QBE Insurance (International) Ltd v MTEC Consultants Ltd no.2

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CIV 2012-463-469 [2012] NZHC 3329

BETWEEN  QBE INSURANCE (INTERNATIONAL) LTD AND VERO LIABILITY INSURANCE LTD

Applicants

ANDMTEC CONSULTANTS LTD First Respondent

ANDROTORUA DISTRICT COUNCIL Second Respondent

ANDPIONEER PROPERTY TRUST LTD Third Respondent

ANDTRENT DANIEL SWEENEY AND MELANIE GWEN THOMPSON Fourth Respondent

ANDGJMCP LTD Fifth Respondent

ANDBAYWIDE CONSTRUCTION LTD Sixth Respondent

ANDCOFFEY GEOTECHNICS (NZ) LTD Seventh Respondent

Hearing:         10 December 2012

Counsel:         N A Till QC and J A Thompson for Applicants Appearance on behalf of First Respondent excused S Thodey for Second Respondent

K J Patterson for Third Respondent

V A Whitfield for Fourth Respondent

M Lenihan for Fifth Respondent and Calais Western Ltd Appearances on behalf of Sixth and Seventh Respondents excused Mr and Mrs Grundy, Mr Collins and Ms Vos, and Mr and Mrs Davis (persons served following interim judgment of 31 October 2012), in person

No appearance by others served following interim judgment of 31

October 2012

QBE INSURANCE (INTERNATIONAL) LTD AND VERO LIABILITY INSURANCE LTD V MTEC CONSULTANTS LTD HC ROT CIV 2012-463-469 [11 December 2012]

Judgment:      11 December 2012

JUDGMENT (NO. 2) OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 11 December 2012 at 12 noon pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Introduction

[1]      QBE  Insurance  (International)  Ltd  and Vero  Liability  Insurance  Ltd  (the Insurers) are the professional indemnity insurers for a civil engineering company, MTEC Consultants Ltd (MTEC).  MTEC provided engineering services to Pioneer Property Trust Ltd (Pioneer), the developer of a residential subdivision, known as “Oakland”, near Ngongotaha.  Pioneer and some purchasers of lots in the Oakland subdivision allege that MTEC gave negligent opinions about the suitability of the soil as a foundation for proposed dwellings and that loss has been suffered in consequence.   The Insurers have carriage of MTEC’s defence, in a number of proceedings that have been brought against it. At this stage, MTEC denies liability.

[2]      On 20 July 2012, the Insurers applied for orders requiring landowners who had not issued proceedings against MTEC to bring such proceedings promptly so that they could determine those parties with whom they could negotiate to resolve all claims.1   The Insurers also applied to consolidate all proceedings currently before the Court and any future claims that might be brought.  If granted, the latter order could have had the effect of deferring resolution of any claims against MTEC indefintiely.

[3]      The Insurers’ application (the s 9(6) application) is driven by their belief that

MTEC’s lack of financial resources is likely to bring s 9 of the Law Reform Act

1936 (the Act) into play.2   Section 9 is a code, designed to create a charge over the proceeds of a relevant insurance policy and to preserve the moneys for the benefit of those who suffer loss as a result of the event that gives rise to the claim.   The Insurers’ seek a declaration that they have “actual notice” of a limited category of claims giving rise to a charge, so…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (International) Ltd v MTEC Consultants Ltd no.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3329
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

QBE Insurance (International) Ltd and Vero Liability Insurance Ltd (the Insurers) are the professional indemnity insurers for MTEC Consultants Ltd (MTEC), an engineering company. MTEC provided engineering services to Pioneer Property Trust Ltd, the developer of a residential subdivision known as “Oakland”, near Ngongotaha. Pioneer and some purchasers of lots in the Oakland subdivision allege that MTEC gave negligent opinions about the suitability of the soil as a foundation for proposed dwellings and that loss has been suffered in consequence. The Insurers have carriage of MTEC’s defence in a number of proceedings that have been brought against it. The Insurers applied for orders requiring landowners who had not issued proceedings against MTEC to bring such proceedings promptly so that they could determine those parties with whom they could negotiate to resolve all claims. They also sought to consolidate all proceedings currently before the Court and any future claims that might be brought. The Insurers’ application is driven by their belief that MTEC’s lack of financial resources is likely to bring s 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 into play. Section 9 is a code, designed to create a charge over the proceeds of a relevant insurance policy and to preserve the moneys for the benefit of those who suffer loss as a result of the event that gives rise to the claim. The Insurers sought a declaration that they have “actual notice” of a limited category of claims giving rise to a charge, so that they may treat with those parties and secure a valid discharge for any payments they may make. The court considered that the desirability of dealing promptly with the s 9(6) application outweighed the risks of making a decision before the Court of Appeal’s judgment was released. The court was satisfied that the Insurers have actual notice of certain claims giving rise to charges over insurance moneys payable under the contract of insurance between MTEC and the Insurers. The court dismissed the applications for consolidation and stay and made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established