Ltd (NZE).  As a result of a stocktake in February 2005, Pegasus discovered that large quantities of its goods were missing.  It claimed that the missing stock was stolen by NZE employees.  But before Pegasus could take any formal steps NZE was placed in liquidation.

  2. Pegasus had a policy of material damage insurance with QBE, the first appellant.  The company made a claim for indemnity for its goods lost while in NZE’s custody.  QBE denied liability. 

  3. NZE had what was called a crime insurance policy with American Home Assurance Company (AHA), the second appellant.  That policy indemnified NZE against liability to third parties for goods lost while in its custody.  Pegasus made a claim for its loss directly under the AHA contract following NZE’s liquidation.  AHA denied liability. 

  4. Pegasus issued proceedings in the High Court at Auckland against both insurers.  Following a two week trial, Winkelmann J found that Pegasus had proved its claim against each insurer.  In both cases the company relied substantially on its stock records to establish the thefts and the amount of its loss.  Winkelmann J entered judgment for Pegasus against QBE for these sums:[1]

    [1]Pegasus Group Limited v QBE Insurance (International) Limited HC Auckland CIV-2006-404-6941, 1 December 2009.

    (a)$354,369 for material damage less:

    (i)$2,500 by way of policy excess;

    (ii)any amount which Pegasus recovered from AHA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (International) Ltd v Pegasus Group Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZCA 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of QBE Insurance (International) Limited and American Home Assurance Company v Pegasus Group Limited [2011] NZCA 268 was heard in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appellants, QBE and American Home Assurance Company, are contesting the High Court's decision to award Pegasus Group Limited compensation for the theft of its goods while in the custody of New Zealand Express Ltd (NZE). The primary issue before the Court was whether the inventory exclusion clauses in the insurance policies barred the use of stock records to prove the theft of goods and the extent of the loss. The Court found that the inventory exclusion clauses did not prevent Pegasus from using its stock records to prove the theft and extent of loss, as there was independent evidence of theft by NZE employees. The Court also upheld the High Court's finding that the thefts were frequent, in large volumes, and over an extended period of time. The Court dismissed the appeals by QBE and American Home Assurance Company and the cross-appeal by Pegasus Group Limited, and ordered QBE and American Home Assurance Company to pay Pegasus Group Limited 85 per cent of costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.