Primero Maritime Limited v Southern Spars Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2015-404-1576

[2019] NZHC 469

BETWEEN

PRIMERO MARITIME LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

SOUTHERN SPARS LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 11 March 2019

Appearances:

E McGill and S K Cartwright for the Plaintiff

D McLellan QC and SFW Learmonth for the Defendant

Judgment:

18 March 2019


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE P J ANDREW


This judgment was delivered by me on 18 March 2019 at 2:30 p.m. pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 2016.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

……………………………………

Solicitors / Counsel:

Ms E McGill, Barrister, Auckland

Mr S K Cartwright, Hesketh Henry, Solicitors, Auckland Mr D McLellan QC, Barrister, Auckland

Ms P Davies and Mr SFW Learmonth, Fee Langstone, Solicitors, Auckland

PRIMERO MARITIME LTD v SOUTHERN SPARS LTD [2019] NZHC 469 [18 March 2019]

Introduction

[1]                 The plaintiff, Primero Maritime Ltd (Primero), is the owner of a super yacht, the Salperton IV. The mast of the yacht fractured whilst being sailed in January 2011. The defendant, Southern Spars Ltd, manufactured the mast and rigging. Primero sues in negligence contending that Southern Spars failed to exercise reasonable skill and care in manufacturing and supplying the rig.

[2]                 The cause of the dismasting and the liability of the defendant for damages are in dispute. The proceedings were brought in July 2015, following formal demand in January 2014.

[3]                 Southern Spars challenges Primero’s claim to privilege over a number of documents pursuant to r 8.25 of the High Court Rules 2016. Primero contends that the disputed documents are privileged under s 56 of the Evidence Act 2006 on the basis that they are communications prepared for the dominant purpose of a proceeding or an apprehended proceeding.

[4]                 The documents for which privilege is claimed are, in the main, reports prepared by the plaintiff or its insurer’s experts. Primero did not file an affidavit of documents until 2018. Before it did so, it provided the majority of the disputed documents to the defendant’s solicitor on a without prejudice basis and for the purposes of a mediation which ultimately did not take place.

[5]                 In addition to the challenge to privilege, the defendant has brought an application for particular discovery pursuant to r 8.19 of the High Court Rules 2016.

[6]The critical issues I must determine are:

(a)whether the plaintiff has discharged the burden of establishing the twin requirements of reasonable apprehension and dominant purpose under s 56 of the Evidence Act 2006 (the privilege issue); and

(b)whether the defendant has established relevance and proportionality in respect of its application for discovery (the discovery issue).

Relevant legal principles

[7]                 The common law test for litigation privilege was described in Guardian Royal Exchange Assurance of New Zealand Ltd v Stuart:1

… when litigation is in progress or reasonably apprehended, a report or other document obtained by a party or his legal adviser should be privileged from inspection or production in evidence if the dominant purpose of its preparation is to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Primero Maritime Limited v Southern Spars Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 469
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Primero Maritime Limited, the owner of the super yacht Salperton IV, commenced proceedings against Southern Spars Limited, the manufacturer of the yacht's mast and rigging, alleging that the mast fractured during sailing due to Southern Spars' failure to exercise reasonable skill and care in manufacturing and supplying the rig. The proceedings were brought in July 2015, following a formal demand in January 2014. Southern Spars challenges Primero's claim to privilege over a number of documents under r 8.25 of the High Court Rules 2016 and brings an application for particular discovery under r 8.19 of the same rules.

The court was required to decide whether the plaintiff had discharged the burden of establishing the twin requirements of reasonable apprehension and dominant purpose under s 56 of the Evidence Act 2006, and whether the defendant had established relevance and proportionality in respect of its application for discovery.

The court held that the plaintiff had not discharged the burden of establishing the twin requirements of reasonable apprehension and dominant purpose under s 56 of the Evidence Act 2006. The plaintiff relied on the decision of E Sport Yachting Ventures Ltd v Southern Spars, but the court found that the facts in the present case were not as unique as in E Sport and that the plaintiff needed to provide a proper evidential foundation. The court also found that the plaintiff's inconsistent treatment of its documents cast doubt on the credibility of its assertion of privilege. As a result, the court set aside the plaintiff's claim to privilege.

Regarding the defendant's application for discovery, the court found that the defendant had established the four grounds of the Assa Abloy test and that an order for particular discovery should be granted. The plaintiff had accepted that the discovery to date had been incomplete, and the categories of documents sought were prima facie relevant. The court also rejected the plaintiff's submission that an order requiring it to file a fresh affidavit of documents in the two disputed categories would not be proportionate. The court made an order for the plaintiff to file and serve an affidavit by a certain date and to make the documents available for inspection by the defendant.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff's claim to privilege in respect of the documents listed in schedule A is set aside and that the plaintiff is required to make the documents available for inspection by the defendant. The plaintiff is also ordered to file and serve an affidavit by a certain date, stating whether certain documents or classes of documents are or have been in the plaintiff's control, and if so, to make those documents available for inspection to the defendant. The defendant is to pay costs and disbursements to the plaintiff in respect of both applications and on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established