Prestige Building Removals Limited v Vogel

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-419-000209

[2023] NZHC 359

UNDER Arbitration Act 1996

IN THE MATTER OF

An application for leave to appeal award

BETWEEN

PRESTIGE BUILDING REMOVALS LIMITED

Applicant

AND

SHELLEY LYNN VOGEL and BRET VOGEL

Respondents

Hearing: 7 February 2023

Appearances:

R A Weir for Applicant

A C N Fuiava for Respondents

Judgment:

1 March 2023


JUDGMENT OF ANDREW J


This judgment was delivered by Justice Andrew on 1 March 2023 at 4.30 pm

pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 2016 Registrar / Deputy Registrar Date………………………….

PRESTIGE BUILDING REMOVALS LTD v VOGEL [2023] NZHC 359 [1 March 2023]

Introduction

[1]    The applicant, Prestige Building Removals Ltd,1 is a specialist building relocator. Prestige entered into a contract with the respondents, the Vogels, to relocate for them a transportable home.

[2]    The parties had a dispute about their  contract.  At issue was whether under  cl 15 of the agreement the Vogels had provided “proper access” to the site. The relocation involved transporting the house across adjacent third-party private land, namely the Maraetai forest. Prestige maintains that “proper access” required the Vogels to obtain permission from the owners of the forest.

[3]    The contract contained an arbitration clause, and the parties attended a three- day arbitration in June 2022 before an arbitrator, Mr David O’Neill, barrister. Mr O’Neill held2 that the Vogels were successful in their claim and granted them an award of $163,012.88, together with costs and disbursements of $75,140.64.3

[4]    Prestige now makes application under cl 5(1)(c) of Schedule 2 of the Arbitration Act 1996 for leave to appeal Mr O’Neill’s award on the grounds of material error of law. Prestige says that Mr O’Neill did not correctly interpret the meaning of “proper access” under cl 15 of the agreement; he failed to address the critical requirement of permission of the owners of the forestry land.

[5]    The critical issue I must determine is whether there is an arguable error of law or whether the dispute is really one of fact.

Factual background

[6]    In January 2021, the Vogels purchased a section in Coromandel township with a view to relocating a house onto that site.

[7]    The Vogels live next door to the Gullivers on Rewa Road, Maraetai. The Gullivers and the Vogels agreed that the Vogels would remove the Gullivers’ house


1      Prestige.

2      Judgment dated 28 June 2022.

3      Interest on this sum is to accrue from 11 June 2021.

and relocate it to Coromandel. They entered into a deed of gift dated 16 March 2021. The deed of gift provided that the Vogels would be responsible for removing and transporting the house.

[8]    The two properties on Rewa Road are sited on steep sections sloping down towards the Maraetai forest. The forest behind the two properties is owned by Whitford Forest Holding Company Ltd.4

[9]    Mr Gulliver and Mrs Vogel were both members of the Pohutakawa Coast Bike Club Incorporated.5…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prestige Building Removals Limited v Vogel and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 359
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Prestige Building Removals Limited sought leave to appeal an arbitral award made by Mr David O’Neill against the Vogels, who had contracted with Prestige to relocate a transportable home. Prestige maintained that the Vogels had failed to provide “proper access” to the site as required by cl 15 of the agreement, which necessitated obtaining permission from the owners of the forest through which the house would be transported. Mr O’Neill held that the Vogels were successful in their claim and awarded them $163,012.88, together with costs and disbursements of $75,140.64. Prestige now applies for leave to appeal Mr O’Neill’s award on the grounds of material error of law. Prestige contends that Mr O’Neill did not correctly interpret the meaning of “proper access” under cl 15 of the agreement; he failed to address the critical requirement of permission of the owners of the forestry land. The Court must determine whether there is an arguable error of law or whether the dispute is really one of fact.

The Court found that Mr O’Neill had expressly addressed the question of whether the owners of the forestry land, namely Whitford Forest Holding, had given permission for the use of its land. Mr O’Neill concluded that the longstanding relationship between Whitford Forest Holding and the Pohutakawa Coast Bike Club Incorporated (PCBC) was governed by the licence agreement, and that PCBC was able to grant access to the property. Mr O’Neill found as a matter of fact that the Vogels had obtained the necessary consent and that this was confirmed by the witness, Mr Callum Wilson. The Court rejected Prestige’s argument that Mr O’Neill admitted hearsay evidence contrary to s 18 of the Evidence Act 2006. The Court noted that the arbitral tribunal has a broad discretion to conduct the proceedings and to deal with evidentiary matters as it considers appropriate. Furthermore, the Court rejected Prestige’s argument that the decision of Mr O’Neill on the question of proper access was perverse. The Court found that there is no arguable case that the decision of Mr O’Neill on the question of proper access was perverse. He had regard to all the evidence. He reached the conclusion that the Vogels did provide proper access and met their obligations under cl 15 of the agreement with Prestige.

The application for leave to appeal is declined. Prestige has not established an arguable error of law in the approach adopted by Mr O’Neill. The Court held that the respondents, the Vogels, are entitled to costs and disbursements, and on a 2B basis. If costs cannot be agreed, then memoranda (no more than three pages) are to be filed within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.