Primary Services New Zealand Ltd v Fonagy

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2019-409-404

[2019] NZHC 1869

BETWEEN

PRIMARY SERVICES NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Applicant

AND

ANDREW MICHAEL FONAGY

First Respondent

ORA TRUSTEES LIMITED

Second Respondent

Teleconference: 1 August 2019

Counsel:

JL Bates for Applicant

A L Harlowe for First Respondent

Judgment:

2 August 2019


JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J


[1]    On 26 July 2019, the applicant filed a statement of claim in the High Court seeking  judgment  against  a  company  known  as   Colombo   Projects   Limited, Mr Fonagy, the respondent in these proceedings, and John Richmond Paynter. The proceedings sought judgment against Mr Fonagy for a principal sum of $850,000 plus interest and costs.

[2]    The proceedings related to a loan agreement which Mr Fonagy and Mr Paynter had guaranteed and in respect of which the first defendant had defaulted.

[3]    In addition to those proceedings, the applicant, the same day, applied for a freezing order. That application was supported by an affidavit of Mr D G R Short, a director of Primary Services New Zealand Limited. An undertaking as to damages

PRIMARY SERVICES NEW ZEALAND LIMITED v FONAGY & ANOR [2019] NZHC 1869 [2 August 2019]

was also filed. The application for the freezing order was filed on a without notice basis.

[4]    The subject of the freezing order was Mr Fonagy’s shareholding in a company known as Fontur Trustee Limited, and the proceeds of sale to which Mr Fonagy might become entitled following the sale or transfer of his shareholding in Fontur, including any proceeds to which the first respondent may become entitled following the sale of assets of two companies: 22 O’Shannessey Limited and Ponsonby 235 Limited which were said to be owned by Fontur.

[5]    The application for a freezing order also sought an order restraining the first and second respondents from removing from New Zealand, disposing of, dealing with or diminishing the value of the proceeds to which Mr Fonagy may, or had become entitled, following the sale of properties owned by 22 O’Shannessey Limited and Ponsonby 235 Limited.

[6]    The matter came before Dunningham J on 26 July 2019. She issued a minute on 26 July indicating that she was satisfied that there was a good arguable case against the named defendants in the primary proceedings, but unclear as to why the Court should issue a freezing order in respect of assets which were not directly owned by Mr Fonagy, where it was not obvious that the applicant would have recourse to them in any event, if it obtained judgment in its favour. She directed a telephone conference with the Duty Judge to clarify this issue.

[7]That teleconference was held yesterday 1 August 2019.

[8]    Mr A L Harlowe, whose client had been served on a Pickwick basis, appeared for Mr Fonagy. Mr Nick Williams had earlier emailed the Court indicating that he had instructions to appear on a Pickwick basis at the teleconference expressly reserving the position of Ora Trustees Limited,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Primary Services New Zealand Ltd v Fonagy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 1869
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Primary Services New Zealand Limited v Fonagy involved proceedings against Andrew Michael Fonagy and Ora Trustees Limited, with the applicant seeking a judgment against Fonagy for a principal sum of $850,000, along with interest and costs. The proceedings were related to a loan agreement guaranteed by Fonagy and John Richmond Paynter, where the first defendant had defaulted. Concurrently, Primary Services New Zealand Limited applied for a freezing order against Fonagy's shareholding in Fontur Trustee Limited and the proceeds from the sale of his shareholding. The application also sought to restrain Fonagy and Ora Trustees Limited from disposing of or diminishing the value of assets owned by 22 O’Shannessey Limited and Ponsonby 235 Limited.

The legal issues before the court included whether there was a good arguable case against the respondents for the primary proceedings and whether a freezing order should be granted. Specifically, the court had to determine whether Fonagy's actions constituted an attempt to dispose of assets to avoid liability under his guarantee on the loan. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the freezing order should extend to the assets of Fontur Trustee Limited and the potential proceeds from the sale of assets owned by 22 O’Shannessey Limited and Ponsonby 235 Limited.

The court found that there was a good arguable case against Fonagy in the primary proceedings. However, the court was uncertain about issuing a freezing order against assets not directly owned by Fonagy, given the lack of clarity on the applicant's recourse to these assets if judgment was obtained. The court also noted the absence of proper service on Fonagy and Ora Trustees Limited, which necessitated a teleconference to clarify jurisdictional and service issues. After considering the arguments and the urgency of the application, the court granted an interim freezing order against Fonagy, while declining to make such an order against Ora Trustees Limited. The court directed that the substantive proceedings and the seizure order be served on Ora Trustees Limited without delay and set a date for a first case management conference.

The final orders included an interim freezing order against Fonagy, with specific directions that it would last until further order of the court and that Fonagy could move to set the order aside on notice. The court also directed that the substantive proceedings be served on Ora Trustees Limited and set a date for a first case management conference. Costs were reserved pending further proceedings.