This case has been anonymized
IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CRI 2007-404-0032
NEW ZEALAND POLICE
Appellant
v
W
Respondent
Hearing: 28 May 2007
Appearances: N R Williams for the appellant
F P Hogan for the respondent
Judgment: 18 June 2007
JUDGMENT OF STEVENS J
Solicitors/Counsel:
Crown Solicitor, PO Box 2213, Auckland
F P Hogan, Dykes Road, Karaka, R D 1, Papakura
NZ POLICE V W HC AK CRI 2007-404-0032 18 June 2007
Table of Contents
Para No
Introduction [1] Factual background [6] Breath testing regime in the 1998 Act
The position in 1998 [17]
The position from 2001 [20] Elements of the offence [29] Reasonable compliance s 64(2)
Legal principles [35]
Appellant’s submissions [42] Respondent’s submissions [52] Discussion [55] Operation of s 64(4) [60] Appellant’s submissions [61] Respondent’s submissions [76] Discussion [78]
Result [85]
Introduction
[1] This is an appeal by way of case stated from a decision of Judge C S Blackie in the District Court at Manukau on 18 October 2006. In an oral decision given following a defended hearing, the Judge dismissed an information against Grant John W (the respondent) charging him with an offence against s 56(1) of the Land Transport Act 1998 (the Act) of driving a motor vehicle with excess breath alcohol.
[2] The Judge found that the evidence disclosed that three samples of breath were given by the respondent, but only two new mouthpieces were used by the enforcement officer contrary to the requirements of the Transport (Breath Tests) Notice (No 2) 1989 (the Notice). The Judge therefore had doubts as to the accuracy of the reading on the breath testing device, as the Notice requires that a new mouthpiece be inserted into the device each time a person blows into it. The Judge was not satisfied that all of the required steps had been carried out in accordance with the Notice. Hence, the respondent was entitled to the benefit of any doubt and the information was dismissed.
[3] The Judge agreed to state a case for determination by the High Court pursuant to the provisions of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957. Two questions
were posed in order to ascertain whether the decision was erroneous in point of law, namely:
a) Was the Judge correct in holding that the reasonable compliance provision in s 64(2) of the Act could not operate to cure the error he found in relation to the number of mouthpieces used in the evidential breath test?
b)Was the Judge correct in holding that, because he had a doubt as to the accuracy of the reading on the device, he should dismiss the information notwithstanding s 64(4) of the Act?
[4] The New Zealand Police (the appellant) submitted that the reasonable compliance provision, s 64(2) of the Act, operated to cure the error regarding the number of mouthpieces used by the enforcement officer. Additionally, the appellant submitted that s 64(4) of the Act prohibited the respondent from defending the charge on the basis of an alleged…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v W HC Auckland CRI 2007-404-32 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NZHC 1857
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court held that the reasonable compliance provision in s 64(2) of the Act could cure the error as the non-compliance was minor and there was no reasonable doubt that an ingredient of the charge had been proved. The Court found that the evidential breath test result was well above the required level of proof, and the non-compliance did not give rise to any injustice or unfairness in the circumstances of the case. Furthermore, the Court held that the failure of the enforcement officer to comply with the Notice fell within the wording of s 64(4)(a) of the Act, which prevents any defence based on the alleged error in the evidential breath test. Therefore, the High Court answered both questions for determination in the negative, allowing the appeal and remitting the matter to the District Court for the entry of a conviction and sentencing.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi