Priest v Ross Asset Management Limited (in liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-11448 [2016] NZHC 1803

UNDER Part 18 of the High Court Rules

BETWEEN

MAURICE DUNCAN PRIEST AND NORA BEATRIX PRIEST

Plaintiffs

AND

ROSS ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) First Defendant

DAGGER NOMINEES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Second Defendant

NESSOCK CUSTODIANS LIMITED Third Defendant

Hearing:

19-23 October 2015

(Further written submissions 6, 13, 26 November and
21 December 2015)

Counsel:

D J Chisholm QC and M H L Morrison for Plaintiffs
M G Colson, F J Tregonning and L Brazier for Defendants

Judgment:

5 August 2016

JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J

Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................. [1] The Priests’ claim ................................................................................................. [7] The Liquidators’ response.................................................................................. [13]

Facts........................................................................................................................ [17]

PRIEST v ROSS ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) [2016] NZHC 1803 [5 August 2016]

RAM, Mr Ross and investors generally............................................................. [24] The usual course of dealing ............................................................................ [24] The position at 6 November 2012 ................................................................... [31]

RAM, Mr Ross and the Priests .......................................................................... [33] The usual course of dealing ............................................................................ [33] The Nessock transaction ................................................................................. [45]

The Priest Holdings – the agreed position .......................................................... [47] The legal context.................................................................................................... [52]

The contractual arrangements .......................................................................... [52] Breach – consequences ...................................................................................... [61] The Priest Holdings: intangible, fungible property – implications .................. [64]

Analysis .................................................................................................................. [68] Outline ................................................................................................................ [68] The Liquidators’ shared proprietary right argument........................................ [72]

Overview ......................................................................................................... [72]

Clayton’s Case and its relevance to the rules of tracing ................................. [78]
The “exceptions” to Clayton’s Case allocation .............................................. [87]

Pro rata sharing ................................................................................................. [92] Re Registered Securities Ltd ........................................................................... [92] Other New Zealand cases ............................................................................. [104]

The English cases .............................................................................................. [108] Sinclair v Brougham.................................................................................. [110] Re Diplock ................................................................................................. [121] Barlow Clowes .......................................................................................... [132] Foskett v McKeown ................................................................................... [137]

The arguments so far ....................................................................................... [143] The Priests’ interests ........................................................................................ [147] Can the Other Investors nevertheless trace into the Priest Holdings? .......... [154] Collective tracing.............................................................................................. [159] Tracing the inherent value ............................................................................... [167] If tracing was possible...................................................................................... [173] Fungibility and shortfall ................................................................................. [178] Certainty of subject of trust............................................................................... [178] The Nessock Transaction ................................................................................. [181]

Conclusion............................................................................................................ [186] Outcome ............................................................................................................... [187] Interest and Costs................................................................................................ [188]

Introduction

[1]      The first defendant, Ross Asset Management Ltd (in liquidation) (RAM), through   its  owner  and   director,   Mr Ross,   provided  discretionary  investment management services.  Mr Ross also owned the second defendant, Dagger Nominees Limited (Dagger).  Dagger’s intended role was to act as a nominee/custodian to hold client   investments.      For   many   years,   those   services   appeared   to   produce outstandingly successful results for investors. As is now well known, however, for a considerable period of time Mr Ross had been defrauding investors and producing falsified  returns  (concealed  losses  and  fictitious  profits)  to  hide  that  fraud.    In late-2012 the fraud, a Ponzi-type scheme, unravelled.  RAM and Mr Ross ran out of cash to meet requests from investors to withdraw their funds.  The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) became involved.

[2]      The  High  Court  appointed  Messrs  John  Fisk  and  David  Bridgman  (the

Liquidators) as receivers (6 November 2012) and liquidators (17 December 2012).

[3]      This  is  an  application  by  Maurice  and  Nora  Priest  (the  Priests)  for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Priest v Ross Asset Management Limited (in liquidation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1803
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Priest v Ross Asset Management Limited (in liquidation) revolves around the ownership of shares, known as the Priest Holdings, held by RAM and Dagger, companies managed by Mr Ross. The Priests, Maurice and Nora, claim that these shares are held on a bare trust for them, and thus should not be part of the assets available for distribution to other investors, referred to as the Other Investors, who were victims of Mr Ross's Ponzi scheme. The Liquidators, appointed to manage the affairs of RAM and Dagger, argue that the shares should be shared pro rata among all investors. The court's decision hinged on the legal principles of tracing, equitable ownership, and the nature of the shares as intangible, fungible property. The court found in favour of the Priests, ruling that the shares were indeed held on a bare trust for them and not subject to distribution to the Other Investors. The court's decision was based on the clear contractual arrangement between the Priests and Mr Ross, the payment made by the Priests for the shares, and the lack of any valid tracing claim by the Other Investors. The court also addressed issues of fungibility and the certainty of the subject of the trust, concluding that the shares could be identified as belonging to the Priests. The outcome was that the Priests were granted the declarations and orders they sought, affirming their ownership of the Priest Holdings.