Property Sales Direct Limited v Hawken Lane Development LP

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA414/2022
 [2022] NZCA 643

BETWEEN

PROPERTY SALES DIRECT LIMITED
Appellant

AND

HAWKEN LANE DEVELOPMENT LP
Respondent

Hearing:

27 October 2022

Court:

Brown, Mallon and Downs JJ

Counsel:

N F Flanagan for Appellant
E St John and S P Maloney for Respondent

Judgment:

20 December 2022 at 10.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for a stay of execution of the High Court judgment ([2022] NZHC 1735) pending appeal is declined.

BThe appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Mallon J)

Background

  1. The respondent (Hawken) is a developer of an 89-lot subdivision in Silverdale.  The appellant (PSDL) entered into agreements to purchase 31 of these lots.  Subsequently Hawken cancelled the agreements for all but 11 of the lots because PSDL failed to confirm them after the due diligence period.  PSDL paid the deposits for the remaining 11 lots, but then could not settle on time when the titles for the lots became available. 

  2. PSDL managed to settle five of the 11 lots late but did not accept Hawken’s proposal providing further time for PSDL to settle the remaining six lots.  Hawken then issued settlement notices for the six lots.  PSDL then purported to cancel the agreements for those lots and demanded the return of the deposits paid for them.  Hawken did not accept the purported cancellations and in turn cancelled the agreements.

  3. Initially PSDL sought to bring a liquidation application against Hawken but later withdrew this application.  PSDL then issued proceedings seeking the return of its deposits on the six lots ($522,129.98).  Hawken responded with a counterclaim for penalty interest payable on five of the six lots before they were cancelled ($461,440.46) and for losses resulting from a caveat PSDL had lodged over the residual land owned by Hawken, which included the area encompassed by the sixth lot (Lot 22) ($122,500.00). 

  4. In a judgment given on 20 July 2022, Powell J dismissed PSDL’s claim and found for Hawken (the substantive judgment).[1]  Hawken was entitled to retain the deposits and to judgment for the claimed amounts for the penalty interest on the cancelled agreements and the loss caused by the caveat. 

    [1]Property Sales Direct Ltd v Hawken Lane Development LP [2022] NZHC 1735, (2022) 23 NZCPR 440 [Substantive judgment].

  5. On 3 August 2022 Hawken served a statutory demand on PSDL for the judgment sum of $583,940.46.  The last day for satisfaction of the statutory demand was 24 August 2022.  On 17 August 2022 PSDL filed a notice of appeal from the substantive judgment to this Court.  PSDL corresponded with Hawken advising that it considered Hawken should withdraw the statutory demand and not take steps to liquidate PSDL pending the appeal, or at least pending the determination of PSDL’s proposed stay application.  Hawken responded that it intended to continue with liquidation proceedings until the appeal or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Property Sales Direct Limited v Hawken Lane Development LP and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZCA 643
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Property Sales Direct Limited (PSDL) sought to appeal against the High Court decision that dismissed their claim for the return of deposits and found for Hawken Lane Development LP (Hawken) on their counterclaims. The primary legal issue the Court of Appeal had to decide was whether to grant a stay of execution of the substantive judgment pending the appeal. The secondary issues involved assessing the strength of PSDL’s appeal and whether the refusal of a stay would render the appeal nugatory.

The Court of Appeal considered several factors in determining whether a stay should be granted. These factors included the potential for the appeal to be rendered nugatory, the bona fides of PSDL in prosecuting the appeal, the effect on Hawken if a stay were granted, the balance of convenience, and the apparent strength of the appeal. The Court found that PSDL’s appeal faced substantial hurdles, as it raised new arguments and sought to resile from concessions made in the High Court. PSDL’s history of taking unmeritorious legal actions in the dispute further undermined the strength of the appeal. The Court concluded that the balance of convenience did not favour a stay, as Hawken had succeeded in the High Court and should be entitled to proceed with enforcement action for its judgment sum. Consequently, the Court declined the application for a stay of execution of the substantive judgment.

The Court also ordered that PSDL, as the unsuccessful applicant, must pay Hawken costs for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements. This decision reinforces the importance of adhering to the principles of good faith and merit in legal proceedings, particularly when seeking to stay the execution of a judgment pending appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Property Sales Direct Limited (PSDL) agreed to purchase 31 lots from Hawken Lane Development LP, a developer of an 89-lot subdivision. PSDL failed to confirm the agreements within the due diligence period, leading Hawken to cancel all but 11 of the agreements. PSDL paid deposits for the remaining 11 lots but could not settle on time for five of them. PSDL managed to settle for five lots late but did not accept Hawken's proposal for more time on the remaining six lots. Hawken issued settlement notices for the six lots. PSDL purported to cancel the agreements for these lots and demanded the return of their deposits. Hawken refused the cancellations and also terminated the agreements. PSDL initially sought to bring a liquidation application against Hawken, which it later withdrew. Instead, PSDL issued proceedings seeking the return of the deposits for the six lots. Hawken counterclaimed for penalty interest on five of the lots and for losses resulting from a caveat PSDL had lodged over Hawken's residual land.

The matter first came before Powell J in the High Court, who dismissed PSDL's claim and found in favour of Hawken on 20 July 2022. On 3 August 2022, Hawken served a statutory demand on PSDL for the judgment sum. PSDL filed a notice of appeal to the Court of Appeal on 17 August 2022. PSDL applied to the High Court for a stay of execution of the substantive judgment pending the appeal, which Powell J declined on 9 September 2022. PSDL now applies to the Court of Appeal for a stay of execution of the substantive judgment pending the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal may be rendered nugatory by the lack of a stay?
2. What is the bona fides of the applicant as to the prosecution of the appeal?
3. Whether the successful party will be injuriously affected by the stay?
4. What is the effect on third parties?
5. Are the questions involved novel or of general importance?
6. What is the public interest in the proceeding?
7. What is the overall balance of convenience?
8. What is the apparent strength of the appeal?

Held
1. Whether the appeal may be rendered nugatory by the lack of a stay? The Court concluded that the appeal would not be rendered nugatory if a stay were refused.
2. What is the bona fides of the applicant as to the prosecution of the appeal? The Court found that the applicant's actions throughout the litigation indicated a lack of bona fides.
3. Whether the successful party will be injuriously affected by the stay? The Court concluded that the successful party, Hawken, would not be significantly affected by the refusal of a stay.
4. What is the effect on third parties? The Court found that there was no effect on third parties.
5. Are the questions involved novel or of general importance? The Court found that the questions involved were not novel or of general importance.
6. What is the public interest in the proceeding? The Court found that there was no public interest in the proceeding.
7. What is the overall balance of convenience? The Court found that the overall balance of convenience did not favour a stay.
8. What is the apparent strength of the appeal? The Court found that the appeal appeared to be weak.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the relevant factors in determining whether a stay should be granted, as outlined in Keung v GBR Investment Ltd. The Court found that the appeal would not be rendered nugatory if a stay were refused, as PSDL could still pursue the appeal through third-party funding or by applying to the High Court to reverse a decision by the liquidator not to pursue the appeal. The Court also found that the applicant's actions throughout the litigation indicated a lack of bona fides, as it had taken unmeritorious points and legal action. The Court concluded that the successful party, Hawken, would not be significantly affected by the refusal of a stay, as it had already succeeded in the High Court and should be entitled to proceed with enforcement action for its judgment sum. The Court found that there was no effect on third parties, no public interest in the proceeding, and that the questions on appeal were not novel or of general importance. Finally, the Court found that the overall balance of convenience did not favour a stay, as the refusal of a stay may mean that PSDL is placed in liquidation, but it was unclear that any unfair prejudice would flow from that.

The Court found that the apparent weakness of the appeal, the history of taking unmeritorious points and legal action in the dispute, and the balance of convenience strongly pointed against a stay. The Court agreed with the High Court that a stay of execution of the substantive judgment, pending the determination of the appeal from that judgment, should not be ordered. The Court ordered that PSDL, as the unsuccessful applicant, must pay to Hawken costs for a standard application on a band A basis with usual disbursements.