IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2011-404-001752 [2013] NZHC 3159
BETWEEN PRINCIPAL FINANCE LIMITED Plaintiff
ANDGRAEME WILLIAM HALSE First Defendant
ANDGRAEME WILLIAM HALSE Second Defendant
ANDQBE INSURANCE (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED
Third Party
Hearing: On the papers
Appearances: DJ Heaney QC and DJ Clark for Plaintiff
P Dale for Defendants
A Challis and P McKinnon for Third Party
Judgment: 29 November 2013 at 4pm
COSTS JUDGMENT OF TOOGOOD J
This judgment was delivered by me on 29 November 2013 at 4pm
Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
PRINCIPAL FINANCE LIMITED v HALSE [2013] NZHC 3159 [29 November 2013]
[1] For the reasons given below:
(a) I decline the plaintiff’s application for costs on the determination of the preliminary questions;
(b)I direct that the proceeding shall be classified as Category 2B for costs purposes; and
(c) I order that the third party shall pay $20,248.64 towards the defendants’ costs and disbursements on the determination of the preliminary questions.
Background
[2] Principal Finance Limited (“PFL”) has issued the present proceeding against Mr Graeme Halse, a solicitor, who was the sole shareholder and director of the company, his shareholding being in his capacity as sole trustee of the Waikato Trust. It sues Mr Halse and his firm for breaches of solicitor’s duties and also for alleged breaches of his duties as sole director of the company.
[3] The defendants joined QBE Insurance claiming that they were indemnified in respect of the plaintiff’s claims under a professional indemnity insurance policy (“the Policy”). QBE declined to cover and, on the application of the defendants, the Court agreed to answer two preliminary questions concerning the interpretation of the insurance policy, the answers to which would determine whether the defendants were covered in respect of the claims.
[4] On 10 July 2013, I delivered a judgment in this proceeding (“the preliminary questions judgment”)1 in which I decided2 that Mr Halse and his firm were covered under the Policy in respect of three causes of action related to alleged breaches of Mr
Halse’s duties as a solicitor. I also decided,3 however, that Mr Halse was not covered in respect of allegations in the fourth cause of action relating to advice or services provided by him in his capacity as a director of the plaintiff, except to the extent that he was acting in the capacity of a solicitor or barrister in providing the same.
[5] In relation to costs, the judgment contained the following indication:4
[52] Each of the parties has had a measure of success and each may feel entitled to apply for costs. Taking a broad view, without the benefit of submissions from counsel, I estimate that around 80 percent of the argument and hearing time were directed to the issues arising in respect of cl 7.11 on which the plaintiff and the defendants have been successful, and that about
20 percent of the argument related to the fourth cause of action on which the third party QBE has succeeded.
Justification for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Principal Finance Limited v Halse and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NZHC 3159
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court included whether the plaintiff was entitled to costs for its support of the defendants' application for a determination of preliminary questions, the appropriate category for cost classification, and whether the resolution of the preliminary questions constituted an interlocutory proceeding or part of a substantive claim. The Court also had to determine what items should be allowed in any costs award.
The Court found that the plaintiff should bear its own costs as its support of the defendants' application did not entitle it to a contribution towards the defendants' costs. The Court rejected the plaintiff’s argument that the proceeding should be classified as Category 3C, instead classifying it as Category 2B. The Court determined that the resolution of the preliminary questions was an interlocutory matter, but the determination itself was substantive. Consequently, the costs recovery items should be assessed accordingly, with a 20 per cent reduction applied to the defendants' costs due to the proportion of argument and hearing time that related to the point on which the third party succeeded.
The final orders were that the plaintiff's application for costs on the determination of the preliminary questions was declined, the proceeding was classified as Category 2B for costs purposes, and QBE Insurance (International) Limited was ordered to pay $20,248.64 towards the defendants’ costs and disbursements on the determination of the preliminary questions.